6 ms·
The health-technology sector overlooks women and their bodies
- cimmanom 8y agoAnd this is also part of why gender diversity on technical teams matters.
- bsaul 8y agoi wouldn't blame the technical team for lack of "social diversity" if a stock trading app lacked an important feature. I would instead blame it on the people specifying the product features for not knowing their market ( and that usually is someone like a product owner). Note that i clearly agree that having more people inside the company actually representing the target audience is a plus, but that's just a general rule, it doesn't apply specifically to having more women in tech team ( which i think is a nice idea, if only because tech is an interesting field to work in and women shouldn't miss this opportunity)
- cimmanom 8y agoSo who’s to blame for more women dying in car crashes than men because there were no female crash test dummies? Don’t you think that having women on the development teams might have helped catch the fact that voice recognition software didn’t recognize female voices before the software ever made it to QA, rather than after release?
- bsaul 8y agoAbout car crash dummies: i know nothing about that field, but i suppose crash test dummies are build to represent the "most average human being", gender neutral. The fact that women are a subcategory that require specially manufactured dummies is i think a scientific discovery. Not something the average person would have guessed... I suppose there are other subcategories ( obese peopl, old people, short people) that probably would benefit for custom made crash test.. On female voices not being recognized i'd like you to show me the article that tell this story, because it seems so obvious that i'm having a hard time believing it ( looks like something as obvious as understanding people speaking with different accents).
- cimmanom 8y agoBut that just the thing. When only or mostly men are involved, “gender neutral” ends up being masculine (like the crash test dummies that had height and weight distributions like average men, not like average humans) because that’s our societal default. “Oh, women are a special subcategory.” No, we’re not. We’re half the fucking population.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- bsaul 8y agoLet's take the car dummy example. Do you think gender is one of the most relevant distinction if you'd really want to dig interesting clues from your team, that professionals wouldn't have thought of ? If i were a team leader honestly i wouldn't care about gender first. I'd be more interested in recruiting people from different weights, sizes, ages, maybe even races, and medical backgrounds first. And then, maybe gender would come into play. For some problems gender is an important factor, for others it's not. The fact that this "gender" predicate divides the world into two half doesn't make it relevant per say. I could divide between blue eyes and brown eyes, or skin tan, or lactose tolerant, etc, and come up with fairmy big chunks. Now I do agree that differences between men and women are indeed so important that it's an very interesting criteria in many topics. Although for some reason i don't think that's the argument you want to base your reasoning upon.
- shimms 8y agoLike this one: https://makingnoiseandhearingthings.com/2016/07/12/googles-speech-recognition-has-a-gender-bias/ https://makingnoiseandhearingthings.com/2016/07/12/googles-s... AI/ML inherits the bias from it's trainers - this is pretty well accepted.
- ralusek 8y agoMaybe there would have been more testing on female voices if there were more female engineers, but that is sort of ancillary solution to a problem of poor product design and testing. It also fails to address the underlying problem that there are simply nowhere near an equal number of available female engineers as male engineers. Shooting for a goal of 50:50 ratio when that is not anywhere close to the ratio of the available candidates makes it mathematically impossible to not make other sacrifices...for what objective? Your claim is that there are things that female engineers bring to the table that male engineers do not. My claim is that there is nothing a male engineer can do on the basis of their gender that a female cannot, and the inverse is equally true. In fact, I can't imagine a more offensive argument than saying "we need more female engineers so that our app is better at handling women's periods."
- cimmanom 8y agoDid I say 50-50. I’m saying we should care about having any. Maybe male engineers and product owners could pay attention to female voices and menstrual science. But they didn’t. It’s much less likely that a woman working on these products would miss those issues.
- thaumasiotes 8y agoHow would female crash test dummies address the problem of women dying in car crashes more often than men? For any given car, women crashing in that car will die more often than men crashing in the same car, because women are much more fragile than men. Dummies will only let you measure the effect.
- Broken_Hippo 8y agoIt isn't really a case of "more fragile", but different body shapes, different center of gravity, and so on. Not to mention that if you are talking averages, the "average" test dummy could easily be built taller, with more muscle mass and a bit less regular fat (even at healthy weights) than the average woman is simply because men would tip the scale a bit upwards. I imagine these things cause differences in the way folks move in accidents. Airbags, for example: If breasts tend to get in the way, then the airbags aren't going to be as helpful for women or, alternatively, cause more harm to women simply because of breasts (I'm speculating the example, I don't know it to be true).
