3 ms·
> Cell phones, wifi, bluetooth, all would be impossible without the FCC It sounds like you need to read up on the vast regulatory difference between cell bands
by mindslight 8y ago
> Cell phones, wifi, bluetooth, all would be impossible without the FCC
It sounds like you need to read up on the vast regulatory difference between cell bands and wifi.
edit: I can't fathom why I'm being downvoted. Without the FCC we would have much faster wifi, not being confined to a few tiny slices of spectrum. But cell service is debatable. And radio astronomy would be fucked.
- wl 8y agoThe ISM bands are a shitshow. Some people legitimately need licensed spectrum.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- mindslight 8y agoI didn't say anything to the contrary. I'd personally like to see a lot more public spectrum (say half of what was reclaimed from that DTV switchover [0]). But I respect there are many applications that do need dedicated spectrum, hence my reference to radio astronomy. Basic emergency comms that want the least possible protocol complexity is another. It's just not a very informed opinion to think the FCC effected wifi/bluetooth, rather than having merely gotten out of the way. [0] Or, if concerned it would merely end up a permanently unusable swamp due to the propagation, at least run an initial experiment with a tiny slice.
- jessaustin 8y agoYes, by all means take small steps. Those would still be progress! We might learn something about the right and wrong ways to deregulate spectrum. Up until now we've just been assuming that it can't be done, despite the WiFi's clear example of it being done well.
- jessaustin 8y agoIt is sort of hilarious that WiFi would be presented as an argument for FCC... Eventually radio astronomy will take place in space, right? Besides, only really old-fashioned stuff like AM/FM can really interfere with astronomy more than a tiny increase in the overall noise level.
- autocorr 8y agoThis is unfortunately not true for radio astronomy, the receivers are very sensitive, and will show interference from even a simple LCD screen within a mile. At frequencies below 1 GHz, the VLA often has to throw away more than half of the data due to interference. Most observations happen outside of the protected bands, nature uses the whole spectrum, although the absolute most important bands are protected, like the 1420 MHz hydrogen line. For comparison, if you put a cell phone on the surface of the moon, it would be the brighter than the brightest natural source at 2 GHz. FM bands are wiped out, but some experiments where it is really important (the epoch of reionization) are put specifically in Western Australia or South Africa where it's wasteland and they protect the sites from interference.