8 ms·
I know some people chafe at the thought of tech companies self-censoring their platforms but they should be allowed to prevent their platform from becoming a pl
by tootie 8y ago
I know some people chafe at the thought of tech companies self-censoring their platforms but they should be allowed to prevent their platform from becoming a place decent people don't want to be. Jones isn't just an opposing viewpoint, he's a hateful lunatic. And no, that's not a slippery slope.
- Sniffnoy 8y ago> And no, that's not a slippery slope. I can't say I have any problem with this particular move, but man, you can't just assert that as if that's an obvious fact.
- Sharlin 8y agoI’m not sure where exactly this particular Schelling fence stands, but it’s safe to say Alex Jones is on the other side of it.
- zellyn 8y agoI thought they asserted it as if it were an obvious opinion. I guess you're asserting that they didn't…
- themagician 8y agoHe's right though, it is fact.
- tootie 8y agoAlex Jones spreads absolute hateful nonsense with no journalistic value whatsoever. There isn't a clear border between a dissenting opinion and raving lunatic but there is a border and he is very far across it. Take the US criminal standard of evidence: beyond a reasonable doubt. He is a lying lunatic beyond a reasonable doubt.
- buboard 8y agoStill , thats not a valid argument, it's complete red herring ['not a slippery slope' vs 'alex jones is bad' :L unrelated - i kinda lose faith when i see lack of basic logic here]
- unimpressive 8y agoThere was a recent interview with Senator Ron Wyden where he lamented that tech companies are unwilling to use their legal freedom to police their platforms: """Let’s go all the way back to 1996 and talk about Section 230. I think historians are completely in agreement that this is the law that made the internet what it is today. We thought it was going to be helpful. We never realized it was going to be the linchpin to generating investment in social media. We envisioned that the law would be both a sword and a shield. A shield so that you could have this opportunity, for particularly small and enterprising operations to secure capital, and then a sword [by allowing them to moderate without facing liability over the practice], which said you’ve got to police your platforms. And what was clear during the 2016 election and the succeeding events surrounding Facebook, is that technology companies used one part of what we envisioned, the shield, but really sat on their hands with respect to the sword, and wouldn’t police their platforms.""" https://www.theverge.com/2018/7/24/17606974/oregon-senator-ron-wyden-interview-internet-section-230-net-neutrality https://www.theverge.com/2018/7/24/17606974/oregon-senator-r... I think that what's happened here is a normalization of deviance. Moderation action that should have been taken a long time ago has now been delayed so long it will be painful. Instead of setting strong expectations about what is and isn't okay up front (like say, Hacker News); these companies have gotten lax and will now pay a hefty price to use the sword.
- TrevorAustin 8y agoSection 230 coverage made (and still makes) a ton of sense for passive hosting of content—it really would be unduly burdensome to require neutral hosts or search indexers to review every piece of content. What wasn't foreseeable 20 years ago is that protection shouldn't really apply to recommended content that the platforms' algorithms push forward onto users, especially in the case of something like YouTube where they auto-play. Those are editorial decisions made in the company's own voice, and you shouldn't be allowed to disclaim all responsibility for what your platform actively recommends.
- bcheung 8y agoSESTA and FOSTA punched huge holes in Section 230. Any site that allows user generated content or private messaging now is potentially liable if used for certain types of adult "activity".
- buboard 8y ago> decent people When 3 CEOs get to define who are "decent people" and when they control all 4 sides of the Overton window, you have a problem. They're just too big
- craftyguy 8y agoMeanwhile, people are free to not use their platforms.
- gkoberger 8y agoYou're not wrong. But when the alternative is their platforms being used to spread misinformation and hate, there's not really many other options.
- buboard 8y agothey should be neutral. I find it funny how people go up in arms about net neutrality but do a 180 about the information platform providers in the level above ISPs.
- 8y ago
- mikeash 8y agoNot just a hateful lunatic, but one with a violent following. Harassment and death threats are not free speech, and he’s lucky he’s merely getting kicked off some corporate platforms instead of being arrested for his role in these things.
