5 ms·
It's likely a short-term problem. There are plenty of ways to fix it (besides the one you mention, just shut down coal & oil power plants for good and replace
by nostrademons 8y ago
It's likely a short-term problem. There are plenty of ways to fix it (besides the one you mention, just shut down coal & oil power plants for good and replace them with technologies like natural gas or hydro that can easily react to spikes in demand), but all of the fixes require capital investments and time to build factories & tooling.
Basically this is a problem because a bunch of existing incumbents are probably going to go bankrupt, or at least have to write down a lot of capital equipment and invest in new technologies. Boo-hoo for the incumbents, but it's good for consumers and good for society.
- mac01021 8y agoIs the responsiveness of an oil plant so different from a natural gas plant? Why? They're both essentially a furnace fueled by a flow of combustible fluid, right?
- mechagodzilla 8y agoThey are similar, but outside of small islands few people use oil for power generation due to the high cost compared to natural gas.
- chronomex 8y agoNatgas is a turbine engine directly; coal and oil uses a boiler running a steam turbine.
- jabl 8y agoNG plants tend to use gas turbines, which can ramp very quickly indeed. Steam plants are a lot slower (thermal stresses and whatnot). Very little electricity is produced with oil, BTW. Steam plants are usually coal or nuclear.
- hectormalot 8y agoNote: many bigger gas plants are combined cycle, the exhaust of the gas turbine generates steam in a waste heat boiler for a steam turbine. Often multiple GTs on a single ST.
- xigma 8y ago> Basically this is a problem because a bunch of existing incumbents are probably going to go bankrupt, or at least have to write down a lot of capital equipment and invest in new technologies. That's not how it works. In Germany, the government subsidizes farmers to put up Windfarms, then forces the electric companies to buy the electricity at an inflated price, which those companies charge their customers for. As a result, energy prices in Germany are almost doubled for citizens, whereas companies get to have exemptions, of course. Then they need to sell surplus energy for negative money when production is too high and import (often nuclear) energy from neighboring countries when it's too low. While they did get rid of most (domestic) nuclear energy, essentially the same amount of fossil fuel is still required to maintain the baseline. It's utter nonsense, but the Germans get to pat themselves on the back for being so green. Well, except for all that coal energy that also needs subsidies because of those poor coal workers...
- eigenvector 8y agoYou hit at an important dimension which is that the problem is not technical per se, it's really a problem of market design. Wind power purchase agreements should allow curtailment (since it is very easy to ramp a wind farm /down/) when needed for system reliability. However, this reduces the rate of return for wind farms so politicians that are looking to maximize wind build-outs will not favour this. It's also beneficial to increase the size of the power market geographically, which reduces the variability of wind generation, rather than arbitrarily stopping at national borders.
- namibj 8y agoWe already have a mostly-unified central European power market. IIRC the whole central Europe grid is in a single market. Also note that providers with international transport capacity can use that to arbitrage over them.
- rmetzler 8y agoI think, it's only in theory like this, since you can't route energy over large distances without significant loss.
- 08-15 8y agoRWE would like to shut down a few coal power plants that are no longer profitable in the current distorted market. But the government, the very same technically illiterate government that fouled up the market in the first place, declared that to be illegal, because the plants are "relevant for grid stability". > Boo-hoo for the incumbents, but it's good for consumers and good for society. Right, the most expensive electricity anywhere in the world, except for Diesel powered islands, is good for customers.