3 ms·
>New York strategically increased enforcement on six traffic violations it identified as being the most likely to kill or injure, including: Speeding.
by dsfyu404ed 8y ago
>New York strategically increased enforcement on six traffic violations it identified as being the most likely to kill or injure, including:
Speeding.
Failing to yield to a pedestrian.
Failing to stop on a signal.
Improper turns.
Cellphone use.
Disobeying signs.
The 1 and 3, 4 and 6 entries are almost wholly dependent on context and the 2 is sort of a tautology.
As a pedestrian (I walk ~2mi in the Boston area daily) I really have no problem with people violating the posted speed limit, running reds that were very recently yellow or taking a right on red where prohibited as long as they travel at somewhat reasonable speeds, don't flagrantly run reds, and ignore signs in a predicable manner.
Cars acting in an unpredictable manner and cars with distracted drivers (#5) are what results in them trying to occupy the same physical space as pedestrians (#2). As I see it four of the six things listed don't actually impact the danger to me any more than the inherent difference among drivers.
As a pedestrian I'd actually prefer the cops write less tickets because the blue lights distract drivers and throw a wrench into predictable traffic flow. A good chunk of drivers act like a spooked horse when the cops are out hunting and that's not good for my safety, attention paid to the cop who's pulling someone over is attention not paid to not hitting me.
If the cops want to post officers on a random street corners with point and shoot cameras and nab people for texting and driving then I can definitely get behind that. Based on my experience and observation I don't think telling them to go hog wild on everything else would be a net positive in terms of safety (that said, I'll take real cops enforcing traffic laws over automated enforcement any day).
edit:pun not intended but I'm leaving it because I like it.
edit2: Downvoted because people are too lazy to type out why I'm so wrong. Typical Reddit.
edit3: Maybe I wasn't clear enough why I'm opposed to prioritizing enforcement of traffic law. As long as traffic is consistent I can deal. When it becomes inconsistent (possibly because people fear strict traffic enforcement) you get more opportunities for pedestrians and drivers conflicting all the time and inconsistent traffic takes the attention of the drivers away from other things, like pedestrians. As a pedestrian I want nothing to do with an intersection where a cop is sitting or an intersection where there's a known cameras because driver's attention is allocated away from possible road hazards (like me) in order to more strictly adhere to the letter of the law. Most of the violations that NYC wants to prioritize pose no threat to me by themselves whereas aggressive enforcement creates more inconsistent traffic which is a danger to me. When someone slams on their brakes for a yellow the drivers who have to change what they're doing in response to that become more dangerous to me. Attention is finite. You can't handle the dev tickets when prod is burning and drivers are no different, aggressive traffic enforcement is another potential distraction to them and a danger to me.
- Symbiote 8y agoYou are downvoted because these violations have been identified as "the most likely to kill or injure", and you haven't made any argument against that.
- Steltek 8y agoDrivers act "like spooked horses" when a cop is pulling people over because they're taught that they'll never be caught breaking the law. Your summary is indicative of a vastly more serious problem: Drivers break the law so frequently that it doesn't even occur to them that they're doing it.