13 ms·
Forget money. As a musician I struggle to even get people to listen to my music for free. There's an absolute glut of content out there, due to two things: 1
by pmoriarty 8y ago
Forget money. As a musician I struggle to even get people to listen to my music for free.
There's an absolute glut of content out there, due to two things:
1 - The increasing ease of making music. It used to be that you had to invest time in acquiring some skill, some relatively expensive instruments, and some in-person relationships with other musicians to make music that was palatable to a significant number of listeners. Today all you need is some free software on a phone or computer you probably already have, and it all but makes the music for you.
2 - The ease of distributing music. You used to have to get contracts with record labels, make other connections with the music industry, or spend a lot of money to get much of an audience. Now we've mostly cut out the middle men, and distribution is virtually free.
As a result there's vastly more content and much more competition between artists for an audience. No longer are consumers limited to a dozen radio stations or having to read music reviews, physically go down to the record store, listen to and buy records. The consumer has virtually the world's entire musical output at their fingertips and far more free content than they even have time to listen to.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- 21 8y agoI think this is a good thing. Only the strongest content will push through. Before, if someone signed you, you were pretty much guaranteed some form of success. I don't think that virality being required is a problem, all the songs I still listen from 20 years ago, and which are still played, I loved the first second I've heard and I would have shared them back then.
- tjoff 8y ago> Only the strongest content will push through. I think it has surprisingly little about content but with marketing and connections. I feel it is especially apparent on youtube where crappy content can thrive and excellent content can be buried where only a handful will see it. Not terribly different from the old days.
- vinceguidry 8y agoThere's a few filters to wrap your head around here. First there's the "has this person any real understanding of how to make music?" Probably 80% of music released is just plain bad music, no craft whatsoever. One person whose videos I watched a lot of, Mat4yo, dives a lot into the craft of composition, at least as it pertains to rap lyrics. It's where he starts giving feedback to other creators who send him their stuff where you really get a sense for what is good and what isn't good, and it's definitely a legible process. Problem is, once you get over bad, once you've followed the rules that everyone else has followed, is where marketing and connections start to make a difference. But still, nobody's really going to care until and unless you can come up with something truly different that's also good. Bring an idea to a style from another style and make it cohesive. Play around with different types of lyrics and beats and energy levels. I have a friend of mine whose been playing music for years put out an album of well, aggressively mediocre country-rock. No amount of connections and marketing is going to get anyone to care about it. There wasn't anything wrong with it, I just had zero interest in listening to it more than once. He needed to bring an order of magnitude more effort to the composition process to even come close to mildly interesting. This stuff literally fills the slush piles of music agents. Once you have something new, good, and different, then marketing and connections again start to become important. Because there's literally nothing else that can move the needle.
- 21 8y agoYeah, people forget or don't know how one of the last albums Michael Jackson did was a total flop despite marketing budget in the tens of millions. Marketing helps, but it doesn't make you.
- joanofarf 8y ago>I don't think that virality being required is a problem Look what that has done to "Online Content-with-a-capital-C" at large. If you launched an ad-supported website today and wanted to make any real kind of money from it, how many page views would you need? And how would that number impact the type of content you created for that site?
- dspig 8y ago> Before, if someone signed you, you were pretty much guaranteed some form of success Well, an advance and a good time, but most ended up not recouping [1]. [1] https://www.negativland.com/news/?page_id=17 https://www.negativland.com/news/?page_id=17
- pmoriarty 8y ago"I think this is a good thing. Only the strongest content will push through." Not necessarily. I think my content is good, but if few to no people hear it, much less pay me for it, I don't have much incentive to continue making it. Or if I make it, I rarely bother to release it anymore. I just make it for myself, and no one hears it but me. It's just not worth my time to go to all the trouble of editing and mixing it, releasing it, making cover art, thinking of titles, uploading it, and maybe trying to get listeners for it if almost no one will ever hear it. I think a lot of other musicians are in the same boat. We can't afford to make music for a living, so have to do it as a hobby, and if we struggle to get listeners even the hobby might not be rewarding enough to pursue in the long run. Lots of good content can get buried in the avalanche of trash. It might eventually get "discovered", but that's far from certain. It might not happen in the artist's lifetime or at all. There's still a lot of room for improvement in the field of content discovery.
