3 ms·
Aside from the whole echo chamber problem this wouldn't be granular enough. Imagine the perfect HN user, always giving well thought it, well reasoned and inform
by flukus 8y ago
Aside from the whole echo chamber problem this wouldn't be granular enough. Imagine the perfect HN user, always giving well thought it, well reasoned and informative posts and they usually only post about topic X which is their expertise. When they then post something not so well thought out about topic Y in which they are not well versed should their comment by at the top?
- dredmorbius 8y agoI'll freely admit that despite my considered screed above, it's often far simpler to merely downvote. HN mods are responsive to emailed notices of questionable (or flagrant) misbehaviour. Not always in agreement, though often so.