3 ms·
You know, people make bad comparisons all the time. My favorite one is the electricity sector, especially when it comes to renewable energy: people compare the
by littlestymaar 8y ago
You know, people make bad comparisons all the time.
My favorite one is the electricity sector, especially when it comes to renewable energy: people compare the «amount of energy» produced by a solar plant (kWh), to the «amount of energy» consumed by a household (also in kWh). But this comparison is pointless (as long as we don't have ways to efficiently store electricity power) because there's no way you could supply a household with the electricity the solar plant produce: when the solar plant produces its «energy», the household doesn't consume much (if anything since most people aren't home at day) and when the household consumes electricity, the plant usually doesn't produce much because it's night or close to it. The only useful comparison unit when it comes to an electric grid is «power» not «energy» (as long as we have no storage), yet people uses energy as a comparison all the time …
- Ensorceled 8y agoThat’s a bad example of a bad comparison. It’s a very good, mostly accurate and approachable way to get people to understand how much electricity is generated by a specific method. Your demand that the mechanism for communicating “scale of electricity generation to the lay person” also include a mechanism for communicating the intricacies and vagaries of the power distribution system is ludicrous. Unless, of course, you have a better way to communicate this information to my mom, a non-technical 75 year old?
- littlestymaar 8y agoThe thing is: the problem is complex, and hiding this complexity behind a misleading comparison doesn't help. It makes people think they understand, and now they have an opinion on the subject. Too bad if this opinion is based on a completely flawed understanding due to a poor comparison. But people aren't that stupid, they can understand a lot of this complexity if you take 5 minutes to explain it to them (we're not talking about quantum physics here). I've been teaching how the grid works to people in jail, and I doubt your mom has less ability than the average French inmate. Of course five minutes is more than the 3 seconds it takes to use the fallacious «energy» comparison, and I think the problem lies more in the laziness of the knowledgeable people than the lack of technical knowledge of the general population.