- pram 8y agoIve noticed a lot of people who don’t spend time on creative hobbies usually think you should just do a thing because you enjoy it, and not for external validation. While that’s a good sounding platitude, they really haven’t experienced how crushingly depressing it is to have your work ignored and unappreciated.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- bsaul 8y agoYou forgot a third thing : the absolute total lack of originality in any kind of music aimed at the general audience, from folk to pop to rap or even techno. It's just complete garbage and the good things are just copies of what was done 30 years ago. If you keep giving people the thing they've already heard and known, because you're afraid you'll make less download if you try something new, then you'll reach "local optimimum" in all genres. Soon it will be all computer generated, and what we call "music composer" will finally be left to the people actually trying to compose something original. You know, like real artists.
- 21 8y agoYou forget that "the good things from 30 years ago" were also called garbage when they appeared (mostly by parents). It's the never ending story, old people calling youngsters music garbage.
- nostromo 8y agoI certainly don't think current music is garbage. But I do think innovation has slowed. If you compare music from 1960, 1980, 2000, and now (almost 2020) you'll notice that the 60's to 80's to 00's were incredibly different. Like, they clearly come from distinct eras. While there is still innovation, there aren't dramatic changes happening as often in the past two decades. There are many popular songs today that could have been popular in 00's and vice versa. Some rap seems to still be innovating, but rock, pop, and a lot of electronic music seems to be stuck in a rut.
- 21 8y ago> If you compare music from 1960, 1980, 2000, and now (almost 2020) you'll notice that the 60's to 80's to 00's were incredibly different. Like, they clearly come from distinct eras. Wasn't that maybe because of the incredible evolution of music hardware? 70s music was IMPOSSIBLE to produce in the 60s, 80s music in the 70s, so on. Today that hardware evolution is slowing down, so it's normal that the sounds don't change that much. But neural networks are on the horizon, expect shocking things in a few years.
- quickthrower2 8y agos/music/code/g s/listen/use/g s/content/projects/g etc. and it's all true :-)
- mooreds 8y agoA bit different though because you use code and you consume music. So code is a bit more active in terms of interaction. This leads to the GI Joe phenomenon: https://www.drud.com/ddev-local/the-website-rfp-the-impossible-to-estimate-g-i-joe-line-item/ https://www.drud.com/ddev-local/the-website-rfp-the-impossib... "features are cheap and details are expensive". Music is all features, code is a mix.
- quickthrower2 8y agoMy point is more that years ago you could thing "I'll make a windows utility to solve this problem" and you could probably charge for it. Now there will be an open source thing that is pretty good quality that will do it for free. You can still sell your solution but that's really a marketing exercise, finding people who don't know about the free solution (or want support) but the code itself isn't worth much. The music analogy would be you might pay $10 to see a local band live if they advertised well, but there is probably a lot of hustle in that, but you might not go around paying $10 for music cds anymore. Not with spotify, youtube, etc.
- ghaff 8y agoThis is generally true of many types of content. A lot of the technical obstacles to taking technically-solid photos and videos have been removed and the barriers to making them available to everyone are essentially non-existent. Writing hasn't been made easier to the same degree (although research is easier in many cases) but you no longer need to get a publisher to sign on--although there are some advantages to doing so. And it's very hard to make money off of doing those things unless they're in support of some other commercial activity.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- johnvanommen 8y agoI think this has also contributed to the homogenization of music. You would think the opposite would happen - with so many music options, wouldn't the options have a wider variety? But here's why this isn't the case: Twenty five years ago, CDs were expensive. Because they were expensive, listeners were compelled to listen to them over and over and over again. Remember buying two CDs for $40 and playing them endlessly? But in 2018, music is basically free. And because it's free, nobody has a vested interest in investing a lot of time getting to "know" an album. So you wind up where we're at now: a lot of music that sounds alike, plus a ton of music that's derivative of music from 30 or 40 years ago.
