22 ms·
Study Finds Increased Incarceration Has Marginal-To-Zero Impact on Crime
- SamReidHughes 8y agoThis is a nice data point in how crazy a "study" can be in how it abuses statistics to detach itself from reality. With a billion variables to control for, you can find many that seemingly account for trends in crime. Basically, locking people up prevents them from committing crimes for that duration. For anything besides organized crime, that's going to reduce crime by removing whatever crimes they'd commit.
- dllthomas 8y ago> For anything besides organized crime, that's going to reduce crime by removing whatever crimes they'd commit. That doesn't automatically follow. First, it ignores crimes committed while in jail, which is totally a thing - but at least hopefully the impact of those on "innocents" is reduced. Second, if punishment reduces honest opportunities and increases criminal opportunities (networking?), enough new criminal acts may follow to make up for the lost time.
- SamReidHughes 8y agoI think punishment can reduce honest opportunities when you go from zero jail to some jail, but once you're in prison for a year, my guess is the additional effect of having a record and disrupting your career is lower, with basic ways you'd expect like being out of contact with people you know, or being behind on technical training. Likewise, I think networking also doesn't account for much when your prison sentence is five or ten years instead of three. There's a big jump from zero to one, and a much smaller jump after. (Regardless, that's one reason why I explicitly excluded organized crime.) These are a few reasons why I think corporal punishment might be a good idea.
- pjc50 8y agoWhy go straight to corporal punishment rather than any of the other non-custodial solutions like electronic tagging? Or is the brutality part of the point?
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoBecause with corporal punishment once it's over you're done. You don't drop off the face of the earth for weeks to years like you do with prison. I'd totally take lashes in exchange for a reduced sentence.
- gnode 8y agoFines also have this quality.
- fundingshovel 8y agoOnly if you can afford to pay them. Otherwise they linger for quite some time.
- gnode 8y agoEven in the case where a fine takes some time to pay, it doesn't exclude the offender from society while they're paying it.
- pimmen 8y agoThe biggest problem I have with corporal punishment is the same with capital punishment; I could never live knowing a not 100% effective justice system harms or kills innocent people, and I'm supporting it by electing the leaders and paying the money to implement it. An incarceration focused on rehabilitation rather than punishment is something i think would work a lot better, I could at least stand sending innocent people to such a place.
- megaman22 8y agoIn some ways, I do think corporal punishment is more humane. Given the option of twenty lashes or a year in jail, sign me up for the cat-o-nines. Time is precious, and pain is fleeting.
- pjc50 8y agoYou've overlooked the "incarceration increasing crime" factors: > "Incarceration is not only "an expensive way to achieve less public safety," but it may actually increase crime by breaking down the social and family bonds that guide individuals away from crime, removing adults who would otherwise nurture children, depriving communities of income, reducing future income potential, and engendering a deep resentment toward the legal system."
- Arnt 8y agoRight. Put crudely: Put someone in jail and he's not going to be around to rob anyone. But he's also not going to be around to talk sense into his kid brother.
- dzdt 8y agoNor is he around his grandma for her to talk sense into him; instead he is around a bunch of career criminals. Nor is he around his children, making a stable household for them to grow up focusing on school and building their own futures.
- king07828 8y agoImprisonment doesn't always rehabilitate and is perhaps linked to not properly weighting the reactions of others and long-term consequences that are in response to one's own actions. I wonder what the effects would be of requiring inmates to handwrite or type a 400 word essay (i.e., just over a page, written from scratch, no cut and paste, each inmate has to write their own) every day responding to the stimulus of "What did you do today to improve your life and the lives of those around you?". Any response is sufficient, even if it is off topic or similar to prior responses. I'd be curious to learn if the inmates would begin to more properly weight others' reactions and long term consequences.
- kartan 8y ago> With a billion variables to control for, What if I told you that to imprison citizens for small crimes causes them to commit a more serious crime in the future? Does that changes your conclusion? Your over-simplification does not make sense. And assuming that the people that did the study are just blatantly incompetent without any information is very presumptuous.
