4 ms·
> real torture As opposed to "enhanced interrogation techniques"? One thing the West certainly does better than the East is marketing.
by StavrosK 8y ago
> real torture
As opposed to "enhanced interrogation techniques"?
One thing the West certainly does better than the East is marketing.
- d0lph 8y agoThe US tortures its enemies, China its enemies and citizens.
- StavrosK 8y agoThat makes zero difference to me. I find them both immoral, not to mention that enemies of the US might include some Chinese people, making the two sets identical. You're saying that only the US can torture person X, but China can't.
- Nav_Panel 8y agoThis is an interesting position, regardless of the fact that the two sets (who the US torture vs who the Chinese torture) are clearly not identical. Why might a government torturing its own citizens be morally equivalent to a government torturing the citizens of other countries?
- StavrosK 8y agoBecause torturing anyone is immoral? Do you seriously need justification? Does this moral position of "we can torture foreigners, it's fine" seem fucked up to anyone else, or is it just me?
- Nav_Panel 8y agoKeep in mind that questioning whether the two are "morally equivalent" is not the same as saying "one is right and the other is wrong". It intuitively feels, to me, "more bad" for a country to torture its own citizens than for a country to torture citizens of its enemies (although both are still bad). Thus, I'd want to hear a justification that "actually, no, both are the same degree of bad."
- StavrosK 8y agoI think the onus falls on you to justify why torturing an enemy is "more good" than torturing a citizen. To me, torturing someone is axiomatically immoral, and the fact that they're a citizen of a specific country doesn't make any difference to that. I don't find it "less bad" to torture someone one day before they get their green card than one day after.
- Nav_Panel 8y agoHold up, "less bad" is not necessarily the same as "more good". Breaking my arm and breaking my neck are both bad, but one is worse than the other. It seems difficult to justify that "breaking my arm is more good than breaking my neck". I don't necessarily agree that the onus is on me (you were the one to initially bring it up here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17717319 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17717319 and I also gave my justification, which is that it feels intuitively different), but I can throw out some ideas as to why. I said it was interesting for a reason... 1) Perhaps it's a moral foundations (Haidt) difference: a state torturing its own citizens violates a moral "loyalty" principle as well as a moral "care" (harm avoidance) principle. Thus, it feels worse IF you ascribe to loyalty as a valid moral foundation. Haidt suggests modern liberals heavily elevate the "care" and "fairness" principles over the others, suggesting we might have a deep value difference causing our different opinions. 2) A more political perspective: the US constitution contains certain rights which all citizens are granted (note that US citizenship is defined as a "right to have rights"). See the passage (emphasis mine): "we hold these truths to be self-evident... that [all men] are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness". One could argue that for the US government to torture its citizens would be additionally unjust, on the grounds that it violates these constitutional rights, specifically (I'd argue) that of Liberty. It's a violation of a social contract as well as a violation of an ethical principle, making it a worse injustice. Note that the authority here is granted to "[the] Creator", intensifying the ethical severity of violating this social contract. 3) Could also make some lower-Kohlberg-level arguments about this, but they're less fun and interesting.
- 8y ago