3 ms·
As someone who's lived in four of the New England states I'd just like to remind everyone that the style of government that the author is idolizing tends to res
by dsfyu404ed 8y ago
As someone who's lived in four of the New England states I'd just like to remind everyone that the style of government that the author is idolizing tends to result in a very strong local government that gets up in everyone's business. Three states and many towns across New England were settled by people who decided that their ancestors didn't cross an ocean and risk starving so a bunch of jerks they don't agree with could tell them what to think, how to worship and generally micromanage their life.
There's two sides to every coin.
- TomMckenny 8y ago>There's two sides to every coin. That some would move to set up their own free community is a good thing. A great luxury for low populations. But there were quite a few rival and very undemocratic "ideal" communities. The most common was the plantation. Another was the theocracy. Thankfully history (mostly) deprecated these and the ideal that survived is the town-hall, its flaws minuscule in comparison.
- WalterBright 8y agoThere's no shortage of people today trying to tell everyone else how to live, and trying to enforce it.
- xkcd-sucks 8y agoYeah but the scope of getting up in errybody's business is limited to business that local people care about. As opposed to larger governments getting up in business that people far away care about. Case in point: In my small NE town, there has never been a discussion of "bathroom bills", but the town does care about roosters and water rights. A larger, neighboring town does care about "bathroom bills", spending tons of time and energy arguing over them, and has no concept of what it's like to live next to roosters or rely on well water. I would not like to have that group of people to have any say over the operation of my town, either as republican constituents or as direct voters.
- dsfyu404ed 8y ago>Yeah but the scope of getting up in errybody's business is limited to business that local people care about. Which varies by town but in some towns it's a heck of a lot more than it needs to be and generally speaking correlates with proximity to salt water and inversely with driving time to Boston. Nobody's arguing over bathrooms, they're too busy trying to prevent the local Indian convenience store owners from building another store on a property they just got because the alcohol to other stuff ratio in their existing store offends the sensibilities of the people calling the shots. This is actually what's going on in the town where one of my relatives lives. I could go on and on about how farcical it is but I'll save you the reading. >but the town does care about roosters and water rights. A larger, neighboring town does care about "bathroom bills", spending tons of time and energy arguing over them, and has no concept of what it's like to live next to roosters or rely on well water. I would not like to have that group of people to have any say over the operation of my town, Funny you should mention that. If you ask most people from Boston they probably don't know that the state goes beyond 495. Of course the rest of the state has to follow the state level rules made in Boston for Boston (for the most part). The states to the north aren't so bad but MA is right up there with IL and NY when it comes to one bunch of people in one city calling the shots for everyone else.