7 ms·
With a low reproduction / declining pop rate, this was the wrong thing to do from a socio-economic perspective, not to mention morality. But really Japan has t
by mc32 8y ago
With a low reproduction / declining pop rate, this was the wrong thing to do from a socio-economic perspective, not to mention morality.
But really Japan has to seriously put an effort to positively utilize the other half of their able worker pool. If they engaged and got similar participation rates as men, that could go a long way in expanding their economy.
- whatshisface 8y agoIt is way more expensive for households with two working parents to raise children than it is for households with one working parent, and as a result it is possible that even fewer Japanese people would elect to have children.
- bangau1 8y agoEllaborate please or link that strength your argument about why it is more expensive if both parents are working
- usaar333 8y agoDay care costs of course. Total paid on childcare is higher in a family without a stay at home patent, though the two earner family generally will have more net disposable income (After child-care)
- stenl 8y agoSolution: free day care. It’s a win for taxpayers if those parents go to work and pay taxes instead of staying home with the kids. Also a win for women’s liberation.
- lambdaphagy 8y agoThere is a strongly negative relationship between women's education and fertility. Is this, in the long run, also good for the taxpayers?
- muricula 8y agoWhy should taxpayers get a say in an individual’s choice to pursue an education or fertility? That’s an incredibly personal decision.
- barry-cotter 8y agoWell if they're not paying for the daycare they don't. If they are they are then they do.If you want someone else's money then you're going to get it on their terms or not at all.
- doombolt 8y agoThis is downpayment for the future taxes by their children. Seems fair to me. But, for some reason, not for you?
- PurpleBoxDragon 8y agoDoes going to daycare over have a stay at home parent lead to an increase in the money made? And if we were considering just the number of children and how having more children will lead to more tax payers, then cutting funding for education in ways that result in more children being had is even better because you save money now and have more tax payers later. If you begin to optimize social and political decisions on the basis of having more tax payers, you'll get weird results. For a second example, cutting reproductive education funding in schools will lead to more tax payers (though arguably tax payers who pay less, so then the question becomes are you optimizing for tax payers or for future taxable income in total).
- doombolt 8y ago> cutting funding for education in ways that result in more children being had Do you have a citation for this? One with "cutting funding" in it and not the generic comparison between Somalia and Germany.
- Double_a_92 8y agoHow is "sacrificing" yourself for capitalism more liberating than taking care of your kids and family?
- doombolt 8y agoBecause you can now have your own means of survival as opposed to depending on someone other (such as "state" or "husband") and possibly being booted from time to time from that dependence together with children.
- aicantar 8y agoWomen's liberation is about choice, not about "acting like men". Not everyone wants to have kids and family. Some will work, some will stay at home. Same goes for men btw.
- isostatic 8y agoIn the UK it's very hard to have one parent stay at home - to pay the mortgage you usually need two full time to cover the mortgage. Child care is subsidised heavily by other taxpayers, but only government childcare - get a grandparent round and there's no tax break. The tax system works hard to discriminate against single parent families too (two people with two kids on total £80k pay a marginal tax of 32%. One person on £55k pays marginal 60%)
- ijlkr 8y agoIf females are denied good job opportunities in Japan, they'd be less inclined to work at all. So if your first sentence holds true, then this kind of discrimination actually should help Japan's reproduction rate.
- doombolt 8y agoThis is not what is observed to happen. The observation is that they will cling to worse opportunities, delay having children or avoid having them entirely. See e.g. France vs. Italy.
- ijlkr 8y agomaybe my reasoning only applies to big cities? In manhattan daycare is like $3k/child. To break even, one has to get paid ~$5k, since there are federal tax/city tax etc.
- ijlkr 8y agoWhat happened to France vs. Italy? I'm curious.
- doombolt 8y agoFrance has 1.5x birthrate of that of Italy, because it helps moms to get education and jobs, as opposed to Italy who put the bet on "family values".
- sulam 8y agoThat entirely depends on what the parents do. Certainly doctors generally make more than caregivers so in this specific case the family would net more with a physician mother. There is also evidence that female children of working mothers tend to go on to better education and career outcomes themselves, so this is effectively a heritable advantage for some offspring.
- mc32 8y agoNot all potential graduates affected would have become mothers, so from that standpoint it’s not applicable to a significant portion of the graduating class. But the real issue is the women were artificially denied an opportunity to decide by themselves.
- tecleandor 8y agoYou're implying that: - only women will take care of kids - daycare is as expensive as in your place of origin. (in Tokyo there are public daycare schools, and you have preference for entering if both parents work)
- w00kie 8y agoAnd yet hundreds of families are on waiting lists. If you don't get a spot, you have to go to a private facility which can easily cost more than one parent's monthly salary, or drop out of work until you get a spot, but then you're relegated even further down the waiting list. Also, once you're in, you'll have to pick the kid before 6pm in most daycares which means you must leave the office at 5pm and since a lot of companies do not have flex time, that single hour will push you to a part-time position. Then the daycare will refuse to take your child if they have a fever of 36.8℃ and do regular temperature checks during the day and force you to drop your work and come pick the child straight away if they go above 36.8℃. Unless you work close to home and have a very flexible and comprehending employer (or have grand parents close by and ready to help), even with a lucky spot in daycare it is extremely complicated to continue working. Let's not even talk about elementary school where mandatory partake in time-consuming useless PTA activities basically assumes one of the parent does not work.
