11 ms·
I don't think that's how risk pools work in the first place. The idea is not to put people with similar levels of risk in the same pool. The idea is to make th
by klodolph 8y ago
I don't think that's how risk pools work in the first place.
The idea is not to put people with similar levels of risk in the same pool. The idea is to make the pool as large as possible, charge everyone for their expected cost + a margin, and then pay out everyone for their actual costs.
It's the law of large numbers at work here. Take the mean value of a large number of variables with high variance and you end up with a mean that has low variance.
Not only is it normal for people with condition X to be in the same pool as condition Y, but this is a good thing because the costs for people with condition X are less correlated with the costs for people with condition Y, and this reduces risk in the pool. For example, if you have a pool that only contains people with condition X, and then it turns out that a commonly used medication prescribed for condition X has horrible side effects, then that single problem is disastrous for the entire pool.
> Why should a profit-seeking insurance company insure me past some point when the data strongly indicates i'm going to need drastic and expensive intervention.
Because you pass laws that make it illegal for insurance companies to deny coverage on this basis, and then you turn around and pass laws to keep the pool healthy enough for insurance to still be profitable. Or you just nationalize it.
- throwawaymath 8y agoIsn't what you describe in the first three paragraphs of your comment the same system as what the person you're replying to outlined in their first paragraph? It seems to me like you stated you don't think the parent commenter's outline of risk pools is accurate, but then went on to describe the same system. How is it different? Both of you are talking about risk pools consisting of large groups of people with different risk profiles for different healthcare liabilities. The commenter you replied to seems to be talking about this concept breaking down as insurance companies increasingly slice risk pools down such that their profit depends less on understanding the mean and more on predicting the future. That being said, your last point sounds like a decent proposal for how to combat this problem. I'm not sure if it would work in practice, however, as healthcare legislation seems to be hotly contested on all sides.
- LeifCarrotson 8y ago> The idea is not to put people with similar levels of risk in the same pool. The idea is to make the pool as large as possible, charge everyone for their expected cost + a margin... As a consumer who is fortunate enough to get life insurance at the "Super Preferred" low-risk rate, I would prefer be in a small pool that excludes people with higher actual costs. That's an economic preference, not moral, though my morals are not bothered by using the system as designed. As long as insurance companies are free to offer plans that admit only really healthy people and exclude people with higher actual costs, my plan will be cheaper. Really healthy people will drop out of the larger pool and into the cheaper pool. The larger pool will, as a result, get more expensive. And the people remaining in what's effectively the shallow end of the pool will be offered a "Preferred" rate that's more expensive than super preferred but less than the large pool. Eventually you end up with small risk pools, with the least insurable, highest-risk and highest actual cost customers unable to buy affordable life insurance. If you're a 20-year-old obese diabetic who smokes and has a family history of cancer, and the actuarial table says there's a 50% chance that your 50-year $1M policy will have to pay out, your premiums before a margin are 1M * 50% / 50 / 12 = $833/month. That's not really affordable, even if it would be wise for our unhealthy friend if he or she has dependents. My super-preferred policy costs me $21.25/month. I empathize with the plight of the uninsurable. Given my voting history on health insurance issues, I would probably vote in favor of a law that limited segmentation and would bump my premiums to, say $50/mo and would offer life insurance to the $833/mo individual at the same rate. But I'm not going to jump from my pool into a more expensive pool by myself if that signal will fall on deaf ears.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Jedi72 8y ago"I sympathize with their problem but I won't disadvantage myself just to help them"