- shimms 8y agoPlease cite evidence that women are inherently more fragile than men.
- danShumway 8y ago> i wouldn't blame the technical team for lack of "social diversity" if a stock trading app lacked an important feature. I would. If you're building a stock trading app, why on earth shouldn't you hire at least one or two people on your design/development team that actually trade stocks and have experience with the current market? It's not even a question of social diversity; it's just that you'll catch so many problems if you do - I can't count the number of times at my last job we ran into technical decisions about performance and algorithms where we didn't know what the right decision was because our dev team wasn't familiar with how the software would be used. You can't user-test architecture, at least not without very long, very costly development cycles and refactors. It's valuable to be able to catch problems early. Even at a purely technical level, having a dev team that's unfamiliar with what you're building is a recipe for disaster.
- tqkxzugoaupvwqr 8y agoWhy can’t she report it as a usability bug? Instead she complains loudly to her readership. I guess Fitbit’s next step should be to recruit female testers to avoid Twitter mobs.
- pgeorgi 8y agoMaybe she did report it? A report may or may not result in a fix. A post like that might accelerate progress there (given some reach).
- danShumway 8y agoIf the company is big enough, complaining loudly to your readership is often the fastest way to report a bug and to get someone who can actually do something to look at it. Take a look at the most recent web audio stuff that happened in Chrome. Bugs had been sitting open in the tracker for months before the code got pushed into stable - dev team didn't do anything about it until prominent developers started calling them out publicly on Twitter and news sites started reporting on it. As a smaller example, I used to do API level maintenance on a software stack. I didn't get to prioritize whatever bugs I wanted - upper management did. I actually advised people who had breaking bugs not to just file something in the tracker, because I couldn't guarantee that I would be able to take time to fix it. On top of filing an issue, I told teams that had serious problems that they should go to a manager and explain that it was going to make them miss a release deadline. Then I'd be allowed to take time off of the more flashy features that looked good in press releases to fix their problem. There is at least a decent chance that somewhere on the Fitbit engineering team, someone is reading that article and saying, "finally we get to address this #?&x$ issue because now it's public enough to care about." > I guess Fitbit’s next step should be to recruit female testers Yeah, they should, because female testers are more likely to catch problems that will effect females. They should also hire blind testers to catch accessibility problems. They should also hire runners and joggers to test if their tracking is accurate in normal usage. I'm not sure if you meant this as a joke, having people who are similar to your end users test your product is basically business 101.
- bliker 8y agoThis is clearly due to lack of user testing.
- Broken_Hippo 8y agoThis is clearly a lack of research before the sub-par user testing.
- danShumway 8y agoSeriously, I don't know why this is such a hard problem for people. "We're building tax software. Should we get a tax consultant to look it over and identify problems?" "We're building a programming IDE. Should we get some programmers on our design team? Should we maybe eat our own dog food and have our programmers use it internally for development?" "We're building a screen reader. Should our QA team have some blind testers on it?" "We're building a product that we're marketing to women. Should women be involved in building it?" Sure you can get around these issues by doing extra market research, but in basically every other area of development we understand that it is an asset to have your designers and builders be intimately familiar with the problems you're trying to solve. The cheapest, most efficient way to make your design team intimately familiar with problems that women face is to hire women. It's no different than hiring security experts if you're building serverside software - you want some people on your team to be an early voice of reason; to be able to raise their hand early in a code review or a tech demo and say, "Hey, just so you know that's an XSS attack vector," or, "Hey, just so you know I've actually had periods that last longer than 10 days."
- Guthur 8y agoWhoa, so pushing a pram is only the proviso of a woman. This micro aggression can't stand the article should be rewritten immediately. I'm so...
- arrrg 8y agoNo one claimed that. If you read the linked article you will be able to plainly see that. Sexism can also include paying less attention or being ignorant of stereotypically “female” activities. That, in practice, pushing a pram is not at all gender specific doesn’t matter here, it’s the stereotype that does.
- Guthur 8y agoStrongly implied "Fitbit isn’t the only tech giant to have big gaps in their understanding of women’s lives. Journalist Alexandra Heminsley noticed that neither Apple Watch nor Fitbit let you log pushing a pram as exercise, despite the fact that everything from barre to Zumba was there already" For the record I don't actually care. I was mocking the current victim hood culture and this article follows very similar language patterns.
