21 ms·
False Advertising for College Is Pretty Much the Norm
- jseliger 8y agoThis is at least congruent with my own experience on the provider side of the college equation; perhaps most interesting to me is the extent to which the grad school side is amiss: https://jakeseliger.com/2012/05/22/what-you-should-know-before-you-start-grad-school-in-english-literature-the-economic-financial-and-opportunity-costs https://jakeseliger.com/2012/05/22/what-you-should-know-befo.... It does seem like the current system cannot go on forever.
- thundergolfer 8y agoWait. 10 years is seriously the MEDIAN time to graduate an english lit. PhD? That's awfully long.
- rahimnathwani 8y agoIt would be interesting for someone to perform such a study in the UK, which already has a near-perfect and near-complete data set of which schools made an offer to each student. You wouldn't even need any data from the universities themselves: - UCAS has the data for university offers and admissions (including subject studied) - HMRC (UK equivalent of IRS) knows whether you were employed and how much you earned If they were somehow allowed to join their data and then release a data set stripped of PII, which includes offers, acceptances and income over time, that would be super-useful for those who see choosing a university as primarily or partially a way to increase their future income.
- martinald 8y agoThis is a great idea.
- vostok 8y agoI think this would be an extremely interesting data set, but the obvious and simple analysis would not address the key problem that I see as mentioned in the article. > On job placement, the biggest deception by prestigious colleges and universities is to claim credit for the brainpower and work habits that students already had when they arrived. I see this all the time in my workplace. Many of my colleagues went to prestigious universities, but I am fairly certain that many of them would have gotten similar jobs even if they had not. There is evidence backing this up in that we gladly interview and hire candidates with similar pre-university experience who did not later go to prestigious universities. It just so happens that prestigious universities admit students with such pre-university experience at fairly high rates. My personal opinion is that the pre-university experience that I have in mind is a stronger and better signal than the university that they attend.
- rahimnathwani 8y agoThe data from UCAS would help distinguish between: - Someone who accepted a place at Oxford - Someone who was offered a place at Oxford, but went to Durham instead It should also help distinguish those two from: - Someone admitted to Oxford who decided not to go to university at all However (and perhaps this is the problem you have in mind) the data set for this last category is likely to be very very small. So perhaps the data can help to compare universities, but not whether going to university at all helps.
- jdietrich 8y agoThe Department for Education did exactly that. You can see the median earnings for graduates one, three and five years after graduation, broken down by subject and institution. You can download the whole dataset as a CSV. The data is also available in a user-friendly format on Unistats, the official website for comparing higher education course data. https://www.gov.uk/government/statistics/graduate-outcomes-for-all-subjects-by-university https://www.gov.uk/government/statistics/graduate-outcomes-f... https://unistats.ac.uk/ https://unistats.ac.uk/
- RobertRoberts 8y agoI taught college for about a dozen years (part time on the side), and may get dragged back into again soon. I can say emphatically, the quality of the schooling only helps people who would succeed anyways. Those that won't or can't, no school can help them. There are just too many lazy, unmotivated or simple defeatist students out there. To not be too harsh, there are many students over their head in life (debts, relationship or mental issues, etc...), also which a school can do little to help with. Nothing proved this to me more than seeing half the class not turn in the easiest assignments.
- ve55 8y agoIt was noticed that those who were in more higher education went on to achieve more success later in life (where success is often more income, but obviously many other things too). Over time some inferred causality from this: clearly the reason why some were successful was because they had a degree or even a masters or PhD. Thus in order to encourage success, it was decided that higher education should be strongly recommended as a means to achieve success. But what was not considered was that the causality here could be incorrect, instead showing us that people with traits optimized for success in life chose to enroll in higher education to use the additional knowledge and experience as a catalyst for their success (or they just otherwise loved academia or learning). Due to the extent of which this first hypothesis was treated as a fact, we are left with a system that attempts to reinforce it at many levels of society, ignoring the large cost that it takes.
- iampims 8y agoSame thing happened when someone noticed a correlation between successful kids and kids who have books at home. Someone ordered that every household should have books at home while failing to realize that correlation != causation…
- seansmccullough 8y agoSame thing with home ownership.
