9 ms·
How Europe Learnt to Swim
- nubbins 8y agoThis may explain why so many otherwise highly developed non western courtries don’t reach swimming to everyone. England and France were big naval powers of the time and had much more reason than just watersports to mandate swimming skills for the populace.
- j9461701 8y agoHistorically sailors were actually quite bad swimmers. The thinking was that any man who fell overboard was basically dead anyway, as the ship was unlikely to be able to turn around and get him before he drifted away (sailing boats aren't exactly precision vessels). All swimming enabled a man to do was prolong his suffering, treading water in the middle of the open ocean for a few days before dying of exposure. More-over, much of British naval strength was press ganged and an inability to swim meant once aboard the men were easier for officers to control. They were stuck there, and couldn't jump ship and swim to shore to escape their bondage.
- jessaustin 8y agoUnless in very close formation with other ships, it's no problem to let a long rope trail a big sailing ship. Leaving men overboard to die was only barbarity. They went back for the captain's favorite cabin boy...
- toomanybeersies 8y ago> Historically sailors were actually quite bad swimmers It's not just historically. A lot of people who work on the water these days in developing countries are still terrible swimmers. One of my friends was a dive instructor in Indonesia for a few months, and apparently the guys skippering their dive launches couldn't swim. Since it was Indonesia, they also didn't bother with wearing life jackets. I don't know how they managed to spend their life living on an island and not learn how to swim. Apparently Fijians are also terrible swimmers. It just doesn't make sense to me. Obviously they aren't going to swim between the islands, but it seems like a fairly essential life skill when boats are your main method of transport.
- adrianratnapala 8y agoSwimming is overwhelmingly (though not entirely) a recreational thing and mostly found in rich countries. A few professionals in poor countries know how to swim, dive and do all sorts of things. But everyone else has more important things to do than to learn how to swim. And swimming is something you should either learn to do fairly well, or not do at all. Most poor mothers will let their kids play soccer on a quiet street -- but they will balk at letting 'em swim unless they get real training.
- peteretep 8y ago> Historically sailors were actually quite bad swimmers. The thinking was that any man who fell overboard was basically dead anyway, as the ship was unlikely to be able to turn around and get him before he drifted away This may be true, but doesn't pass the sniff test. There are many situations with small boats (to and from the shore, other ships) and when the boat is stationary when being overboard would be easily remedied.
- macintux 8y agoA small boat can stop immediately and recover someone in normal circumstances. Even those who can’t swim should be able to stay above water long enough to be rescued in such a situation.
- c2h5oh 8y agoEven a small sailboat will need to do 3 turns and position itself against the wind when approaching person in water. That takes long enough for someone who can't swim to drown even under perfect weather conditions.
- macintux 8y agoI thought the context was the rowboats used to ferry people to/from ocean-faring ships.
- eftychis 8y agoThis really depends on the area of origin. Greek sailors , for instance, were really good swimmers on average (recall Greece comprises several islands with "short" distances; fishing and sponge diving were/are also a side job for sailors and swimming was certainly part of a child's entertainment (a good source here is 19 century and later literature). I am not sure about the argument that falling in the water was a death sentence so that is the reason swimming was unnecessary. Consider that naval life for instance after the 14th century had a high accident rate. In such cases, being an above good swimmer is a highly desirable skill. I think the main reason for the lack of swimming was British and French sailors were "conscripted" in 18-19 centuries [0], and the average citizen at the time did not leave close to shore. At the time not living in close proximity to the sea practically meant, due to travel being a luxury of time (especially during the pre-enlightenment, i.e. feudalism, era), that you never learned to swim as a kid. That places a high-learning curve on an individual who does not have the luxury for such an investment. (Tried to find some credible research and reference; was disappointed with the material; Here is an article on the learning vantage point of an adult https://adequateman.deadspin.com/an-adults-guide-to-learning-to-swim-1718027248 https://adequateman.deadspin.com/an-adults-guide-to-learning...) Thus my point is that Feudalism [1] essentially removed access to the sea to people in mainland/central Europe during pre-adulthood, by land-locking families and later eras (industrialism) perpetuated this trend. Thus swimming became even more of a luxury, which is inline with the existence of a written manuals (certainly not aimed for the average citizen), that seem to focus on basic familiarity with the water. These seem similar to other luxury manuals at the time, such as fencing. Then the average sailor from these regions did not have prior familiarity with water. The time period the article focuses on is a post-Byzantium and post Venician era. I think the article kind of jumps ahead and focuses not on Western Europe but only on North and Central Europe. What was the "swimming state" of Roman era Germania or Britain? How can one draw conclusions about Northern Europe from the lack of access to baths in Rome? The reasoning of the article leaves a lot to be desired there. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Impressment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Impressment [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feudalism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feudalism
- baud147258 8y agoThere's one little problem with your argumentation: most of the population was living either along the shoreline or along a river, which would allow access to large bodies of water. And sailor recruitment was massively done in coastal cities.