- tomelders 8y ago> Sexism can also include paying less attention or being ignorant of stereotypically “female” activities. What is a stereotypically female activity?
- arrrg 8y agoAny and all aspects related to child rearing, for example.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- tomelders 8y agoOk. I personally don't think that's a female activity, but I take your point that others might. That said, I don't have any children of my own. As such, I only have a vague idea about the challenges involved. I am without a doubt, ignorant to the reality of child rearing. Does that make me sexist?
- docdeek 8y ago"Journalist Alexandra Heminsley noticed that neither Apple Watch nor Fitbit let you log pushing a pram as exercise, despite the fact that everything from barre to Zumba was there already. Jogging prams are absolutely everywhere now...and yet, according to Apple and Fitbit, it’s not happening.” As a runner and a parent, this might annoy me. However, is it really a sign of (concious or unconscious) sexism? Don’t men run with prams in the US?
- cwmma 8y agoI'm bit sure I've ever seen a man in the stroller division of a race I've been at.
- dspillett 8y agoI see people with pushchairs regularly at the local park runs, both female and male individuals who are there on their own (with child, obviously) or in one case a couple who take it in turns to take the stroller or try for a PB. I think I see more solo men than solo women with pushchairs, though I've not paid that much attention so I might be noticing the men more due to them standing out to me because they breach some subconscious expectation/bias. Or maybe I notice more due to jealousy: one of the regulars is usually a minute or two faster than my best even with the pushchair! (context for reference: I'm in the UK, and a middle-aged, single, happily childless, male)
- bshimmin 8y agoOur local Park Run has two or three men who regularly run around with pushchairs, at least one of whom gets admirably impressive times. I have never seen a woman do it. There are usually a couple of hundred people running.
- arrrg 8y agoYeah, if pushing a pram is seen as a stereotypically “female” activity and because of tat further outside the lived reality of the men writing the software, then it could be sexism. I do agree, though, that this is more generally something indicating that diversity in teams working on software all kinds of people use is important. I think a father could just as well have helped out here, because I can’t imagine that you wouldn’t immediately think of pushing the pram as an activity you want to track if you were a parent heavily involved with your child. It’s obvious, really.
- ralusek 8y agoThere are many things about this article that I really dislike. 1.) The implication that a statistical outlier not being represented is something that would have been fixed by having more female engineers. How much of an outlier is it for a woman to have a period exceeding 10 days in length? 1 in 15? 1 in 100? Is it not relevant? Would the 14/15 women who are not themselves these statistical outliers be roughly just as likely as men to lack this information? Presumably they would have a chance to be exposed to it by family/friends/relationships, but isn't that the same for the men? This sounds like either a problem with the FitBit team having not done proper research, or this being such a statistical outlier that it's an understandable mistake. Do the programmers on a diabetes bloodsugar reader need to themselves have diabetes, or is it not reasonable to suggest that they should instead be as well informed as needed to build the product? 2.) The implication that the lack of employed female engineers has more to do with anything other than...the lack of female engineers. 3.) The fact that statistical outliers need to be represented in every application for the general public. If there was a nutritional application that didn't account for Celiac's disease, or a running app that didn't properly accommodate somebody's asthma, I'm not so sure that the right idea is to determine that this app needs to cover all such cases. There are market forces at work here, if there is a need for it, i.e. asthmatic runners who are unsatisfied with XYZ apps, then there is an opportunity. If you have longer-than-10 day periods, and FitBit doesn't change, you have a market opportunity. If it doesn't do well...there wasn't enough of a market. Or I guess we can just demand that all apps are built by diabetic asthmatic women to cover our bases.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- mcphage 8y ago> Presumably they would have a chance to be exposed to it by family/friends/relationships, but isn't that the same for the men? Well, how long is the longest period that your female family members have had? Is this a thing you discuss with them? > The implication that the lack of employed female engineers has more to do with anything other than...the lack of female engineers. You're bothered by the implication that thing have consequences? > The fact that statistical outliers need to be represented in every application for the general public. You mean the fact that period trackers need to be able to track periods?
- pgeorgi 8y ago> "Early voice-recognition software didn't always recognise female voices,” she says. “None of the developers had been female and no one thought to test out the technology on women.” So why didn't women build voice-recognition software? Developing software is not a regulated activity. It's simple to complain from the sidelines [edit: or push down-vote buttons].
