2 ms·
As the article you've linked points out, the fact you _can_ theoretically do this in England doesn't mean it will actually work. There are private prosecutions
by tialaramex 8y ago
As the article you've linked points out, the fact you _can_ theoretically do this in England doesn't mean it will actually work.
There are private prosecutions in England, but they almost all happen under the tacit approval of the state, e.g. rather than spend government money prosecuting people who mistreat their pets the government doesn't stop the RSCPA (a charity) from prosecuting them privately with donated money.
If instead a rich person has just decided to try to prosecute someone they don't like, it is almost certain that the state will intervene, and indeed it is legally required to do so once it's told this is going on, by a judge, a newspaper article, a law clerk who realises what's happening, almost anybody.
What will happen is that a very bored junior barrister from the Crown Prosecution Service will show up (this could happen as early as pre-trial discussions), they will inform the court that the CPS would like this case assigned to them, they're privileged to do this without giving any reason. Then, having been granted control of your prosecution, the barrister will inform the judge that they're not offering any evidence, the judge will accordingly declare the defendant isn't guilty as no evidence has been presented against them. You have now spent a lot of money and achieved nothing except to annoy a judge and the prosecutor, which seems like a bad idea.
If you've got a dubious case, maybe the defendant was caught red-handed stealing something from your store and you're trying to prosecute them to ruin their reputation after police decided a formal warning was sufficient - the CPS can demand all your paperwork, take over the case and then having read your evidence decide to take that evidence to court or offer no evidence on the same basis they'd have used if the police sent them the case (a "full code test").