3 ms·
I've long held that Discord lacks an actual business model. This is the first time I could honestly say they have one, as the benefits of Nitro were a joke. Of
by ocdtrekkie 8y ago
I've long held that Discord lacks an actual business model. This is the first time I could honestly say they have one, as the benefits of Nitro were a joke.
Of course, it's interesting they chose a business model that nobody has ever succeeded at: Competing with Steam. You need exclusives to draw people to your game platform, and with that on PC comes "why can't I just get this on Steam?" Without something like a "Games Anywhere" offering sync, you'd also have to have people buy games anew on your platform.
- dbmikus 8y agoPeople can keep their old Steam games and still use Discord. That's what people have been doing since Discord came out (along with Epic Games, Blizzard, EA, etc.). I'm curious to see how the social stickiness of Discord will affect their foray into a games/app store. I believe that, for multiplayer games at least, people first fire up the way they want to talk with their friends and then set about playing a game. From there, you grow the product into managing and buying your games. If Discord provides some differentiated social benefits to the games bought through their store, then I could see this doing quite well.
- ocdtrekkie 8y agoWith Steam comes the achievements, the trading cards, etc. Sure, you can copy all of that, but the challenge is that Discord isn't fighting Steam on day one, they're fighting an established library. How do you convince someone with 99 games in Steam that their 100th should be bought through Discord instead? Sure, people can use Discord for chat while playing Steam games, but Discord really doesn't benefit from that. They need to convert chat users into game buyers, and I think you'd need something like Games Anywhere (or more simply, like GOG Connect), to bridge in what people already bought to start the process along. Bonus if you can find a way to bring over people's achievements and other progress.
- tapoxi 8y ago> How do you convince someone with 99 games in Steam that their 100th should be bought through Discord instead? You don't have to, there are always people just starting their library. The Discord client is already significantly better than Steam's (which is why its so popular for chat). I think people are pretty meh on Steam achievements since hacks to unlock them are pretty widespread, but Discord would need to provide other platform norms like cloud saves and DRM. I also think Microsoft should swoop in and buy Discord before it's too late. The Xbox brand and UWP need a shot in the arm, and a Discord purchase could finally get PC gamers using Xbox services.
- Macha 8y agoBecause that audience didn't collectively jump ship from the last service Microsoft bought _to_ discord. They also don't have a long lasting mistrust of Microsoft due to GFWL, the Xbone attempt to stop game sharing, umpteen "We really care about PC gaming this time, honest" promises, etc. Frankly, while programmers have benefited enough from new Microsoft that people are starting to give them a chance, gamers have not at this point a MS owned Discord would do more harm to Discord than good to MS. Users already see the Microsoft store as a flytrap to avoid, and any future Discord services would be tarred with the same brush.
- benatkin 8y agoDiscord has a pretty fancy emoji system called Emoji Magic, and a sophisticated user model (for moderation and such). So it's not like they're starting from scratch, either in terms of implementation or having a userbase that expects to find interesting stuff on the platform.
- drdaeman 8y ago> for multiplayer games at least, people first fire up the way they want to talk with their friends and then set about playing a game I believe it's the other way around. At the very least, it's the other way around for me and my friends. We decide we want to play something. Then we check whatever works for voice chat. Used to be Skype, then TeamSpeak 3, then Mumble, then Discord. When Discord had failed we've just brought back old TS3 server (and while I was doing it, we used in-game VoIP stuff, hardcore-mode).
- benatkin 8y agoDiscord is used like Slack, you don't arrange to meet on Discord before you meet on Discord, you just fire up Discord and see who's around or message someone. I'm sure some use it the way you describe but it doesn't seem like the most common usage pattern to me.
- gknoy 8y agoFor day-to-day use, sure. But, a common way that many teams/squads/groups/guilds move to Discord is that they find that _all of the random pick up groups_, or servers, etc, are having people use Discord (instead of Mumble or TS or Ventrilo..etc).
