4 ms·
I'm not going to say I can absolutely refute this paper but I can say that in my day job, which is an international not for profit in the Asia Pacific, with a s
by ggm 8y ago
I'm not going to say I can absolutely refute this paper but I can say that in my day job, which is an international not for profit in the Asia Pacific, with a strong Japanese sub presence I see collectivism and individualism, but I see a lot more collectivism. I'm told in the domestic equivalent circuit they fight like cats and dogs, but outside? It's a party line.
I also think there is a strong Confucianism element to things. Collectivism is a sister to respect for collective and hierarchical authority sometimes.
- smhost 8y agoA lot of Western people (especailly a certain brand of Americans) parrot this line of thought like it's the 19th century when in fact what they're perceiving is their own inability to understand another culture. The atom bomb and hollywood has had a stronger influence on contemporary japanese culture than Confucius, but there's always this constant need to regress to a differentiated past.
- ggm 8y agoI asked my colleagues who come from a range of Asian backgrounds and they tend to feel there is a resurgence of modern soft Confucianism. Obviously they could be chosing a trope to get out of the conversation too. I'm not American. I'm in Australia but working with a body that covers all 56 Asia Pacific economies with some national chapters. The Bhutanese are very very strong on ancestor and elder respect (for instance) So you tend to support the papers view?
- smhost 8y agoYeah, I've heard that there is some renewed interest in Confucianism which I think has to do with the global rise of fascist mythology, but for example it's still true that young Japanese are quickly losing interest in family values and traditional notions of responsiblities to society.
- have_faith 8y ago> young Japanese are quickly losing interest in family values and traditional notions of responsibilities to society I think this is common across the developing world. Contributing to declining birth rates "why put in effort to bolster members of my society?" and similar notions.
- mercurysmessage 8y agoMore educated people have always had less children.
- ameister14 8y agoThat's not true on an individual scale, only on a country average scale, and only post-industrialist. So basically, that's not true.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- mantas 8y agoMore like current Japanese economy makes it fucking hard to live out traditional Japanese family image. Life-long cushy salaryman jobs are sparse. Yet Japanese women who stick to the traditional image won't take up a dude working McJob. The only way save face (which is one of top priorities in Japan if not Asia) is to pretend you have no interest in that at all. There're quite a few young people living out the traditional Japanese dream though. Birth rates seem to be coming back up too. Possibly because Tokyo (where most young people are concentrated, the rest of the country is more or less dying) is slowly becoming child-friendly. More spacious housing for affordable (as that can be) prices, more public facilities for children and child care/schools seem to be getting cheaper.
- mercurysmessage 8y agoI don't know why people always focus on the birth rate in Japan. It's pretty standard to developed nations, and there are nations with a lower birth rate.
- reacweb 8y agoI know many japanese people (I am a go player) and I am very interested in this culture. When I have read the books of Amélie Nothomb, it was perfectly in line with my discussions with these people. The movie and book "Fear and Trembling" are excellent illustrations of Japaneese society. I have never seen japanesse people as collectivists. I do not understant why it would be a common view in America. AFAIK, it is not a common view in France.
- wodenokoto 8y agoIt is worth noting that there is a Søren Kirkegaard book, with the English title "Fear and Trembling", that has nothing to do with Japan. > I do not understant why it would be a common view in America. AFAIK, it is not a common view in France. Probably because it is a common view in Japan and just about everywhere else in the world.
- ekianjo 8y ago> a lot more collectivism I see it too but rather than just Confucianism I think that individuals are too clueless to drive anything on their own and end up leaving decisions and directions to "consensus" instead of relying on what they can do themselves. I rather blame education in Japan, which is absolutely terrible and actively destroys bright minds from an early age.