4 ms·
The 'warrant' part is unrelated to the ownership issue of the tracking device. Even if it was used under unlawful circumstances, the FBI remains owner of the de
by roel_v 16y ago
The 'warrant' part is unrelated to the ownership issue of the tracking device. Even if it was used under unlawful circumstances, the FBI remains owner of the device. To take an extreme example, if I throw a brick through your window with a note attached to it 'this brick is owned by jimmy jones and I have no intention of relinquishing ownership', I remain owner of the brick. That I'm liable for the damage caused by it is self-evident. (the note is to preempt a digression into 'apparent abandonment of property' or whatever the exact wording it is in the appropriate jurisdiction)
'Ownership' of something, and 'committing a crime' with that something are orthogonal. Apart from some specifically designated by law items (drugs, weapons), committing a crime with something does not change its ownership status. I don't quite see the controversy here (that is, after one steps back and looks over the 'oh my god! big gubmint is spying on us!' knee-jerk reaction. Let's not forget the kid (from what I gathered...) was apparently connected to organized crime, even if only through blood).
- roel_v 16y agoCorrection: guy's family wasn't organized crime, I misremembered - father was a Muslim leader. No mention of what that entails more specifically. Still without knowing more it does seriously detract from that part of my point.
- VBprogrammer 16y agoThere is something about the tone of what you just wrote that deeply annoys me. Had the boys father been a Christian leader would you have been concerned by what exactly that entails?
- roel_v 16y agoIf the father had been a Westboro Baptist Church or Branch Davidian style sect leader? Of course. We don't know what happened. For the guy to post to Reddit starting off with a 'look I'm being investigated because I'm Arab! FBI is racist!' post while not giving any information on the circumstances, that just sounds like a PR spin.
- nkassis 16y agoI don't know about this, Muslim leader could mean anything from successful business man to radical leader. The news was sparse on who the father was. And frankly, nothing in the article shows that his father was the reason they followed him. The article states that one of his friends wrote something on his blog. I wouldn't put it pass the FBI to investigate everyone who knew the friend in question for no other reason than they play halo together.
- roel_v 16y agoI guess it's a matter of interpretation, but when someone says 'Muslim leader', I personally interpret that narrowly, as in this person having a 'position of authority in the religious sense, within the Muslim faith', and not so much 'person from Muslim cultural background who is in some form of power'. The 'article' I mentioned was the original Reddit post. Apparently the kid thought the Muslim angle was important enough to deserve a mention.
- lzw 16y agoDid you know that, when David Koresh discovered the ATF was asking about him and asked about him at the gun store where he did business, he proactively called the local ATF office and offered to come in and have a chat with them? Koresh was not hiding anything. This is why he, and all the men, women and children, in there had to be killed at the end of that siege. So that these facts would not be made publicly known. You talk about "Branch Dividian style sect" and most americans have a completely false perspective on those people and that event because they were fed government lies during the entire period. And afterwards, when the truth came out, it was no longer news. Enough of that, and you start thinking that it is ok to illegally spy on americans.
- Ennis 16y ago"Muslim Community Association" is what was mentioned in the article. A paragraph explaining the organization and it's activities would have helped. Maybe a link to it's website and profile pages for its board of directors. Just to be sure. I'm being sarcastic if you couldn't tell. I think the description is detailed enough for a newspaper article that is not focused on the organization. This frustrates me as well. I hope the ACLU challenges this.
- psn 16y ago"was apparently connected to organized crime, even if only through blood" So if you're the son of the local mafia don, from what age should you followed around by the FBI? 18? seems old - there are plenty of child offenders. maybe 10 or so. At what age, having lived a life free from crime, should the FBI stop following you? 25? 30? 40? Perhaps we could assume people are innocent until we can prove them guilty.
- roel_v 16y agoI'm not saying anything about the kid actually being a mobster. I don't think it's unreasonable to say that there may well be reasonable grounds for the feds to track the whereabouts of a child of a mob boss. There is no evidence or even suggestion of all children of all mafia dons being tracked. As a side note, I quite resent your populist straw man argument. "Perhaps we could assume people are innocent until we can prove them guilty." Of course, and how do you do that? Sometimes, by tracking people you have a reasonable suspicion of guilt of, as long as its done through legal means. Let me also point out that the Ninth Circuit ruled last month that warrantless gps tracking is legal. You may oppose this, it's still the (current) law (yes I'm aware that it's a contested issue, and I also don't know what jurisdiction this was in).
- lzw 16y agoThe 9th court can repeal gravity, but it doesn't make it law. It merely makes it the opinion of the court. The law has not changed, and the law is quite clear in requiring a warrant. The law will not change until the constitution is ammended. It is very important to recognize that the courts do not create law, and they cannot change the meaning of the law with rulings (otherwise there would be no purpose in having separation of powers.) That, in effect, they are able to do so, is merely a measure of how lawless the government in this country has become. But that should be obvious. For instance, the existence of the FBI is unconstitutional, since it is not mentioned as an agency of the federal government in the enumerated powers clause.
- bhjodokast 16y ago
- jacquesm 16y agoIf you attach it to my property, I just might feel the need to discard it. Good luck suing me for losing your shit. And in the case of a GPS unit I'd be making very sure I discarded it far away from the place where it was last functional. You (as in you the law enforcement agency) might be in the right to attach stuff to my car, but I as the owner of the vehicle am not responsible if your stuff goes missing in action. And if you do it without a warrant I'll make sure you have bigger problems.
- roel_v 16y agoYou don't seem to understand. "You (as in you the law enforcement agency) might be in the right to attach stuff to my car, but I as the owner of the vehicle am not responsible if your stuff goes missing in action." Wrong, If the owner of the car on purpose destroys the agencies property, he is legally liable for those damages. How could it not be so? How could the fact that a tool is used unlawfully detract from the ownership? When the agency attaches the tool to the car, there is no transfer of ownership. Secondly, I'm not sure what you are imagining that the absence of a warrant means, in theoretical and practical terms. In our country, illegally obtained evidence will usually cause at most a small reduction of the sentence. A complete dismissal is quite rare.
- jacquesm 16y ago> If the owner of the car on purpose destroys the agencies property, he is legally liable for those damages. Prove it. > Secondly, I'm not sure what you are imagining that the absence of a warrant means, in theoretical and practical terms. In our country, illegally obtained evidence will usually cause at most a small reduction of the sentence. A complete dismissal is quite rare. That is a structural problem with your legal system. Besides that, I've done nothing wrong as far as I know (other than maybe dropping your GPS unit on the back of a truck bound for Afghanistan) so much good luck in prosecuting me. Here (.nl) cases that rely on evidence gathered in illegal means get thrown out with some regularity, even if the rest of it is ironclad. Not that long ago a bunch of car thieves was apprehended and in a first sitting convicted based on information taken from a license plate scanning experiment. The case was rock solid, except for one little detail, that data should not have been in the hands of the police, so the whole thing was thrown out without a chance for a 'do-over'. Tainted evidence is the last thing the police here wants in their cases, and throwing out the whole case keeps them sharp.