- HelloFellowDevs 8y ago"Just because you got in doesn't mean that you should go". With the amount of high school students being prepared nearly around the clock to gain admission into college, there looks to be a great deal of FOMO. From parents to students to possibly school administrations. Not many stop to question is the student themselves ready for College or will they wash out with tons of debt?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- sigfubar 8y agoI think that most people shouldn't aspire to go to college. They should learn a trade instead in order to become a plumber, carpenter, electrician, or car mechanic. There are lots of occupations that don't require a college degree, yet provide a solid paycheck without the crushing mass of student debt accrued in the pursuit of a useless degree. Michael Bloomberg himself said it best: http://www.foxnews.com/politics/2013/05/19/pipe-dream-skip-college-become-plumber-nyc-mayor-bloomberg-says.html http://www.foxnews.com/politics/2013/05/19/pipe-dream-skip-c... I'm personally surprised that this isn't conventional wisdom already.
- cm2012 8y agoI also think more jobs should be trades. Data analyst (not machine learning, but running SQL queries, etc), marketing, bookkeeping, sales, etc, dont need 4 year degrees. 1 year bootcamp could get people reliable jobs.
- hakfoo 8y agoWhat bothers me-- assuming there's still a preference for a full degree over a bootcamp certificate-- is that even clearly career focused degree paths are still burdened down with an "academia" mindset that feels dated and quaint. The old "college is about being well rounded/learning how to learn" narratives made sense 50-100 years ago, when people were going to university as more a "cultural elite" thing. The rich 20-generation legacy who attends to build his social network, mixing with the top-5%-of-his-class scholarship student and social-climbers powering their way through school, had a different set of needs. Yeah, let them study Latin and great thinkers so they can schmooze in the corridors of power. It was fine when only a few percent of the population went on to university, and the actual degree content was less important than that you got a degree. However, the kids signing up today-- especially in well-known high-revenue programs (CS, EE, etc) are in it because they either 1) love the subject matter or 2) are bootstrapping their careers. These kids have neither use nor interest in becoming cultured or well-rounded. They'll go further referencing Dennis Ritchie than William Blake. There might be a case for a writing course or two, but all those 100-level survey humanities or "fun sciences" classes you're taking to hit general studies requirements? I doubt it. Or the requirement some programs have of "at least NNN total credit-hours" even if you can technically hit all the content requirements on fewer. I'm surprised you aren't seeing legitimate universities responding to the market and producing a 2-3 year BSc program, stripped of almost all general-studies courses. You want to fight tuition increases? Get kids out in 2.5 years! I assume the endgame of this would be that a lot of literature and philosophy professors will be out of work, but this surely leads into some sort of punchline about them working at Starbucks..
- _hardwaregeek 8y agoIt's extremely hard to get good, unbiased information on colleges. Almost every news source is either based on metrics that students don't care about (number of papers published by the department, NSF grants, etc), or basically advertising done by the school itself. If there was a way to get information about schools, stuff like "oh XYZ college has really great campus life" or "ABC college has an amazing hackathon community" or even "oh this school's food sucks", then I think it would be immensely popular. The only (but main) problem is convincing college students to contribute.
- dan-robertson 8y agoA problem with this is that it’s harder to do useful comparisons when most people have experience of only one of the things being compared. Eg if students say they are happy, does that mean the College is good or that they just bring in students who were happier than average in the first place.
- topkai22 8y agoThe real problem with higher education is really how we finance it. Give the lenders the ability to discriminate based on major and borrowers the ability to default easier and all of a sudden you’ve got some banks seriously motivated to ensure students get economic return on their investments. Besides, it just shouldn’t take a decade or more for someone to discharge a bad debt. Student debt seems uniquely oppressive within the American system, and it really needs to look more like other forms of personal debt.
- CPLX 8y agoOr instead, like most other advanced societies, we could stop trying to quantify higher education in purely personal economic return on investment grounds and consider an educated populace a public good.
- tikhonj 8y agoIf education rather than credentialing was the overwhelming driver, a priority should be providing education to people without credentialing built-in, in a form factor that's a lot more flexible than a classic four-year degree. Ideally, it should be easy for people to educate themselves on their own pace, even as they are doing other things at the same time (like working). I somehow expect a system focused just on education like this would not have the ballooning costs we see now. The incessant obsession with multi-year degree-granting programs specifically is a lot more about the degree than the education.
- vertex-four 8y agoI mean, in the U.K., if you’re interested in learning at your own pace, every university has at least some form of part-time course, local FE colleges do part time courses regularly, and there’s the Open University if you want to work towards a degree part-time. This is an American problem, not one to do with the concept of being able to prove you’ve completed an education.