- sonnyblarney 8y agoIt's a good point, but I don't think it's 'price'. Music is 'homogenized' for the same reason products are: labels are making 'lowest common denominator' for the same reason 'Transformers' has no plot whatsoever. Radio and Google searches, 'hype' are ironically more commercialized than ever before, ergo, music is more 'product'. There is actually 'more diversity' in music - but you have to actually expend a little bit of effort to find it. An I mean 'just a little bit' i.e. a search on iTunes or whatever. Most people do not consume music that way - they just don't care that much. They accept what's on the radio, or what their friends tell them and esp. for younger folks, they are influenced by marketers trends. Consider the parallel: there are more 'web sites' than ever before, and the web is far more diverse - yet - our time is more and more focused on a smaller subset of places i.e. FB, Amazon. A couple of nuanced things: 'Making music' is easier than ever, and what is considered 'music' is more broad - so anyone can spend a few minutes using off-the-shelf software to make a few interesting sounds and voila. Eddie Van Halen spent a decade nerding out in his basement practicing to develop his talent - now - you don't have to like Van Halen, but if you actually listen, you can respect the talent. 'Talent' is no longer necessary - so this is a problem. It completely blows me away that a lot of shows now are simply Kareoke - young guys were rapping over an mp3. Not very exciting to me, but even worse ... I saw something with 'Chief Keef' recently and he's not even rapping over a 'backing track' - he's literally just playing is regular release track and then drunk/high mumbling over top of the track. He stumbles around on stage with his buddies, and each of them mumble a few lines over top now and then. Which brings me to 2cnd nuanced point: it's not about the music (maybe it never was) it's about the fame. Kanye West and Kim Kardashian are in the same business. One is more lyrical than the other. (FYI I think they are both geniuses in different ways, and I don't care for either of their fare but they are brilliant nonetheless). It's about creating a 'meme' - and wether it's instagram, or bits of acting, or 'music' or appearances, whatever - it's the same thing. It's almost impossible these days for a pop artist to be huge without having a very visual aspect. Taylor Swift's Instagram is at least as important as her albums. Her shows are massively produced spectacles. She and Beyonce are better described as pop-figure entertainers ... with a lot of music in the mix. So the focus on pop-culture, and the visual aspect, has truly and fundamentally altered things. Maybe some of you are old enough to remember: 'Video Killed the Radio Star' - since the social media revolution, this is further blown up. I love all genres of music - but every genre has been blown up with really low grade stuff, almost written by a computer and you can hear it. Obviously EDM is worse than others because of the nature of the 'E' of course, but it's bad. Final nuance: a great deal of the 'art' has shifted from classical musical paradigms, into the Engineering. So now, the 'producer' is in a way the 'chief artist'. We saw this in the late 20th century when U2 got popular. Brian Eno and Daniel Lanlois were producers on their huge hits - and you can clearly hear their impact. They were 'part of the band' in Bono's words. Radiohead has used the same Engineering guy forever and he's definitely a key ingredient in their secret sauce. Max Martin writes 100% of Katy Perry and other's hits and he, together with Dr. Luke basically own the hot-100 of known entities. And of course ... in the early 20th century if you wanted to hear music, someone had to play it really. You needed a full orchestra for good music. When the 5-piece rock and roll band came along 90% of horn players had to get other jobs. When Ableton/Steinberg/GarageBand came along ... well, you don't need any musicians at all to make music. Clearly there's a lot of intelligence even in the most mundane pop music, just as it's not actually easy to make 'Transformers' films, but the artistry is more focused on production than art ... and with so much 'noise' in the long-tail, it's exceedingly difficult for decent talent to break through. I was never a fan of Van Halen, but I happed to see them in an Arena concert several years ago and it was absolutely amazing. The music seems 'passe' and cheezy on the radio, but live ... it's basically exhilarating. They are the definition of 'Stadium Rock' and enormously talented. Imagine Dragon's doesn't hold a candle to them it would almost be comical listening to them side by side live. Edit: should not that the biggest money makers are the 'established brand' live acts, like 'Journey' and 'Bruce Springsteen' are making zillions more money than ever in 2018, 30 years after the fact - i.e. 'new artists' now have to compete with massive bands that are still truckin'. Check Billboard 200 album list, towards the middle you find: Nirvana's 'nevermind', Metallica 'black' and Guns n Roses 'apetite for destruction' on the chart for like the last 6 years (!) and might be for another decade (!) so 'new artists' literally have to outsell 20 year old Metallica albums to get listed. Rough!
- EvilEndures 8y agoDo you happen to make music that would fall under the Electornica umbrella? Mainly just curious because I'm looking for new, free music in that genre. ;)
- paul7986 8y agoYour either not that good, decent, pretty good or the best of the best. I graduated from MTSU with a degree in Recording Industry. My favorite class was songwriting class where we were paired up with classmates to write songs for a grade. There was this one guy whoever knew he was the best in the class and he was. He went onto write tons of number one country songs from 2007 to 2016. Even being the best of the best didnt get him to that point rather meeting the right connection as my college g/f was just as good as him or better. She's a homemaker now. Myself, I might be a decent songwriter, but Im a terrible singer. I get joy from others listening to my songs and say ing something nice lol. Overall it's always been hard and if your not the best of the best or know the right person then well......
