4 ms·
> My friends/social network are going to suggest cool stuff to read, not some startup's bot reading by browsing history. Isn't that how we ended up with Facebo
by acdha 8y ago
> My friends/social network are going to suggest cool stuff to read, not some startup's bot reading by browsing history.
Isn't that how we ended up with Facebook's ad targeting algorithms controlling most people's web experience? Running a cheap experiment testing how alternatives might work seems like important if you care about not having network effects giving a couple of companies significant control over the web.
> Chrome (and siblings) … and have significantly better performance.
That was never generally true and it really hasn't been accurate for the last year or two, where performance has been very competitive depending on what you're measuring.
- JetSpiegel 8y agoWhy are Laserlike's ad targeting algorithms better than Facebook? The alternative to Facebook is not a smaller younger Facebook, it's open protocols. If you want to send all your browser history into a black box and get recomendations on what to read use Chrome.
- acdha 8y agoThink about what you're describing: if the goal is to offer a new UI feature and see how users react, do you a) spend years standardizing a new protocol or b) use a single source to try it immediately while you independently explore the long-term options?
- JetSpiegel 8y agoThe goal of that private company is take history data, aggregate it and sell it to the highest bidder. The "recommendations" are ads. Ads are not "features", so they will never be protocols. Otherwise they would be a news aggregator, and so competing with Huffington Post or the zillion others.
- tapoxi 8y ago> Isn't that how we ended up with Facebook's ad targeting algorithms controlling most people's web experience? Running a cheap experiment testing how alternatives might work seems like important if you care about not having network effects giving a couple of companies significant control over the web. A social network doesn't mean Facebook. It could be an open platform like RSS or Mastodon (the latter I think is more closely aligned with Mozilla's mission, and could use the funding). Friends sharing content with me typically do so over Slack or Discord. I don't know how many people could be convinced to use an app that will algorithmically find something cool if you let it watch what you do all day. That's creepy and the value generated is pretty minimal. > That was never generally true and it really hasn't been accurate for the last year or two, where performance has been very competitive depending on what you're measuring. In my case, performance has been slow/stuttery on macOS to the point where I keep actively trying to use it, even enabling WebRender, and falling back to Chrome or Safari. I've also noticed the performance issues on Android. It seems fine on Windows, but not noticeably faster than Chrome or Edge.