- robaato 8y agoGrew up in a fishing village in north east Scotland - many of the trawlermen could't swim for similar reasons.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- User23 8y agoI have a soft spot for the aquatic ape hypothesis, even if it is rather ludicrous it’s just so entertaining.
- gadders 8y agoIt's one of those things you want to be true.
- ggm 8y agoA common tragedy in Australia is recent migrants, going to the beach, not understanding "the rip" and drowning. These migrants can come from anywhere. Africa, Asia, Europe. The commonality is that they have at best, 25m or 50m swimming proficiency. They have never swam in open water, experienced tidal pull, waves, uneven rocky shorelines. At various times, there have been campaigns to get them trained up. Its a short, sad life to emigrate, hit the beach and die. (a second common fatality is rock fishing without an anchor or a life vest but thats Off Topic)
- pjmlp 8y agoSadly it happens with tourists in the Portuguese coast as well, which never got to swim with the Atlantic waves or sudden change of underwater currents.
- Symbiote 8y agoThe waters surrounding Europe are varied; in from England so I was taught about rip tides and strong currents, but someone from near the Baltic or Mediterranean Sea might simply not know. I once had an Danish teenager tell me "tides are an old viking thing". We were on a beach with a 6cm tide, I'm more used to several metres.
- Kurtz79 8y agoAs an Italian, having spent all my life up to that point bathing in the tame and shallow coasts of the Mediterraneum, I remember vividly when pluging the first time in the Atlantic in Figueira da Foz :) Even in a tourist beach, the strength and sudden depth of the ocean was so different from what I was used to.
- baud147258 8y agoI remember being impressed by how strong the wave were and also how cold the water was, compared to the air temperature.
- barking 8y agoI'm used to the Atlantic but I had one of my scariest moments on an Algarve beach and I've since heard others say the same.
- Tharkun 8y agoIn Belgium at least, swimming proficiency is rapidly declining. Can't remember the numbers, but many children can no longer swim. Some schools have changed their programmes and have lowered the bar from the traditional 1KM in breast stroke or front crawl and are now basically teaching kids how not to drown. The cause, from what I remember, is a serious shortage of public pools. Many older pools have had to close because they can't meer water quality/hygiene standards, and hardly any new pools are being built. The sad result is that kids are now horrible swimmers.
- phobosdeimos 8y agoImmigration doesn't help. Swimming isn't really something people do in Iraq or Afghanistan. And boys and girls can't swim in mixed groups. Every summer is now filled with news of kids drowning- we are back were we started a hundred years ago.
- nolok 8y ago> Immigration doesn't help. Swimming isn't really something people do in Iraq or Afghanistan. And boys and girls can't swim in mixed groups. ? It is completly irrelevant, the proportion it represent is next to none. For your reference > The largest group of immigrants and their descendants in Belgium are Italians, with more than 450,000 people, which is well over 4% of Belgium's total population. The Moroccans are the third-largest group, and the largest Muslim ethnic group, numbering 220,000. The rest consists mostly of French-speaking people from Brussels, Turks, Kurds, Dutch, French, Portuguese, Spaniards, Greeks, Bosniaks, Algerians, Congolese, Vietnamese, Poles, Indians, and Guineans (around 23% of Belgium's population is of non-Belgian origin). Moroccan people swim just fine. I really do wonder how can people have that idea on their mind at all time even in cases like this where it doesn't even begin to be in scope.