- topmonk 8y ago36.8 C is less than normal human body temperature.
- dingo_bat 8y agoMaybe it is different for babies? https://www.nhs.uk/conditions/pregnancy-and-baby/how-to-take-your-babys-temperature/ https://www.nhs.uk/conditions/pregnancy-and-baby/how-to-take... says: > A normal temperature in babies and children is about 36.4C (97.5F)
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- epx 8y agoYeah, but it is not acceptable to try to boost natality by denying opportunity to 50% of adults. My response would be "ok, you don't want me to be a productive member of the society in the way I wanted, I won't be in any other way whatsoever". OTOH I'd guess that low natality in Japan has other factors, as other comments pointed, even for men: long, long hours of work, living in a cage called "apartment", probably no leeway in the work to handle domestic problems (yes, even living under the most conservative marriage arrangement possible, there will be domestic emergencies all the time, where a man needs to step in).
- KirinDave 8y agoThis is ludicrous. Firstly, this is a small and modestly exclusive institution. So much so that it could hardly be a causal factor in motivating women to decline to have children in preference to their career. Simply declining to let qualified women be doctors to make room for privileged rich sons is a repugnant insult to human intelligence, and should be viewed as the sexist attitude it is. Secondly, if the "force women to stay at home by disadvantaging them in the workplace" were such a great strategy, Japan wouldn't have a declining birthrate because until very recently (and ongoing, to a marginally lesser degree) this is the case.
- kaitai 8y agoJapan would not have the low reproduction rate it has if it made it easier for women to have kids and also stay in the workforce. Amazingly, women don't like giving up their entire societal and intellectual life to have a baby and live, isolated, in a tiny apartment. Japan's low birthrate is in part a symptom of the fact that motherhood is a career death sentence there. To be crude and still discriminatory, even a half-assed, difficult, crippled career limping along after motherhood would be much more motivating than the zero currently allowed in Japan. (BTW, the previous HN discussion referenced above is definitely worth referencing if a reader wants a more wide-ranging discussion.)
- fiblye 8y agoGermany's birth rate is 1.5. Japan's is 1.46. Saudi Arabia's is 2.71. Vietnam's is 1.96. Canada is 1.6. Making employment easier for women is clearly not related to birth rate. It seems to be inversely correlated with first world living status and education more than anything.
- mschuster91 8y ago> Germany's birth rate is 1.5 > It seems to be inversely correlated with first world living status and education more than anything. Well, at least for Germany I can provide some anecdata: either you're on welfare and have the state fund your life including kids or you're rich. The middle class and especially the young (20-30y) population in the major cities simply often cannot afford kids, not with the exploded rents and the trend to unpaid (!) internships, year-limited contracts, "gig work" and other things making my generation's life a living hell. I'm 27 and lucky to have landed an unlimited employment contract. The whole situation reminds me more and more of the setting of Idiocracy, and that without the US president in that movie being obviously inspirational for the current real world one. In addition the young population that fled the rural areas (due to e.g. job availability, the lack of public transport, any form of Internet faster than ISDN, ...) but left their parents/grandparents behind cannot rely on them to help with bringing up a child, further lowering the birth rate. For Italy, the situation is even worse - depending on the source and demographic target, up to 70-80% of young people still live with their parents because they cannot afford their own home (https://www.thelocal.it/20161024/two-thirds-of-italian-millennials-live-with-their-parents https://www.thelocal.it/20161024/two-thirds-of-italian-mille...). Hard enough to... uh, get going with your partner when your parents are next room, much less actually wanting to raise a child.
- prawn 8y agoI was baffled that the university appeared to get away with just "oops, we'll stop doing it now". Years and years of something this serious should be enough to end an institution.
- close04 8y agoWhere's the benefit in that? End the people responsible for this, not the institution that still provides invaluable services for the country (if run properly).
- prawn 8y agoFair enough. I meant more the operational tier that oversaw this rather than scrap buildings and general staff. But realistically, you'd hope there are alternative educators that can step in and provide a better, fairer service.
- drak0n1c 8y agoThe noble goal of increasing the supply of doctors is, unfortunately, also what motivated the discrimination. They made this policy because they did not want limited doctor spots going to women who may drop out of the workforce after 5-8 years. In Japan, most women who have a child do end up dropping out of the workforce regardless of profession. My Japanese mother once told me that women being expected to or made to work by their family is distasteful, and that women should be "treasured". Her opinion is not the overwhelming majority, but it is a sizable part of the spectrum. Regarding policy - of course the size of the class should instead be expanded to accommodate all who meet the bar, but unfortunately Japan also has issues with institutional rigidity and artificial licensure restrictions.
- Chris_Jay 8y agoJapan is probably more concerned about boosting their declining pop rate, which is inversely correlated with women's education, than expanding their economy in the short term and accelerating the population decline.
- doombolt 8y agoIt doesn't really work like that. You can't unmince meat back. Once there is demand for education you can't roll it back by not delivering. Moreover you can't fix anything by cheating on people and/or making their lives miserable. That's putting oneself in a very bad position indeed. It sounds more and more of a bad joke. In Russia, you cheat on exams for University, but in Japan, University cheats on exams for you. I would be interested in seeing the opposite examples where screwing people over fixed their birth rates (and introduced pink unicorns) but I'm pretty confident there will not be any.