5 ms·
A Comcast Security Flaw Exposed Millions of Customers’ Personal Information
- eric_b 8y agoThere was no mass exposure of sensitive data. Two paths existed for determined attackers to get the home address and possibly SSN for individually targeted accounts. The process was manual and would have been difficult to automate to compromise "millions" of accounts. Based on the details in the article, this sounds like something that needed to be fixed, but probably not even worth the time to write this article.
- meowface 8y agoStrongly disagree. This effectively granted anyone with basic HTTP knowledge the ability to dox anyone they interact with online, if that person is using Comcast. The attacker does not need to be "determined" at all; it's trivial to get someone's IP address (send them a link of any kind) and with this vulnerability, trivial to find most of their home address. In short, some asshole kid could send a SWAT team to your house just by knowing your IP address, with not many steps in between. The SSN last 4 digit bruteforcing is really bad, too. I'd say arguably not as bad, since it's not very hard to get most people's SSNs on black markets these days. This is not a breach, but these are two massive vulnerabilities and deserves many articles.
- btilly 8y agoThere is no shortage of asshole kids who use SWAT teams in exactly that way. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swatting#Injuries_or_deaths_due_to_swatting https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swatting#Injuries_or_deaths_du... for a list of some notable cases.
- meowface 8y agoAbsolutely, but this exposure made it much easier to do en masse, plus made it possible to dox targets who otherwise have good OPSEC and aren't easily identified.
- oh_sigh 8y agoThis wouldn't necessarily be about determined attackers. Maybe a crazy guy you were beefing with in an online game has your IP address, and from that could get your physical address.
- meowface 8y agoThe address exposure vulnerability is really, really bad. Just about anyone was able to impersonate another Comcast customer by sending their home IP address in the X-Forwarded-For header to Comcast's device activation page, and easily see a masked version of their address (first number of street number and partial street name; street name is trivial to figure out with IP geolocation, street number would need some trial and error). I wonder how many Comcast customers were doxed with this method before it was fixed.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- shawn 8y agoSo, at the risk of getting murdered for this sentiment: Who cares? So what if someone knows your address? I guess it's a bigger problem for celebrities or for those who are targeted. But even then, the police are there. Just call them. I'm trying to understand the other side of this.
- kaishiro 8y agoI'm actually with you to a degree - but on the flip side, should we expect repercussions for something like this? Should we just be ok with it? As an industry we tend to play it pretty fast and loose compared to other engineering disciplines.
- vvanders 8y ago> But even then, the police are there. Just call them. Uh, isn't that the exact problem? Once someone knows your address you're a voip call away from swatting.
- shawn 8y agoAh, yeah, I completely forgot about swatting. Good point. The sooner that problem gets solved, the better.
- 8y ago
- CaliforniaKarl 8y agoDoes US federal or California law mandate that breach notifications be sent by postal mail? If not, then I wouldn’t be surprised if Comcast sends any/all notifications to people’s Comcast email addresses. That’ll be a good way to bury the notification, since I doubt many people check or forward their Comcast email.
- lmkg 8y agoActual legal text on CA data breach law from the following link. Notification requirements are near the bottom, starting with the section labeled "(j) For purposes of this section, “notice” may be provided by one of the following methods:" https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection.xhtml?lawCode=CIV§ionNum=1798.82 https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySectio... Email notice is an option if meeting the restrictions listed in the Federal law linked below. I think the relevant part is section (c), with the major restriction being "affirmative consent." https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/15/7001 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/15/7001 Alternatively if the breach affects over half a million people, they can send notifications by email, but also have to plaster their homepage and send "Notification to major statewide media." The homepage banner would only affect people who pay electronically but not by autopay. There are ways to minimize the effect of news broadcast, e.g. send the press release at 4 o'clock on a Friday when no one watches the news. So, it's not quite as easy as you think but Comcast does have options to minimize the impact of notification.
- CaptSpify 8y agoTo be fair, I dont read physical mail from Comcast either. I'm constantly flooded with junkmail from them.
