4 ms·
> I like systemd, it's a pity some vocal people aren't enthusiastic about it. To give some context as to why, for non-C++ developers systemd makes things very
by dijit 8y ago
> I like systemd, it's a pity some vocal people aren't enthusiastic about it.
To give some context as to why, for non-C++ developers systemd makes things very difficult to debug and understand in general.
Moreover the biggest issue /I/ personally have is the fact it was essentially forced on me by the mainstream distro maintainers.
When you discuss the merits and fallbacks of systemd it’s common for people to either try to discuss its merits only against sysvinit. Or they imply that issues that have affected me personally are not such a big deal and I should be quiet because: progress.
It’s a frustrating and exhausting position to be in. It’s like everyone shoving Windows registry on Linux down your throat, with all the opaque, obtuse and stifling qualities that would come with such a solution and telling you and your ilk to be quiet and suck it up.
Edit: I’m getting pounded by downvotes. But I guess offering any kind of other opinion about systemd for any reason isn’t met with kindness. However I can say this: neither google nor amazon use systemd to host AWS or GCP. At least consider why that is before you bury your head in the sand.
- LukeShu 8y agoSystemd is straight C, not C++.
- wokwokwok 8y agospins finger in the air the difference is immaterial and irrelevant in this context.
- lolc 8y agoA huge part of GNU/Linux is written in C. A small part is written in C++. I would accept the argument that C++ is less accessible than C to people maintaining Linux systems. Based on this alone I would say that yes, the difference is material and relevant.
- wokwokwok 8y agopish posh. It could be written in Egyptian and it would make no material difference to the ease of debugging for most people. The number of people who are C++ programmers and can deal with strace vs. C programmers who can deal with strace is really that significant? I don't buy it. The two groups intersect significantly. The point is that other people who are not C or C++ programmers have to deal with this kind of stuff from systemd. This is just pedantry for the sake of it. Systemd would be only marginally harder to debug if it was in C++ or heck, even rust, or go. No one is opening the source code here.
- Gibbon1 8y ago> C, not C++ The two wretched sisters.
- Uberphallus 8y ago> Uses UNIX-like OS > C/C++ bad
- Gibbon1 8y ago> writes C/C++ every day. > C is is stupid and breaks things > C++ has serious mental health issues
- josteink 8y ago> Moreover the biggest issue /I/ personally have is the fact it was essentially forced on me by the mainstream distro maintainers. So pretty much the same as any other decision distro maintainers make, if you disagree with it then.
- dijit 8y agoMost things can be replaced. Not systemd. Prefer postfix or exim over sendmail? Sure, completely replaceable. Prefer another cron system, Logging system. Prefer another /anything/ and it used to be possible to swap. Not any longer.
- cwyers 8y agoDistro maintainers didn't force you to do anything. They made a decision about how to allocate their limited resources. And we're past the days of Linux being a primarily volunteer OS, but a fair proportion of distro maintainers are still volunteers. They are not at your beck and call. If you want to have a Linux distro without systemd, there's several. If none of them meet your needs, pitch in with time or money to improve them. The purpose of free-as-in-libre software is that you can do the work yourself, not that you can expect others to do the work for you.
- dijit 8y agoFalse dichotomy. I pay redhat a lot of money, short of paying people full time to maintain a mirror distro of redhat without systemd, which would be impossible given how embedded it has become into everything. Some decisions cannot be unmade. Short of starting from scratch with gentoo (which is a Herculean effort at scale) I’m not sure what you’re saying. I cannot be disgruntled at choices because distro maintainers time is worth more than mine? Fair. But how many people have to be in my shoes for it not to be fair.
- Teknoman117 8y agoThe company I work for runs Gentoo at a global scale...
- dijit 8y agoThen you either make significantly more money than we do or are able to allocate resources to that project as it is key to your business strategy. The main focus of my company is to make Video games. Not maintain operating system distributions. That’s why we pay redhat so much.
- sparewalking 8y agoI think Gentoo scales very easy. Especially in enterprises. One thing I like about Gentoo that no other mainstream distro has is something like this https://packages.gentoo.org/packages/net-proxy/haproxy https://packages.gentoo.org/packages/net-proxy/haproxy. That page says that you can install any version of haproxy that suits you. You don't have to upgrade/downgrade the OS just because you need an older or newer piece of software. But, as always, no distro is perfect. Gentoo has its issues too.