4 ms·
Pittsburgh has this, too. A dedicated transitway from downtown to the airport. It was a pretty efficient ride when I used it about ten years ago. But at the sam
by reaperducer 8y ago
Pittsburgh has this, too. A dedicated transitway from downtown to the airport. It was a pretty efficient ride when I used it about ten years ago. But at the same time it seemed kind of wasteful.
- bobthepanda 8y agoA good functioning bus lane will feel very wasteful only if it's working as intended and the buses are free-flowing. The entire point is that the buses flow quickly past traffic; you could open up the lane to HOV or cars, but then traffic times would just degrade. https://la.streetsblog.org/2014/07/08/balancing-cars-cash-and-congestion-metro-silver-line-brt-in-the-express-lanes/ https://la.streetsblog.org/2014/07/08/balancing-cars-cash-an... > In May 2014, Streetsblog L.A. began to receive tips that Silver Line BRT service along the 110 Freeway was experiencing some problems. So many drivers were taking the toll lanes to the point where the mix of buses, carpools and paying drivers resulted in congestion. > In some cases, traffic in the express lanes was moving slower than the rest of the 10 Freeway. This congestion impacts all the busway users including buses, carpools, and toll-paying drivers.
- xeromal 8y agoThe tolls should be raised until a lower amount of cars are around
- mikeyouse 8y agoWhich is an efficient economic solution that basically ignores that we have a terrible public transit system and pervasive inequality which would result in the tolls being primarily on the backs of the poorest among us who travel the furthest to work in City centers to be paid the least.
- jlebar 8y agoSo use the surplus to lower taxes on poor folks? Like, you can't fight the laws of economics. We don't have to like them, but can't we work within them rather than coming up with economically inefficient solutions which are bad for everyone?
- bobthepanda 8y agoIf you read the article I linked, they raised the tolls and used the money to pay for more frequent bus services, and those bus services also ran faster due to the tolls decreasing congestion. So in the end it was pretty equitable given that higher tolls directly funded public transit improvements.
- Shivetya 8y agoWell many cities have implemented express lanes which raise and lower prices depending on traffic patterns. metro Atlanta has added them with a new reversible express lane; I believe it is elevated its entire length; coming online in a few months. the problem with any well designed road system is that the people who need it cannot guarantee their needs don't change. this is especially true where both parents work. where a residence might have had a good commute when bought changes in work location can upset the whole process.
- bobthepanda 8y agoOf course, you can't really beat the congestion offered by zero cars in your bus lane.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- kalleboo 8y agoIt may feel wasteful if you're used to seeing packed roads, but if you compare to the common alternative (a train track) it no longer seems so bad.
- isostatic 8y agoLook at a line of 60 cars with 1 person each, taking up quarter of a mile. One car every two seconds. Then look at a bus with 60 people taking up 20 yards. One bus a minute. Then look at a train 200 yards long with 1000 people every 3 minutes. Which is more wasteful?
- kalleboo 8y ago> One bus a minute The dedicated bus lane we're talking about here appears to have one bus every 30 minutes (GP said it was a line out to the airport). So it's natural to look at a dedicated road lane that sees two vehicles an hour and think "what a waste, would it really hurt to let some cars drive here too?". But nobody looks at a train track the same way since you're used to seeing train tracks without a bunch of traffic on them. And yet an extra lane is cheaper to build & maintain. So it's understandable to look at the dedicated lane and think that it's inefficient, when in really it isn't.
- jimktrains2 8y ago> The dedicated bus lane we're talking about here appears to have one bus every 30 minutes The West Busway doesn't go to the airport and has buses serving the communities it runs through ever few minutes.
- jimktrains2 8y ago> Pittsburgh has this, too. A dedicated transitway from downtown to the airport. This has never existed. I'm not even sure what you could be thinking off. The West Busway is an old rail-bed, but it only goes a short ways from the city and servers a couple of communities, after that the airport bus uses the highway.
- theandrewbailey 8y agoYes. The west busway ends around halfway between downtown and the airport. It ends just shy of I-79, and uses the parkway (I-376) for the rest. https://www.portauthority.org/rt/28x.pdf https://www.portauthority.org/rt/28x.pdf
- reaperducer 8y agoThis has never existed. I'm not even sure what you could be thinking off. I guess I’m having my first “senior moment.” I remember this quite vividly. I sure hope I’m not confusing it with another city. I used to keep pretty good expense records back then, so I should have a record of the fare. If not, where do I go to collect my Crazy Old Man badge?