3 ms·
I think they are perfectly comparable. If you were to convert all shares to cash, you could make every single purchase that was made within that country in a y
by wodenokoto 8y ago
I think they are perfectly comparable.
If you were to convert all shares to cash, you could make every single purchase that was made within that country in a year.
That tells you a lot about how much value you are dealing with.
It is similar to the physical volume of the market cap, if it was converter to cash.
- dredmorbius 8y agoActually ... no. Market price is based on the present level of supply and demand. Dumping all shares on the market would swamp demand with excess supply. The entire notion of market capitalisation has ... significant issues. Put in a different context, many advocates of asteroid mining treat ore prices as fixed. The reality is that dumping an astronomical quantity (literally!) on the market would have drastic impacts (non-astronomically). Pricing of extractive minerals has been recognised as problematic going back at least to Ricardo. See also: Spindletop, Dad Joiner, and the Harbord List.
- pixl97 8y ago> Dumping all shares on the market would swamp demand with excess supply. Yep, it's hard to see with the big numbers involved, but if you reduce it to smaller numbers it's easier to see (though less accurate). We have 10 shares of stock at $50, and we have 10 people in a population. 5 people own 2 shares each, 5 people own no shares. To see the entire value of the stock realized, the 5 people that have it would have to sell all their shares to the 5 that don't. Of course, in reality the 5 people that have it are generally a self selecting group, they tend to have the wealth and the stock, so in general there does not exist a market that can absorb the sale of all the stocks to new people, since people that have the stock are the ones that are most likely to buy more.
- wodenokoto 8y ago> Dumping all shares on the market would swamp demand with excess supply. But then it is not the comparison that is problematic, but the number, that you are claiming doesn't represent anything. You could also argue that we can't compare these numbers because GDP are not capturing all transactions.
- dredmorbius 8y agoWell, that is a rather well discussed matter, going back to at least Simon Kuznets. https://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=problems%20with%20gdp&btnG=Search&as_sdt=800000000001&as_sdtp=on https://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=problems%20with%20gdp&b...
- mkirklions 8y ago>If you were to convert all shares to cash, you could make every single purchase that was made within that country in a year. But if that actually happened, the price would collapse. Im back to the "They are not comparable" camp.
- wodenokoto 8y ago> But if that actually happened, the price would collapse. By that logic, you are really just saying that the market cap is an invalid number, and as such cannot be compared to anything.
- mrwebmaster 8y agoI agree, they are comparable. A stock can buy a flow for a specific period of time. Or: a flow, accumulated during a period of time, could buy a stock. For example, "if Netherlands would invest all of it GDP generated during one year, it could buy Apple". Debt (stock) to GDP (flow) ratio is very useful, because it allows to see the percentage of the yearly GDP that would be needed to pay 100% of the debt.