- foldr 8y ago
- martin_bech 8y agoI find it funny that these numbers are not available. In our free education system (Denmark), almost all of this data is freely available, also as the government, want students to make an informed choice. So most schools its easy to get graduation rate, salary estimates and even how many from the last class are employed, and how many in relevant fields.
- Mashimo 8y agoOh indeed. Found something here [0] from the Education and Research Ministry. My Excel does not really like that file though. [0] https://ufm.dk/uddannelse/statistik-og-analyser/faerdiguddannede/aktuel-ledighed https://ufm.dk/uddannelse/statistik-og-analyser/faerdiguddan...
- jimhefferon 8y agoI work at a college and we are required by the federal government to report all kinds of numbers. I know grad rate is among them, and I am 99% sure it is broken down by major. Those reports are public.
- jononor 8y agoWhere can I find them? Interested in mining the data
- capnrefsmmat 8y agoThe Department of Education College Scorecard has a great deal of data which they make openly available: https://collegescorecard.ed.gov/data/ https://collegescorecard.ed.gov/data/
- jimhefferon 8y agoI don't know where it would be in mine-able format. There is this for instance: https://www.smcvt.edu/on-campus/offices-and-services/institutional-research.aspx https://www.smcvt.edu/on-campus/offices-and-services/institu....
- cptskippy 8y agoIt's odd that no one has addressed the issues of the rising cost of higher education. Once upon a time you could work a full-time job during the summer and part-time during the school year to pay for your education and graduate debt free. This wasn't that long ago either, I paid for my college education in the late 90s in cash I earned.
- pmiller2 8y agoIf you paid for school yourself with money earned through employment in the late 90s, my guess is you either majored in STEM, had a lot of AP or other credits going in, or did your first 2 years at a community college (or, possibly more than one of these). I’d also wager you went to an in-state public school. Am I right? If so, that probably makes you the exception rather than the rule.
- cptskippy 8y agoI attended an in-state public university and paid the full in-state tuition from 1998-2001. I worked a retail position at an office supply store for 2 years before taking a help desk position at a small company. With both jobs I worked part-time during fall and spring semesters and full-time during the summer to pay for tuition. > If so, that probably makes you the exception rather than the rule. So you're saying the majority of people seeking higher education are going out of state or to private schools? Enrollment in public/state colleges and universities outpaces private schools three to one. https://www.statista.com/statistics/183995/us-college-enrollment-and-projections-in-public-and-private-institutions/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/183995/us-college-enroll... https://nces.ed.gov/programs/coe/indicator_cha.asp https://nces.ed.gov/programs/coe/indicator_cha.asp
- alasdair_ 8y ago>I paid for my college education in the late 90s in cash I earned. If you went to a public school, taxpayers paid for a large portion of it.
- cptskippy 8y ago
- justsomedude43 8y ago"The administration of President Donald Trump just made it easier for for-profit colleges to get away with making fake promises about things like graduation rates and job placements." This is where I stopped reading. Pretty much the first sentence. False advertising has been a problem for at least two decades now, mostly in Law and nothing has been done about it. People started talking about it only recently after the rich kids got affected by the false advertising; their parents spend $200k-$300k on a Law degree with a Bar test only to find out that their kids can't get a job that pays more than $50k because there's been an abundance of lawyers for about twenty years now. Same goes for IT and all sorts of BS degrees ala marketing, communications, david beckham studies etc... besides you don't need somebody to tell you: "Hey, save your money you don't yet have, that degree is useless! You can do that without having one." You only need half a brain cell to figure this for yourself. It's not brain surgery and if you do need someone to tell you that, then you really do need a hard lesson.
- jstewartmobile 8y agoFalse advertising for everything is pretty much the norm. I get fatigued just navigating through all of the rackets out there. I do not know how people who skip the fine print manage to survive these days.
- koin0r 8y ago*advertising IS pretty much the norm for everything these days. we are being flooded with ads, but we're often selling ourselves as well... ad-based world this is..
- jwally 8y agoThe U.S. would do itself a huge favour by allowing student debt to be bankruptable. College prices can rise infinitely because there is an unlimited supply of AAA+ debt to feed it. Drop that rating to reality and investors don't buy the debt, loans don't get originated, demand for college at $250k dries up.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- kryogen1c 8y agoUsed to be. Doctors and lawyers would go through a decade of school on loan and then discharge it all and start a lucrative practice. That's part of how we got here.
