6 ms·
The pfSense Book
- KiDD 8y agoWell Worth It!
- StudentStuff 8y agoPFSense was nothing but a failure for me. Installing it at multiple clients caused me to have nightmarish drives to fix simple issues (PFSense would refuse to boot if the 2nd WAN port was down, decide it had an Intel NIC and take hours to boot, get wedged, etc). The real kick in the pants was when they killed UDP multicast forwarding with no warning when upgrading, just boom, IPTV no longer works! We moved to Lede, which has been extremely fault tolerant. I no longer worry that I won't be able to remotely fix a router just cause it had a minor hardware issue.
- travbrack 8y agoWhat's your hardware story?
- StudentStuff 8y agoWe had a few netgate boxes, but ran into RAM dying on two of 'em, which would cause them to get wedged iirc (Never ran into wedging outside Netgate boxes). On that particular model the ram was soldered down, making it a nightmare to repair. On the custom boxes we put in later, it was less hardware issues and much more LTE modem failure (where the LTE modem needed a reboot and wasn't offering a USB ethernet interface, causing PFSense to halt and catch fire). Today we're split between Ubiquiti's UniFi for our earlier rollouts after dumping PFSense, and Lede for the latter ones as the remote, centralized manageability of both is a huge leap forward from what PFSense ever offered us. I can pull live stats, configure VLANs and implement them remotely and much more.
- vvanders 8y agoI looked at pfsense before going with Ubitquti/UniFi. Have to say I'm really happy with it, breeze to setup and does 99% if what you want to do out of the box.
- StudentStuff 8y agoThe UniFi suite has some rough edges, the Unifi Security Gateways will just sit there in a useless state if both WANs are down and they are rebooted (until one of the WANs comes up and they connect to the controller). That is a less common scenario, but its still annoying & breaks the local network. Better to run in a crippled state than not at all IMO!
- Whitestrake 8y agoIf the blocking issue is a startup connection to its controller, could this be mitigated by having a local controller?
- tjoff 8y agoOuch, that is bad. I guess that will happen pretty much every time there is an power outage. If internet hasn't recovered all local devices will boot up and not even get an IP?
- StudentStuff 8y agoNa, the Cable/DSL modems and LTE Modems we spec out usually come online a bit before the USG. Ubiquiti's USG and USG Pro take a solid minute to boot, much longer than the modems take. That was another nice feature of Lede, it is booted and ready in well under a minute.
- tjoff 8y agoThat assumes that internet is working and that all the gear on the way also have had time to boot. That is very much not guaranteed. And if you ever have an internet outage this is probably a likely time to have it. I also realized that we probably don't have this problem. The controller is in a VM that is pretty much only booted when we need to edit something. So most of the time there won't be any controller to talk to during boot.
- berti 8y agoYou also gain extra hardware and protocol support by going to a Linux based solution e.g. BSD does not support 6LoWPAN or any IEEE 802.15.5 hardware to my knowledge.
- StudentStuff 8y agoThere are lots of packages that just don't get maintained on BSD, when it comes to gigabit or less routers the whole market for consumer and small/medium business is based on customized versions of OpenWRT from the large router vendors. The depth of maintained packages and documentation is significantly larger.
- stock_toaster 8y agoI love FreeBSD, but as a routing platform, VyOS/EdgeOS are pretty nice.
- Fnoord 8y agoThere's also Router7 recently shown on HN: "Show HN: Router7 – A pure-Go implementation of a small home internet router" [1] PC Engines APU2 [2] is a good hardware platform, and then there's the more expensive but complete Turris Omnia / Turris Mox. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17530086 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17530086 [2] http://www.pcengines.ch/apu2.htm http://www.pcengines.ch/apu2.htm
- gonzo 8y agorouter7 is really cool.
- mrmondo 8y agoA great resource for an excellently flexible and rock-solid reliable platform. Have been running pfsense and pfsense clusters for many, many years and had practically nothing but ultra-reliable success stories.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y ago> rock-solid reliable platform Eh... I've had a lot of issues with it on my flakey Charter internet[0] connection. Php-fpm hangs so often I added a cron job to restart it every fifteen minutes, it doesn't always run dhclient when an interface has been down for a bit and then comes back up (cron to the rescue again), the gateway monitor did weird and stupid things and had to be disabled, services aren't always restarted when they crash (Unbound recently) stuff like that. [0] I am aware that this combination of words is redundant.
- willejs 8y agoWhat hardware are you running pfsense on?
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y agoSome overpowered former thin client. It isn't likely to be the hardware, which can run Windows 7 comfortably.
- mrmondo 8y ago‘Windows 7’... doesn’t mean much to be honest, if that OS didn’t corrupt its filesystem it’d crap out on its poor kernel or registry design and regardless why would you run a presumably important routing system on the same hardware you thought was suitable for ‘Windows 7’ (rhetorical).
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y agoHigh end routers made for enterprises run on significantly fewer resources than Windows 7 requires. If pfSense can't manage on this hardware then it is exceptionally bloated for its job.
- Bucephalus355 8y agoAnyone used the commercial firewall / IP list you can slap on top of pfSense? There is the community version, but then there is also this: https://www.proofpoint.com/us/threat-insight/et-pro-ruleset https://www.proofpoint.com/us/threat-insight/et-pro-ruleset My understanding is it’s around $900 or so a year for a license. That kind of sucks. But on the other hand I know it’s very easy to install, just a one-liner in the GUI of pfSense (which is how I found out about it).
- 56chan4 8y agoCommunity version is 30day old or behind the paid version. Problem with alot of IDS/IPS is it needs to see the contents of the packets before it can block, unless it breaks the encryption its not going to work. So its not a panacea but then nothing is, and its hard to tell if this is already provided by AV products with web browser addons. If you take Kaspersky, they are the only AV product which uses CPU virtualisation to scan for malware running in memory on a windows box for their Safe Money web browser facility. CPU virtualisation is one of those areas that can bypass alot of security products, so if you can stack up enough zero days to get into an OS and mod a bios, you can hide for a long time. Single core CPU's also have their uses as well, but you dont see that mentioned much either in the security arena.
- late2part 8y agoUse it in prod. 10gbps throughput on egress NAT on commodity x86 hw. 5 stars would recommend.
- pmorici 8y agoAnyone had experience using this to setup up an ipsec VPN? I am looking for something that can do ipsec at 10Gbps which seems like it should be possible with an x86 processor that supports AES-NI but a lot of anecdotal benchmarks I've seen on randon websites seem to suggest it is difficult to achieve.
- godzillabrennus 8y agoYMMV with Pfsense. I've been using it since Scott and Chris were in Kentucky working on it together... that'll date me for sure... Anyway, I found that unless someone else has already done it and proven the hardware can handle it then it's all an experiment you conduct on your own dime. FYI - Netgate, the parent company of PFSense, went after OPNSense by scooping their domain and used it to spread FUD. Just dirty stuff. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/OPNsense https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/OPNsense
- gonzo 8y ago> YMMV with Pfsense. I've been using it since Scott and Chris were in Kentucky working on it together... that'll date me for sure... You've been "using" it. We've been directly supporting it (and before it, m0n0wall) with cash on the barrel every month since before it was first released (Oct 2006). In Sep 2012, we bought out Scott, and started investing even more heavily in pfSense development.
- godzillabrennus 8y agoI also “paid” for netgate hardware and recommended to many companies that they buy it. So in essence I helped you invest in the pfsense development. What you did was still dirty.
- brynx97 8y agoThey have a new product called TNSR that looks like it can do this.
- 8y ago