3 ms·
Reading this resonated with me. I knew that the responses here would pretty much rip it apart, but I'm surprised that as of right now only one of 15 comments i
by dasil003 16y ago
Reading this resonated with me. I knew that the responses here would pretty much rip it apart, but I'm surprised that as of right now only one of 15 comments is positive.
It's pretty easy to find ways to criticize this post. It's not particularly well written, it's not inspirational, and of course you can poke holes in any kind of argument this vague. But if you don't agree, I think it's worth it to stop and be honest with yourself about whether you really think it's complete bullshit, or if there is maybe a tinge of guilty defensiveness mixed in.
I'm not claiming that this article is anything close to the whole truth—after all, we can't make a difference if we can't make a living—but if there wasn't at least a seed of truth here then I don't think "changing the world" would be part of the standard entrepreneurial goals.
- sbov 16y agoIts similar to something I have thought before - this isn't only a problem with tech startups, its a problem with the majority of businesses in the world. I half-joked about it with friends before, saying that people should only be allowed to do jobs that weren't "bread and circus" (to borrow a phrase) from 5-9, then after work hours could do what they pleased. Realistically though, this poster probably contributes to the bottom line of many bread and circus businesses. And so do I. Today I bought a box of hot tamales (the candy) and a cherry coke - these are all bread and circus and only serve for my enjoyment. I ate a steak dinner on Saturday night - totally bread and circus, as I could get my nutritional value through better methods. The people who work to produce these things could be put to work doing something better, while the government provides a tasteless, odorless, white paste for all our nutritional value. Some of the most enjoyable parts of life tend to be surrounded by bread and circus. But if they were never invented in the first place, I guess I wouldn't know what I was missing.
- smokeyj 16y agoAnother blog heard from. Group A thinks group B doesn't do enough for society. Instead of describing a system to overcome of the selfish tendencies inherent in all humans, she chose to belittle an entire industry and the aspirations of entrepreneurs trying to learn to be productive.
- zaidf 16y agoThe premise of the article is that because there are so many fluff start-ups, there are so few non-fluff start-ups. Now, for the sake of debate, let's agree there are lots of fluff start-ups. But does that mean there are fewer non-fluff start-ups? I don't think so. It's a false dichotomy. Just because you have more Zynga-like companies does not mean you don't have more start-ups today than a decade ago going after cancer. This is the most common flaw I find in arguments related to this.
- davidw 16y agoThe label I think you're looking for is "zero-sum thinking". That there are only a fixed number of startups to go around, and if they're all off doing web stuff, there is no room for other fields of endeavor.
- zaidf 16y agoand if they're all off doing web stuff Obviously not the case. The fixed number could be going up for both. At once, there could be more web start-ups and so-called serious start-ups than previous years.
- davidw 16y ago> Obviously not the case. I agree, I was just stating what "zero-sum thinking is".
- Tichy 16y agoJust think why some countries are good in football, and others are good in baseball. It does make a difference what kind of sports is the most visible and prestigious - talent really does focus on those sports.
- david927 16y agoI think this is a great criticism of Silicon Valley, in general. It used to be filled with nerds who wanted to change the world. Now it's filled with hackers who want to get rich. Let me quote the author again: They’re creating "bread and circuses" ... apps that are wildly popular, infinitely entertaining, and exactly what people want. The only problem is that they don’t really do anybody any good. They’re not doing what technology is intended to do: Solve problems. I'm ringing the bell on Silicon Valley. It's days are not up, but they're numbered. Because it doesn't understand this, it will begin its slow descent to become part of Hollywood. And real innovation will happen elsewhere.
- MarkSweep 16y agoWas silicon valley really originally about changing the world? It is my understanding that the customers for integrated circuits during the 70s and earlier were primarily the military and large corporations. While delvoping technology for those sort of companies may be more "real", it hardly seems like that sort of work would be any less profit-driven. Also I would guess that the prominence of silly start-ups that are based on "game mechanics, addiction, self-reference, and narcissism" is made to appear larger because these sorts of companies need large numbers of people to be aware of them. Start-ups that create products that are not used by the general public probably will not seek publicity and thus you are less likely to read about them on tech crunch. I have interned at three start-ups over the last 4 years and none of them have ever been mentioned on Techcrunch, despite one of them being involved in some serious M&A action. But why would they be, since readers probably are not hugely interesting in moving silicon wafers around a fab and companies are unlikely to find customers for their protein analysis hardware. So before you lament that lack of "real" start-ups, consider the possibility that you just are not hearing about them.
- enko 16y ago> It used to be filled with nerds who wanted to change the world. Now it's filled with hackers who want to get rich. What about nerds who want to change the world, but know they'll have to get rich to do so?