2 ms·
I don't know if I want to agree or not with the premise of this conversation thread. If everything about A is the same as B except for where it was made, shoul
by Groxx 16y ago
I don't know if I want to agree or not with the premise of this conversation thread.
If everything about A is the same as B except for where it was made, shouldn't A be allowed to label itself as belonging to the same category as B? Yes.
On the other hand, if this were allowed (and location were the only difference), the following is possible / likely:
Champagne becomes "Genuine Champagne Champagne". Or "official" champagne becomes a commercial entity, with a different name, and the category itself is left to go wherever it will. All we've done there is lose the specificity that Champagne had, as well as the ability for new wineries in Champagne to make Champagne (because now "official" champagne is a company's brand name), and for what gain?