- LTom 8y agoOne of the reasons for period tracking is identifying changes to one's menstrual cycle, which may indicate health issues.[1] So even if periods normally were to only last up to 10 days, not allowing to track for a longer period would impede that goal. In fact, this is even one the vague reasons Fitbit mentioned when it launched this functionality. [2] The functionality feels like a bit of an afterthought. [1] https://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/320758.php https://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/320758.php [2] https://www.theverge.com/2018/3/13/17113096/fitbit-watch-period-tracking-wearable-fitness https://www.theverge.com/2018/3/13/17113096/fitbit-watch-per...
- yabb 8y agoAs a female engineer and a feminist, if I were implementing this feature I would have obviously known that periods can last forever. Unfortunately given that Fitbit's engineering team is majority male, some male engineer is probably going to push a fix in response to this article that removes the explicit upper limit on period length while still using an int32 or int64 to represent it instead of using a big integer type as they should to represent periods lasting over 9,223,372,036,854,775,807 days which is possible if you are a really, really hardcore feminist.
- cup-of-tea 8y agoThis is the kind of humour that we should be able to enjoy here. Accept the patch allowing unlimited period lengths and laugh at this joke. Why does everything have to be so serious and flagged/downvoted etc.?
- cup-of-tea 8y agoWomen like this who hate men should just stop using technology created by men. Start with things like Fitbit that you don't actually need. Then work up to cars and other things. Show us how it's done because we clearly don't know how to do it.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- rimunroe 8y agoAt no point do I get the feeling that the author hates me. This feature sounds like no one who actually has a period (or maybe even knows someone who has them???) was involved at any stage. I think you have more to get over than the author.
- DonHopkins 8y agoMen who hate women tend to project a lot.
- cup-of-tea 8y agoThe author has made every effort to make it about men vs women, rather than just her vs Fitbit. I've "known" a great many women but had no idea a period could last a month. Even if it was built entirely by virgin men who really are clueless there is no reason for the tone in the article. If I don't know something, just tell me. Don't write a passive aggressive piece because I don't know about that period you had 2016.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- sctb 8y agoYou're not meeting the standards of discourse on this site. Because we've asked you many times to fix this, we've banned the account. We're happy to unban accounts if you email us at hn@ycombinator.com and we believe you'll use the site as intended.
- kowdermeister 8y ago> Only 40% of professional designers are women So the glass is almost empty. I get it.
- belorn 8y agoThe line which researchers here in Sweden define that a profession is gender segregated is if it has less than 40% of a single gender. It comes out to about 90% of the population, both men and women, work in gender segregated professions and only 10% work in the remaining gender equal professions which would include professional designers. If we set the bar higher than a minimum of 40% then we are quickly going into single digit percent of the population. There is very few professions with an exact 50/50 ratio.
- imarg 8y agoWhat is interesting, is this reply to the tweet mentioned in the article (https://twitter.com/JeremiahLee/status/1025424090184728576 https://twitter.com/JeremiahLee/status/1025424090184728576) where this former(?) fitbit employee says that actually there were women involved in this feature.
- brlewis 8y agoDisclaimer: I work for Fitbit, but don't speak for Fitbit. Thank you for bringing attention to this very important point. From the tweet: "FWIW this feature was led by women (product manager, head of product, engineering manager). I am not defending the design & I understand that it fails to meet your expectations. Fitbit isn't that big and the people there care a lot about helping people." A later reply by a current employee: "Also, the algorithm development was led by a woman." This is just another software flaw, not a demonstration of rampant sexism. I'd ask commenters here (in general, not replying to the parent comment) to curb their outrage. And if things like this really bother you, apply to one of our many open positions.
- imarg 8y agoYeah, as I said before in another comment I would be surprised "if the people that designed the Fitbit's period tracking feature did not include or at least consulted women". I take your comment (and the tweet I linked) as being correct about my assumption. As a non-American (I am European) I am always amazed about how easily things like that are attributed to gender (non) inclusion in the USA. On the other hand, as a male I have to always wonder if I find these kind of reactions over the top not because I am not American but because of my gender.
- brlewis 8y agoIn this particular case, the problem is that everybody thinks that if you include women you'll get menstruation right. This applies both to Fitbit assuming we didn't need to consult a gynecologist, and to outsiders assuming Fitbit must not have put women on the project. More generally, there is a lot of sexism, at least in the U.S., which makes people more inclined to see it everywhere...it's a natural human bias.