3 ms·
Does it seem weird to anybody else that a vendor would semi-blame the customer in public like this? I can't imagine seeing a statement like this from a Google o
by wpietri 8y ago
Does it seem weird to anybody else that a vendor would semi-blame the customer in public like this? I can't imagine seeing a statement like this from a Google or Amazon engineer.
It also doesn't seems to ignore a number of the points, especially how support was handled. I think it's bad form to only respond to the one thing that can be rebutted, ignoring the rest. And personally, I would have apologized for the bad experience here.
- xpaulbettsx 8y agoYa, tbh this is a really bad look and I thought the same thing. If you're building a product, Don't Do This.
- jazoom 8y agoI like hearing the other side of the story. I wish I got the other side more often.
- ickler9 8y agoWell, this is on the front page, the top comment is misinformation, the posters left out details that made them look bad, and they seem to be going on a smear campaign out of spite on every platform they have. at what point is any of this in good faith?
- wpietri 8y agoWhat makes you think it's not in good faith? As far as I can tell, Prashant Deva had a series of bad experiences on Azure, including significant downtime. He's mad, and he's saying so. From his perspective he was using it right; from Azure's apparently he was using it wrong. A difference in perspective isn't bad faith.
- ickler9 8y agoProbably the part where he doesn't actually ever say it's a difference in perspective- that's your take. He says AKS is terrible, etc, etc. You're giving him a benefit of the doubt, which I appreciate, but he's gone too far in his bias. Maybe underlying it is a real issue, that clearly hackernews wants to indulge, but the threshold has been crossed.
- wpietri 8y agoHe doesn't have to say it's a difference in perspective. He's giving his perspective. That's what blog posts generally are. I note that you don't say your comments here are just your perspective as you trash-talk him. Does that mean you're pursuing a smear campaign and not acting in good faith? Why should he be held to a standard you yourself aren't willing to follow?
- brudgers 8y agoSteve Jobs told customers they were holding their phones wrong, so, to me, not really.
- Cthulhu_ 8y agoJobs was a dick; Microsoft has PR and developer relations teams that are trained in how to provide feedback to their community.
- shaklee3 8y agoI would prefer a vendor responds publicly rather than request a private message. It's possible that one side was angry, and writing a blog post that makes it on HN will surely get a ton of negative attention. If that's the case, they should have the right to clear anything they'd like. I didn't read it as blame, but explanation.
- azurezyq 8y agoI think it's good to listen to both sides. But the response from Azure eng can be more professional. Customers have the right to do anything, maybe technically right or wrong. But the original post's attitude is more like blaming and throwing out random tech details, not explanation.
- ummonk 8y agoWhile it might be phrased in a way that implies the customer is partly to blame, the actual details would indicate the main problem was with Azure Kubernetes Service. Critical system daemons going down because the application uses too much memory is not a reasonable failure mode (and the AKS team rightfully fixed it).
- wpietri 8y agoExactly. The whole point of offering a service to the public is that you know more than other people. So of course customers will do wrong things, be confused, etc. In Microsoft's shoes, I would have strongly avoided anything that sounded like customer blame. E.g.: "We really regret the bad experience they had here. They were using the platform in a way we didn't expect, which led to an obviously unacceptable failure mode. We appreciate their bringing it to our attention; we've made sure it won't happen going forward. We also agree that some of the responses from support weren't what they should have been and will be looking how to improve that for all Azure users." The goal with a public statement like this isn't to be "right". It isn't even to convince the customer. It's to convince everybody else that their experience will be much better than what is hopefully a bad outlier. The impression I'm left with is that a) Azure isn't really owning their failures, and b) if I use their service in a way that seems "wrong" to them, I shouldn't expect much in the way of support.
- Drdrdrq 8y ago...and apparently forgot to notify customer of it, and in general communicate with customer better. I think this is the main reason for AWS lead. They simply treat customers right (well, better than G and MS anyway).
- rblatz 8y agoYet Azure is the top cloud provider, and AWS is #2.
- nemothekid 8y agoThey are number one because Microsoft doesn’t break out Azure and Office 365 revenue.
- wizardofmysore 8y agoNo. If the customer is at fault there is no problem in blaming them especially if they run a smear campaign.
- jschwartzi 8y agoWell, we really don't know what was said as the blog didn't actually provide any of the original communications. It's a he said she said thing at this point. Frankly the author comes across as having a huge axe to grind. That may be with good reason but it's hard for me to judge the quality of the Azure support when we never see any of their communications, just paraphrases.