- smsm42 8y agoThere are a number of legit politicians who have violent followers. Remember James T. Hodgkinson, Bernie Sanders follower, who shot at members of Congress (one of the latest examples, there are many more in history) - of course Sanders is not responsible for the actions of this deranged individual. I've never seen any content by Alex Jones (and I'm not sure I ever will) but from what I heard, while he is a crackpot of the highest degree, he never advocated direct violence. And if this is true (I may be wrong since, as I admit, I have only third and fourth party knowledge of his content, and I am not sure I want to have a dip into that cesspool) then he should be allowed the same as Sanders - not to be held responsible for the actions of even bigger crackpots than he is, if he did not directly promoted them.
- mikeash 8y agoLooking through his page on WikiQuote, I see at least a couple direct calls to violence. And that’s just from those few statements the editors deemed worthy. I don’t understand why you’d write this response without looking into the man first. If you’d rather not examine him, I totally get it, but then maybe don’t defend him?
- smsm42 8y agoWikiQuote is a good idea, I didn't think Alex Jones would have a page there but here it is. But the worst I could see is "I will STUMP your head in if you start a fight with me, you thug scum" and "Stop being weak! And when you see a threat coming down on you, deal with it!". As political speech goes, I've heard worse from very mainstream politicians. Which ones do you think are the worst there? > I don’t understand why you’d write this response without looking into the man first. I did. I know who Alex Jones is. But of course I didn't read every single one of his rants, I have much better ways to spend my limited time on this Earth, thankyouverymuch. I also think if somebody argues for his exclusion from all major platform, they should already have the examples of the violent calls ready, just saying "yes, he did that, trust us, we wouldn't lie to you would we?" shouldn't be enough. > but then maybe don’t defend him? People still can't get an idea that demanding someone to be treated fairly is not the same as liking them or defending them. I mean, we're doing this thing for millenia, the Bible (and I mean the old, Jewish one, not even the newer one) talks about just courts - for criminals, not for good nice people - as one of the basic requirements, and we still don't get it through that being just to someone and defending someone is not the same. How long will it take? Will the collective conscience in year 9000 get it?
- mc32 8y agoI dunno. I am not a fan of conspiracy theorists who continuously spread information known to be false; however, the reason posted is problematic: “we want everyone using facebook to feel safe”. Sorry, but feeling safe is very contextual, imprecise and can change from setting to setting. Insofar as “glorifying violence”. Let’s see how they come down on censoring holywood blockbuster movies. Let’s see how sincere they are about that.
- mikeash 8y agoDo you need a precise definition to know that a lunatic who incites harassment and death threats toward shooting victims is on the wrong side of the line?
- mc32 8y agoI do think they need to be more precise. And they need to address both sides, both extreme right and extreme left conspiracists who incite violence. But the current language is very vague and only emboldens people seeking censorship and coddling.
- Brockenstein 8y ago> And they need to address both sides, both extreme right and extreme left conspiracists who incite violence. Who says they don't? Every time a right wing nut gets chopped you need an equivalent pound of flesh from the left? This just seems like whataboutism to me. >But the current language is very vague and only emboldens people seeking censorship and coddling. People always seek whatever they want, it doesn't mean they will get it. Sort of like how you're seeking absolute fairness in equality in corporate censorship. Good luck...
- mc32 8y agoIts not whataboutism. If police in some latam country mostly gets its “mordidas” from foreign tourists, and complaining it mostly happens to tourists is not whataboutism toward the locals.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- threatofrain 8y agoAlso, the promotion of a message is as much free speech as the refusal to promote a message. Facebook and other entities granted free speech should be free to not promote certain messages.
- guilhas 8y agoYes a lunatic, which begs the question what are we doing so wrong, that we need to censor something like this.
- gspetr 8y ago> And no, that's not a slippery slope. And yes, it most certainly is when mainstream politicians get banned. https://www.nationalreview.com/corner/heng-gets-facebook-blocked/ https://www.nationalreview.com/corner/heng-gets-facebook-blo...
- tootie 8y agoThat was almost certainly blocked by an automated policy against gore for posting genocide scenes. These sites have an absolute avalanche of content to police and make mistakes pretty frequently which is why you can appeal and get the block overturned as this one has been. The video is on her FB page right now.
- gspetr 8y agoIt gets better. You cannot talk about un-persons. How good are your chances of getting unblocked unless you're a YT star? https://twitter.com/h3h3productions/status/1028047008144080896?s=19 https://twitter.com/h3h3productions/status/10280470081440808...