- ataturk 8y agoThis sounds sad, but I'm not sure how I really feel about it. I went to college with a lot of Music Industry major types in the mid '90s and I thought most of them were kidding themselves about their real prospects even back then. It just seemed way over-saturated from the outside looking in, everyone had a big ego and wanted to be a baller. Wasn't going to happen. Not that I don't sympathize completely because I love music, too. Most recently, I worked with a business analyst guy who was living in Nashville trying to get work by filling in for sick musicians and thereby making a name for himself. It was going, eh, okay for him. He still kept his day job, of course. The company I worked for back then had let him move to Nashville and work 100% remote. He was on point with a guitar and banjo, I'll say that.
- ksec 8y agoIt is a little hard in these days and age where talents went unnoticed if you actually tried. And by talent I don't mean just being good or very good. You have to be the best, not just in your class, your state, but in your country or even the world. Now if you are only very good, ( which in itself is great, you could be the top 5% in the industry, or even top 1% ) you will need some connection and luck. The problem is there are only finite amount of popular song writer writing for best music. And that space is likely to be limited to a double digit personnel. It is like Formula 1, there are only a handful of drivers in Formula 1, but they represent the best of the best in the world. You don't want a centimetre off Apex, you want them to be in millimetres. These best of the best may only be 4 - 10 faster even on the same cars, but you could spend the rest of your life time never be as fast and as consistent as they are.
- swiley 8y ago>some relatively expensive instruments I wouldn't think of guitars as relatively expensive. In fact, most instruments can be had for fairly cheap if you're not super picky. I own a decent violin that I got from a pawn shop for $60.
- WhompingWindows 8y agoThe best way is to just play live music. That was the way it was for hundreds of years in music, and still the best musical experiences occur in live performances. I've been an amateur musician for 20 years. I would never try to make a living out of it, it's so much of a craps shoot trying to get people to listen and focus on your music online. The best way is to simply go in front of them and make their eardrums resonant with your instrument directly. You may need another career to support this live-only lifestyle, but what's the point of dumping 100's of hours and $1000's in capital into a recording barely anyone will listen to?
- fipple 8y agoI am a serious listener to and creator of music and I HATE live music. I can’t hear the subtleties as well, and I can’t put my best performance forwards. The only exception for me is chamber music.
- thirdsun 8y agoSame here. Plus, location is a very limiting factor when it comes to musical selection. There aren't many artists in my collection I could have seen live in my area.
- KozmoNau7 8y agoThe phrase "serious listener" makes my eye twitch, it must be the association with woo-woo audiophiles. I love listening to well-recorded music on my rather capable stereo or good headphones, but it just doesn't provide the same rush and sensation of seeing the actual musicians, live in concert, at a proper concert volume on a good live sound setup, handled by competent sound techs. Over the last I-have-no-idea-how-many-years, I've averaged 3-4 concerts per month, and 3-4 festivals per year, and I've experienced both garbage tier gear/sound and the exact opposite -- concert experiences that bordered on religious experiences. I especially appreciate small intimate venues, where you get right up close to the musicians and can really interact with them. The energy you feel in those situations is just second to none. My musical niche as a listener is metal, primarily death and thrash. YMMV obviously, depending on genres and available venues. But for me, going to live music shows on a regular basis is absolutely essential.
- brandall10 8y agoI was curious as to why all 'SoundCloud' rappers in the mumblecore genre had face tattoos. One interesting explanation I saw was it was a way to get exposure - few people are willing to do it, so for those who do, it's basically a right a passage and a way to show that you're the real deal. I saw an interview with Lil Xan talking about his face tattoos where he basically said as much, and on purpose made his first tattoo his mom's name so she wouldn't kill him for taking the plunge. His next tattoo was just 'zzz', which he stated was an act of branding due to his association with xanax. It seems to me this is a pretty big difference between say an indy rock band and an indie rapper. The rock bands act like the business side of things is something they'd rather not deal with - they just want to make music and do shows. The rappers first and foremost are focused on themselves being the core of a business in which their image needs to be carefully cultivated, the support group around them needs to be taken care of, etc.
- scarface74 8y agoTrue. How many rock bands have you heard going out to the community and passing out sample CDs?
- romwell 8y ago>How many rock bands have you heard going out to the community and passing out sample CDs? I've got quite a few CD's like that. So I'd say - plenty.