- azemetre 8y agoWhere are you getting this information from? Because nothing I am able to see points to people discharging their loans happening on a massive scale. The only "news article" [1] I can find that references this mentions 0.3% of student loans were discharged through bankruptcy in 1977 [2]. [1] https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/history-student-loans-bankruptcy-discharge-steven-palmer https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/history-student-loans-bankrup... [2] http://harvardlawreview.org/wp-content/uploads/pdfs/vol126_student_loan_exceptionalism.pdf http://harvardlawreview.org/wp-content/uploads/pdfs/vol126_s... Seems be to be some serious revisionist history going on...
- reaperducer 8y agoSeems be to be some serious revisionist history going on... Just because it’s not a link on the internet doesn’t mean it isn’t true. It was pretty much common knowledge when I was in school. I only knew a few pre-meds, but it certainly came up as a discussion topic more than once.
- SketchySeaBeast 8y ago
- russfink 8y agoThe author's position is that the only reason to go to college is to learn academic subjects and obtain a job when graduating. If the same logic were applied to automobiles, there'd be no reason to choose a Lexus over a Nissan. College is about the whole experience: friends, contacts, travel, opportunities, and yeah, for some, it just comes down to wanting to to go to a place that "doesn't suck." As for innate ability - well, students were selected based on the college wanting specific types of students, largely because they want to create an unsuckish experience for the students. (There are unmotivated, immature, and/or improperly-backgrounded people in every class, but is it just a couple, or a majority?) As for the focused universities, the ones that bill themselves solely as get-smart-get-job/promotion/whatever, and that fail to deliver, those must be held accountable. If I bought a "Cheaperson S Hatchback" and it consistently failed to take me to work, and a significant portion of other Cheaperson owners reported the same thing, then the problem is in the car, not me, and Cheaperson should be held accountable.
- scarface74 8y agoCollege is about the whole experience: friends, contacts, travel, opportunities, and yeah, for some, it just comes down to wanting to to go to a place that "doesn't suck." And that’s a luxury that only a few have. I’m sure most parents wouldn’t get into thousands of dollars of student loan debt for that reason. I can’t imagine a world where it makes sense to get a luxury car and get in thousands of debt before you have a good job either.
- CM30 8y agoEh, even most normal colleges are pretty honest in their ads compared to game design ones: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kAFLfx3mvIg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kAFLfx3mvIg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BRWvfMLl4ho https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BRWvfMLl4ho But seriously, the fact of the matter is: 1. Too many people go to college, so its original value (as a status indicator) is now virtually non existent 2. It's too expensive, so unless a good job is a near guaranteed outcome, people will laden with debt after going. 3. Most people and most jobs don't need college, and the push to send everyone to college has led to rampant degree inflation in terms of academic requirements. The only solution to fix that would be to somehow get employers to stop caring about degrees, to make it less 'necessary' for many people, and to encourage less people to attend for the career 'boost'.
- reaperducer 8y agoThat sounds good in writing, but it doesn’t seem to work in real life for some reason. Two of the cities I’ve lived in have been places with several large businesses focused on a single non-factory industry. They could never get enough workers, so demand for labor was high and because of that so were wages. The prevailing attitude among the very local teens (2nd generation plus) was “Why should I go to college when I can make $xx/hour working in the industry?” Their parents also worked in the industry and thus didn’t push their children to go to college. The mentality is so pervasive that at a community event I saw an industry table set up with a big banner reading “Why you don’t need college,” and nobody else thought that was odd. The result is that most of the locals are pretty dumb. They make poor decisions in their personal lives, which has an impact on the entire city, it’s policing policies and it’s healthcare system. Non-industry businesses are reluctant to move to those cities because they can’t find educated workers, so the economy can’t diversify. I saw a tech startup hiring people straight out of high school simply because that’s all it could find. Not surprisingly, the company failed in under a year. It’s a shame that college is so expensive, and there should be a way to fix that. But in my experience, employers wanting degrees helps society ad a whole because it encourages more people to seek higher education who would otherwise be complacent.
- randomdata 8y ago
- RestlessMind 8y agoHow about: - allowing discharging of student debt after 10 years - allowing someone to pay only up to 10% of adjusted gross income per year (lenders cannot ask for more; voluntary prepayment is okay) What will happen, probably, is that: - lenders will start looking at earning potential of various degrees and loan amounts will be tied to degrees being pursued - tuitions for degrees with low earning potential will be lowered - universities who cannot afford to lower tuitions will shut down some departments. That slack will be picked up by community colleges. - some of the majors will only be pursued by rich (as happened for hundreds of years)