- phobosdeimos 8y agoBecause swimming is no longer publicly funded and mandatory at schools. Which leaves it at the discretion of parents. Is it racist to point out that asylum seekers and migrant children are over represented in drowning? Swimming is something that needs to be taught.
- Raed667 8y agoI have lived my entire life never more than a 10 minute drive to a beach. I can barely float. But once you reach a certain age the social stigma of it will prevent you from even trying, I have been looking to learn but most places I found are oriented towards very young kids and nothing for the 20-something people that need to catch-up
- Steve44 8y ago> But once you reach a certain age the social stigma of it will prevent you from even trying, Are you sure about that? There are a lot of people who worry about going to the gym , concerned that everyone else will be staring at them. No one [except for the very rare hole] is bothered about what you're doing, they are just getting in with their workout. I'd expect swimming to be the same. Our local pool has various sessions for beginners, both young and old. Normally the pool is separated into three lane sections, fast, medium, and splashing around. Any 'stigma' you do perceive isn't worth bothering about - it's their problem and not yours.
- Raed667 8y agoThe stigma is internal I know. But usually beach time is with friends and acquaintances, people that know how to swim and don't understand at all my experience.
- philbarr 8y agoI would think if you said, "I don't know how to swim, so I'm going to learn," good friends and acquaintances would be massively supportive?
- Raed667 8y agoYes of course, but that puts me under the spot and everyone becomes an improvised teacher. Its just a combination of social pressure and stress with a stressful situation. My guess is to make it more sterile and professional by learning alone with a coach.
- INTPenis 8y agoIs it really worth while to try and pinpoint a time when swimming was forgotten? My reasoning is that in a world where people are born, work and die in one place there is a smaller chance of them ever needing to swim. Only coastal people really need to swim and even then, as the article states, mostly if they harvest aquatic resources. So in other words. As long as global communications have been lacking humans have been living very localized lives and not had the need to swim. Why then try and pinpoint a specific time when we "forgot" to swim? Doesn't make sense to me. And yes I know strontium analysis show that humans could migrate a long way even in ancient times. But they were usually migrating over land. With the exception of small groups of humans during relatively small windows of time who aided in colonizing islands like the british isles or south east asian islands, people who weren't involved in the aquatic industries mostly moved across land. I guess the article is trying to say that humans moved away from coastlines as agriculture became more efficient. And therefore forgot how to live near the coast.
- wyattpeak 8y agoWhy is knowing any history important? The Western Empire's collapse in 476 is considered a major and important event in world history, but it's knowledge is of conceivable value to any future human endeavour. We value it because we like knowing where we came from. To the question of obviousness - lots of things are obvious but wrong. It was obvious that Earth was at the centre of the universe. It was obvious that heavier-than-air craft couldn't fly. It was obvious that the aether existed. Studying obvious things is important.
- _ph_ 8y agoAs waterways were the only efficient means of transportation before the age of trains, you will find most larger cities in Europe near a river or lake or at least small waterway. And beyond that, there is a plenty of lakes and small ponds. So I would guess rather 90% of the population lives and lived close to a place where they could swim.
- 1_800_UNICORN 8y agoLate to this thread, but I loved this article because it put something into perspective for me... my New England boarding school had a swimming requirement, and was proud of its longstanding tradition of requiring all graduates to be able to swim. It makes sense given the context of when it was started and the extent of people's ability to swim.
- dingoegret 8y agoAncient Greeks were not Europeans. Ancient Greeks were a combination of Levantine and Anatolian peoples. Modern Turks and Lebanese have more in common genetically to ancient Greeks than today's Europeans. The romanticizing of Greeks as European is plain Eurocentric revisionism.
- lvoudour 8y agoI'm sorry but this is an absurd comment. How do you define Europeans? North/western only? The continent's name is ancient Greek and, while the eastern borders may have changed, there is no point in time where the greek mainland was not considered part of it even in ancient times. And what the hell do genetics have to do with a geographic designation?