3 ms·
I wonder what the reasoning behind this is. It seems that it would reduce the amount of content on Facebook. Perhaps the thought is that people will go and pos
by mrweasel 8y ago
I wonder what the reasoning behind this is. It seems that it would reduce the amount of content on Facebook.
Perhaps the thought is that people will go and post directly to Facebook instead? Or it could be a way of reducing noice/spam.
- ghaff 8y agoApparently it's part of further locking down their API (https://techcrunch.com/2018/08/01/psa-cross-posting-tweets-to-facebook-no-longer-works-as-of-today/ https://techcrunch.com/2018/08/01/psa-cross-posting-tweets-t...) so that random apps that have been given permission to post by default can no longer do so. The way I read it, people who deliberately want to cross-post tweets are essentially collateral damage.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoWhy couldn't they blanket-deauth all Facebook apps (or maybe just ones authed before this year, or sth.) instead? People would fix the apps they still use. And really, publishing apps on FB is not a real problem; apps exfiltrating data is.
- ceejayoz 8y agoApps exfiltrating is one problem. Bots posing as real people to rile up racial/political/etc. tensions is another, and this approach helps a bit there.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoThis won't help much. Evil Enemies of Freedom and US Way of Life will continue to hire low-paid workers in poor countries to post manually, with or without help of whatever Selenium/mbasic.facebook.com automation someone will promptly create.
- rhizome 8y agoYes, of course it can still be done manually, but that introduces magnitudes more friction to their operations. It's no longer "post once, publish everywhere" as far as FB is concerned.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoAgain, I don't think this kind of friction is meaningful for the purported targets - but it definitely is for everyone else.
- rhizome 8y agoWell I think it is. It may not eliminate the actors and thus not a perfect solution, but this isn't a calculus final and it's going to slow propagation by definition, which for me is a self-evident win.
- tripzilch 8y agoAnd conflating the two problems really doesn't help. Simply: Apps exfiltrating data can be prevented almost entirely using sane permissions, sufficient security, oh and not willingly turning a blind eye, helps. That is about read permissions and entirely not what this news is about. Bots and troll-armies posting to polarise and increase tensions, are indeed a write permission problem, and superficially appear to be what this news is about. Except that as long as humans can post on FB, so can troll armies and bots. This only takes away capability for the small to medium scale ease of use. Any determined adversary wouldn't have been using these capabilities anyway because it's too easy to detect as not organic. Surely the automated blackhat and/or psy-op bot farms use automated browsers, headless browsers, key macro scripts, or whatever to simulate an actual human user interacting at human speed--just 1000s in parallel. I mean it's not rocket science and as soon as you're running a slightly larger operation it pays to just do it properly right away. This news changes nothing for the bot farms on missions that had to fly below the radar already anyway.
- gm-conspiracy 8y agoThat would be the death of the platform.
- daveFNbuck 8y agoAssuming they just meant revoking the authorization to post, that's less extreme than permanently disabling the API endpoint for all apps.