2 ms·
It would be interesting for someone to perform such a study in the UK, which already has a near-perfect and near-complete data set of which schools made an offe
by rahimnathwani 8y ago
It would be interesting for someone to perform such a study in the UK, which already has a near-perfect and near-complete data set of which schools made an offer to each student.
You wouldn't even need any data from the universities themselves:
- UCAS has the data for university offers and admissions (including subject studied)
- HMRC (UK equivalent of IRS) knows whether you were employed and how much you earned
If they were somehow allowed to join their data and then release a data set stripped of PII, which includes offers, acceptances and income over time, that would be super-useful for those who see choosing a university as primarily or partially a way to increase their future income.
- martinald 8y agoThis is a great idea.
- vostok 8y agoI think this would be an extremely interesting data set, but the obvious and simple analysis would not address the key problem that I see as mentioned in the article. > On job placement, the biggest deception by prestigious colleges and universities is to claim credit for the brainpower and work habits that students already had when they arrived. I see this all the time in my workplace. Many of my colleagues went to prestigious universities, but I am fairly certain that many of them would have gotten similar jobs even if they had not. There is evidence backing this up in that we gladly interview and hire candidates with similar pre-university experience who did not later go to prestigious universities. It just so happens that prestigious universities admit students with such pre-university experience at fairly high rates. My personal opinion is that the pre-university experience that I have in mind is a stronger and better signal than the university that they attend.
- rahimnathwani 8y agoThe data from UCAS would help distinguish between: - Someone who accepted a place at Oxford - Someone who was offered a place at Oxford, but went to Durham instead It should also help distinguish those two from: - Someone admitted to Oxford who decided not to go to university at all However (and perhaps this is the problem you have in mind) the data set for this last category is likely to be very very small. So perhaps the data can help to compare universities, but not whether going to university at all helps.
- jdietrich 8y agoThe Department for Education did exactly that. You can see the median earnings for graduates one, three and five years after graduation, broken down by subject and institution. You can download the whole dataset as a CSV. The data is also available in a user-friendly format on Unistats, the official website for comparing higher education course data. https://www.gov.uk/government/statistics/graduate-outcomes-for-all-subjects-by-university https://www.gov.uk/government/statistics/graduate-outcomes-f... https://unistats.ac.uk/ https://unistats.ac.uk/