- scarecrowbob 8y agoSame, I play a lot of original folk music and most songwriters are giving away their CDs in about a 1/3 of the transactions I've seen. The other 1/3 of sales are more like tipping for service workers, and the other 1/3 is genuine "folks want the music and they want to pay for it.
- blackrock 8y agoWhat's a CD?
- 8y ago
- saaaaaam 8y ago“The consumer has virtually the world's entire musical output at their fingertips and far more free content than they even have time to listen to.” This is true, but the flip side is that people will take more risks because there is no financial consequence to sampling previously unknown music. Additionally there are still a lot of gatekeepers. When I talk about music distribution and consumption I always make a point of emphasising the difference between active consumers of music - those people who will actively search out new music, or even those who know what they want to listen to and will (for example) make their own playlists, and those people who just want a “make music happen” experience. The latter are more common and will typically fire up their stramaing platform of choice and select a playlist that matches their taste. For these people music is often somewhere between background noise and accompaniment to other activities, but inclusion on “premier” playlists (those with high visibility on platforms) is lucrative but quite rigidly controlled. You are probably less likely to be included on one of these if you don’t have a track record, or if you don’t have industry contacts. If you are included it can be a powerful way to gain new fans and get your music out to a much broader audience.
- shams93 8y agoYeah back in the 90s I was able to scratch out a living as a musician, but rent was $200 a month in 1992, the bar was very low back then. I did a recording session at Death Row Records that one I got paid $0 but Suge was not the kind of person you demanded payment from lol. Other gigs like DJing were more lucrative then to the point where I paid my rent and got food. But we didn't have cell phones or student loans. People had to buy our tapes to hear our music there was no way to hear it for free. Having only a couple hundred fans was good enough to survive back then you didn't need to have millions of listeners. Now if John Coltrane put out a Love Supreme in 2018 he couldn't pay people to listen to it. The hold that the majors have over music is heavier than ever. All my friends who still make a living from music are all signed to majors, I don't know anyone who makes $1 without being signed these days.
- scarface74 8y agobut Suge was not the kind of person you demanded payment from lol Just for the people who don't get the reference.... https://www.telegraph.co.uk/culture/music/music-news/11379104/who-is-suge-knight.html https://www.telegraph.co.uk/culture/music/music-news/1137910...
- bonniemuffin 8y ago“The Death Row people had this big-ass fight and the f------ New Orleans Police Department – being that they’re also a little psycho – rode their horses into the hotel.”! I'd pay money to see that.
- johnx123-up 8y ago> increasing ease of making music Can you please suggest few tools for this? TIA
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- thirdsun 8y agoAbleton Live is a very popular, accessable, yet powerful and complete solution with a huge community and countless ways to expand on the tools already included. It's a great starting point as well as potentially everything you might ever need.
- wyclif 8y agoI know well enough what you mean, and I don't want to downplay any aspect of it, but that software you're talking about that "all but makes the music for you" never ends up sounding like music to me. I don't totally dismiss it as "non-music", but when I hear tracks that are using Pro Tools presets it's obvious that the person who recorded it was just dialing it in. Music ultimately requires analog sounds and the interplay between musicians. Software can never truly replicate that.
- wilsonnb3 8y ago> Music ultimately requires analog sounds and the interplay between musicians. Software can never truly replicate that. This is nonsense. First of all, there's no such thing as a digital sound. Once it's sent to the speaker, it's analog, regardless of whether it originated inside your laptop or from a guitar. I would bet that you can't tell the difference between a top-end VST emulating an analog synth and a real analog synth, or a Kemper Profiling Amp and the real tube amp it's modeling. I enjoy the interplay between musicians as well but you can make a great album tracking all of the parts yourself and there are entire genres of electronic music where it's standard to not have more than one musician.
- majewsky 8y ago> Software can never truly replicate <thing>. I've heard this so often that it lost all meaning to me.
- screye 8y agoI think one way to do it is start with a genre that has a niche following and internet discussion forums. For example : Prog is one such community. (Fourm : r/progmetal) I have routinely discovered bands with <1000 listens on their top song on Spotify on that sub. I have seen these same bands grow to the point of gaining interest from a label. Interest that was fueled by forum members. Since the genre rewards musical proficiency, even causal listeners (non fans) can have quality discussions with forum members and boost engagement. IDK, if this works for other other genres too. But, IMO this is one of the better ways to survive in the new musical era.