3 ms·
Fermi's paradox is basically an example of saying "the only two possibilities are that it's impossible or inevitable, and since we don't know it to be impossibl
by jcranmer 8y ago
Fermi's paradox is basically an example of saying "the only two possibilities are that it's impossible or inevitable, and since we don't know it to be impossible, it must be inevitable"--actually multiplying a few of those together--and then being surprised that the evidence doesn't show that it's inevitable.
We don't have enough knowledge of fundamental physics, chemistry, or biology to come up with any reasonably tight bound (tight here meaning only a few orders of magnitude) as to how likely alien interstellar voyaging is, to say nothing of our complete ignorance of xenosociology. Our own experience is n=1, which means it's extremely dangerous to generalize.
But even then, we run into a problem: intrastellar travel is hard. We don't yet have the technology to colonize a single other body in our own solar system, and it's dubious that we could send a human to and from any other body save our own Moon. The only mechanism we have to travel in space is via rockets, whose fuel costs are prohibitive for any sort of long journey. Even getting out of our gravity well requires rockets, and while we have concepts of other ideas that are less expensive, they tend to have problematic requirements such as "requires things we haven't discovered yet."
- sebazzz 8y ago> We don't yet have the technology to colonize a single other body in our own solar system Is it? Or is it that no one wants to put any resources into that because you would probably get very little out of it. We are a money-based mostly capitalistic society, so unless there is any gain any entity whether it be a government or commercial company, investments in development of technology or actually attempting colonisation will not get anywhere anytime soon.
- jcranmer 8y agoIf you define colonize as "build a self-sustaining colony," that is very much outside of our current capabilities. We don't know how to build a self-sustaining biosphere, let alone one any body so fundamentally hostile to life as Mars or any other rocky body in the planet.
- modzu 8y agoim not sure who you're quoting but i don't think that is Fermi. the point of the paradox is not merely wondering how likely alien life is. rather, it starts with the simple fact that no evidence for alien life has been observed, ever, anywhere. why? well, there's all kinds of potential explanations, maybe its far away, maybe its not advanced anywhere else, etc. we don't know the answer of course, but given the vastness of space one might expect to at least see some evidence of alien life, if not alien life directly, somewhere. that we do not suggests something fundamentally bigger is going on (ie the speed of light is legit)
- jcranmer 8y agoThe very name of the Fermi paradox suggests that we ought to be surprised that we haven't seen evidence of alien life. Instead, what I'm trying to say is that we don't even have enough evidence to be able to assert that we should expect to see alien life in the first place.
- modzu 8y agook, thanks for the clarification. so if fermi and you are looking up at all the stars in the night sky and he says to you, "where is everyone??" you would say, "what do you mean? why would there be anyone out there?" i don't think most people would have that intuition but it's fair. drake's equation is a fun way to try to answer fermi. it seems you would assign n_e or f_1 a value close to 0
- a_wild_dandan 8y agoWe also don't even know how likely life is to arise at all. Abiogenesis could be a freak accident with a 1 in a googolplex probability, rendering us (Earth) a freak accident, a la the anthropic principle. We just don't know.