- Asooka 8y agoThey have curation, which is something Steam explicitly lacks, and that makes it pretty bad for discovering new games (or so people say - I've always had on-point recommendations from Steam). I honestly expected to read that Discord is partnering with Steam to allow you to buy games on Steam on their client while also curating the list of games you can buy. Though obviously that way they don't get the same share from each sell, but it would have simplified things a lot for them. They may not be able to build a better game store platform than Steam, but they might fit into building a better curated store.
- foepys 8y agoDoesn't Steam have a "Curators" section in their store for a few years now?
- pvg 8y agoThey have curation, which is something Steam explicitly lacks How do you figure? Steam has about a zillion curation, discovery and promotion mechanisms.
- s73v3r_ 8y agoYeah, but most of them are pretty meh.
- meheleventyone 8y agoThat’s kind of the problem in some ways. There is a whole bunch of user curated and algorithmic noise. It also requires a lot of work on the part of the user to refine the algorithmic recommendations. There’s definitely a place for the lowest common denominator store like Steam but I’d love more boutique curated stores as well.
- pvg 8y agoI don't understand how Steam is 'lowest common denominator'. You can pick your curators. Let's say discord comes up with some super-awesome curation. It can be trivially replicated as a curation channel on Steam. I doubt curation alone is what discord is really going for here, as a distinguishing feature.
- lathiat 8y agoThat reason specifically makes me excited about this as hopefully they'll make enough money to keep going. They are the best chat client around right now IMHO, beating out all the enterprise apps (slack, hipchat, etc) particularly if you want a fantastic client on all 3 OS.
- 013a 8y agoPlenty of companies have succeeded going against Steam. You have game developers like Blizzard, EA, and Epic who all have their own Steam-like platforms on PC where they distribute their titles. Arguably these platforms are more popular than Steam, if only because of the popularity of the titles they own. You have popular games that distribute outside of these platforms, like League of Legends and Guild Wars. And you have other studio-unassociated storefronts, like Humble Bundle, Twitch, GoG. Yes, I'm aware GoG is owned by CD Projekt Red, but it's a generic storefront not just for their games, and they distribute their games elsewhere, so it resembles Steam more than it does Battle.net. The PC gaming space is ridiculously diverse and there is room for competition. There's also a lot of value I can see arising here in the indie space; if Nitro becomes a "Netflix for Indie Games" type subscription, that's something relatively unique (Humble is close, but has a curation problem). Combine that with the huge curation and discovery problem Steam has, and possibly some strategic partnerships with Humble or CD Projekt Red, and it'd be a huge win for small developers and gamers alike.
- ocdtrekkie 8y agoI wouldn't consider any platforms distributing solely their own titles as a Steam competitor. Aka, Origin, Battle.net, etc. are not Steam competitors. GOG and Humble Bundle are Steam competitors, and I wouldn't argue either of them are on the same scale as Steam. And Discord needs to make a lot of money if they're going to pay back their investors.
- Macha 8y agoOrigin also has Ubisoft games (https://www.origin.com/irl/en-us/store/assassins-creed/assassins-creed-iii https://www.origin.com/irl/en-us/store/assassins-creed/assas... ), THQ Nordic games (https://www.origin.com/irl/en-us/store/darksiders/darksiders-iii#store-page-section-overview https://www.origin.com/irl/en-us/store/darksiders/darksiders...) and indie games (https://www.origin.com/irl/en-us/store/opus-magnum/opus-magnum https://www.origin.com/irl/en-us/store/opus-magnum/opus-magn...) though you wouldn't easily tell since the front page exclusively promotes their own games.
- chatmasta 8y ago> You need exclusives to draw people to your game platform No, you just need to draw people to your game platform. And Discord already has people on their game platform. Discord has the active attention of millions of gamers throughout the day. It's just not selling games yet. This is a horizontal integration play and a very smart one IMO. Before this move, Steam had game sales and weak social; Discord dominated social and no game sales. Now, Discord dominates social and will sell games, at least to some of their millions of customers. Social features are much more of a defensible "moat" because they depend on network effects and are difficult to "manufacture" relative to other features. In this sense, Discord has a massive head start on Steam. Discord only needs to catch Steam in terms of game sales, whereas Steam needs to catch Discord in terms of social.