- bpchaps 8y agoAbout two years ago, I spoke with Comcast's CISO over the phone about a leak of a sysadmin's home directory. It included private keys, log files, configs, licensed binaries, splunk(!), etc etc. A week before, her staff told me that they were going to use the chance to offer me a bug as part of a non-existent bug bounty, which didn't (and doesn't) exist. She (paraphrased) told me that since it wasn't a "bug", it didn't deserve a bounty as part of a bug bounty program. She followed that dribble by saying that for them to implement a bug bounty program would be far too expensive because it would lead to them having to fix all of the security flaws at Comcast. No joke. Dear Comcast: put out a fucking bug bounty!
- Pinkertron 8y agoShocking such an upstanding company would let this happen /s
- Pinkertron 8y agoShocking such an upstanding company would allow this to happen /s
- Paul-ish 8y agoMeanwhile, DirectTV still requires SSN to sign up. Until something changes, (create a liability?) this will keep happening.
- confounded 8y agoIf you have an independent local ISP, use them! In SF both Monkey Brains and Sonic are excellent, pro-Net-Neutrality, pro-privacy ISPs who offer non-exploitative contracts for internet access which is unfiltered, blazingly fast, and incredibly cheap!
- woolvalley 8y agoWhen I brought up those two ISPs to coworkers, they said they experienced frequent enough outages. Do you use them? What has your experience been like?
- andrei_says_ 8y agoSee dslreports for up to date local isp speed and reliability records. http://www.dslreports.com/ http://www.dslreports.com/
- jdblair 8y agoSonic quality depends on the quality of the AT&T wiring to your home. At my old house in Oakland, Sonic meant 3mbit DSL because AT&T had not updated the old twisted pair. It meant I bailed and signed up for Comcast. My new place in San Jose has fiber to the premise, so I signed up for Sonic again. Good bandwidth, Rock solid service.
- medmunds 8y agoIn SF, at least, Sonic has started stringing their own fiber. But it’s not in every neighborhood yet, and even in places where they are installing fiber, some streets may be left dark, (Including, frustratingly, a big swath of Portrero Hill where the utility poles are “overloaded”.) If you’re in a larger building (15+ units), there are a couple of other fiber providers that may be an option, if building management is up for it. MonkeyBrains is a wireless ISP. I regularly get 25-40 Mbps from them (though they don’t guarantee that). I’ve had only occasional slowdowns and one outage lasting a few hours. (So, more reliable than Comcast had been, at least for me.) I’d heard rumors MonkeyBrains was planning some equipment upgrades that would let them deliver 60-80 Mbps, but no official announcement or timetable.
- D-Coder 8y agoCan we send Comcast a bowling ball? An undrilled one? I'd love to see how they fsck that up.
- sky_projektor 8y agoHahahaha!
- King-Aaron 8y agoI know shitposting is completely frowned upon here, but I can't help but have the image of that South Park comcast guy in my head right now. "Oh, you had your personal address and social security numbers stolen? Ooh that's too bad. "
- shawn 8y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rja7tCtxSN4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rja7tCtxSN4 It fits too well.
- crazy_monkey 8y agoThanks Comcast! You did it!
- ryanlol 8y agoThis exact same bug existed and was widely exploited 4-5 years ago.
- cptskippy 8y agoComcast leaks different bits of information in all sorts of ways. It would be relatively easy to combine the information they leak with public records to gain access to someone's account. This is just icing on the cake. You can identify addresses that are Comcast customers simply by going to their website and shopping for service. If you enter in the address of an existing customer, it tells you. You can cross reference this with open records like tax and voter registration to determine who lives their and potential phone numbers. You can confirm the owner of the account by using Comcast's bill pay without login feature. It allows you to specify a street address and telephone number to view/pay a bill. And based on the bill amount you might be able to determine which services they're subscribed to. If the person is renting equipment then they'll be broadcasting a hotspot that other customers can log into and use unless they're savvy enough to disable it. That could be used to determine their IP address. Those are just the ones I know about off the top of my head. I'm sure there are many more.