3 ms·
It's pretty clear that they are. And so it is arguable that the First Amendment should apply. However, it's also arguable that the men who wrote the Bill of Ri
by mirimir 8y ago
It's pretty clear that they are. And so it is arguable that the First Amendment should apply.
However, it's also arguable that the men who wrote the Bill of Rights had not even a shred of a clue about the power of social media on the Internet. News spread slowly then, and there was time for considered debate.
I mean, they were concerned about restraining democratic will to protect against populist extremism. For example, US senators were initially elected by state legislatures. And the Electoral College wasn't just an accounting system.
But damn, I don't have an answer. One could argue that Alex Jones is basically yelling "fire", and so has no expectation of free speech. But what about the antiwar.com people? What's so horrible about advocating the rights of Palestinians, or opposing sanctions against Iran?
- kryogen1c 8y ago> One could argue that Alex Jones is basically yelling "fire", and so has no expectation of free speech. Of all the things you could argue, I think this is explicitly not one of them. All the crazy and ridiculous things Alex says are in no way comporable to a direct call to violence or endangering Public safety with knowingly false statements. In other words, Facebook is silencing free speech in a way that is definitely not covered if they must comply with the bill of rights.
- mirimir 8y agoI meant "fire" in a political sense. OK, hypothetically, if he were part of a Russian operation to destabilize the United States, would the US government be justified in prosecuting him? I mean, consider Mariia Butina , who "face[s] charges related to interference in the presidential election."[0] 0) https://www.nytimes.com/2018/07/16/us/politics/trump-russia-indictment.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/07/16/us/politics/trump-russia-...
- kryogen1c 8y ago> OK, hypothetically, if he were part of a Russian operation to destabilize the United States, would the US government be justified in prosecuting him? Sedition is a different charge than censored speech. > I meant "fire" in a political sense. When you are talking about free speech, there is no other sense other than the literal in-a-movie-theater sense.
- mirimir 8y agoWhy is he being censored, do you think? Is it just a PR issue?
- abnry 8y agoThe mainstream media yells fire every. single. day.