- furyg3 8y ago> Basically, locking people up prevents them from committing crimes for that duration. [...] that's going to reduce crime by removing whatever crimes they'd commit. You're making a lot of assumptions here. 1) There is no crime in prison. 2) The imprisoned would have kept on committing crime for their total sentence if they were not in jail. 3) Prisoners 'return' to the world committing the same type/volume of crimes that they were committing when they went in. For #1: There is crime in prison, a whole lot of it, and (even if you don't have sympathy for criminals) it's bad for society; people may come out worse off than they went in, driving crime up further. Jail is an intense experience, and it seems like the skills that you develop while 'surviving' in jail may not be so constructive for society when you're released. For #2: As a kid my friends and I made a lot of stupid mistakes and some pretty bad decisions. Purely arbitrary factors (race, affluence, geography, etc) meant that none of us were ever locked up for them. We had the opportunity to correct our behavior, grow out of it. Had we have been punished harshly, it's likely that that our bad behavior would have continued. This is due to #1 (exposure to crime/criminals in prison, and contact with the justice system), but also loss of opportunities, and probably a different exposure or experience with drugs. For #3: The above two points lead to the possibility that people who come out of jail are more likely to engage in more or worse criminal activity when they're released than when they went in. So while there need to be consequences for crime, it's not at all evident that increased incarceration, certainly the way we are doing it, would lead to reduced criminal activity.
- skate22 8y agoWell for my family member who was/is a heroin addict, 6 months in jail meant 6 months of not stealing from her family. 6 months of not neglecting her kid. 6 months of sobriety to reflect on where her life was going. She did not stay clean, and I'm sure we can do better as a society to rehab our people, but for 6 months she was limited in the damage she could do to those around her. I'm pretty conflicted on the topic
- emiliobumachar 8y agoHow could one possibly not neglect one's kid while in jail? Presumably someone or some institution stepped in, probably the family. How much was the jailing necessary for the kid to get this help?
- matt4077 8y agoControlling for confounding factors is required when such factors exist. To use it as an argument to attack the study is rather bold, considering not correcting would actually be statistical malpractice. If you believe confounding factors make it impossible to use empirical methods to study the subject you're just giving up on scientific method. Because your alternative seems to be a few slogans that claim to be "common sense", but are really just a projection of your moral preferences into a causal model. Fortunately, policy professionals are not giving up on evidence-based decision-making quite as quickly.
- zamalek 8y agoBecause incarceration is penitentiary, which means criminals are made to pay for their crimes - not to be rehabilitated. There other countries where incarceration works, for example Norway [1] - primary because they focus in rehabilitation. Incarceration is not the problem, the typical opinion of the purpose of incarceration is (justice through revenge). Incarceration is 100% effective for what America wants it to achieve: penance. [1]: https://m.phys.org/news/2016-08-norwegian-prisons-criminal.html https://m.phys.org/news/2016-08-norwegian-prisons-criminal.h...
- dragonwriter 8y ago> Incarceration is 100% effective for what America wants it to achieve: penance. “Punishment”, perhaps. It's far less than 100% effective for penance, which is voluntary, self-imposed, and done as an outward sign of genuine acceptance of responsibility and desire to make amends.
- zamalek 8y agoWrong choice of words, you're right.
- SamReidHughes 8y ago"Expiation" might be the word you're looking for.
- gnode 8y agoI would say that "expiation" is not a suitable word. Incarceration neither compensates those who are wronged, nor does it atone / redeem -- the incarcerated person is still typically regarded a criminal / felon upon release.
- ilovetux 8y agoThis, a thousand times! Our criminal justice system is in fact based on penance, but forced penance is a flawed concept. In order to get a lighter sentence (or later parole) perpetrators are expected to show penance for what they did, but they are coached in what to say so it is usually a lie which causes a rift between society and the offender which is almost irreparable. This follows a line of "counter-culture" mentality, an us-vs-them mind-set which is divisive and self-reinforcing. The same problem comes with the war on drugs, if someone experiments with drugs at a young age and consequentially finds that they like drugs then they are forced into a counter-culture where escape is difficult at best. Edit: removed some superfluous words for readability.
- pytyper2 8y agoHow could the opposite ever be true, most incarcerated are not there for life and when they get out they get shit on by the rest of us. Post incarceration opportunities that lead to yearly incomes above the poverty line are reduced 10x probably more. I'm not saying we shouldn't jail people but jail should be like forced education unless your jail term is for life.
- cubano 8y agoWhat good is forcing someone to get an "education" when corporations refuse to give decent paying jobs with benefits to ex-cons?
- pytyper2 8y agoThey don't offer decent paying jobs because the odds are that if you are a con you don't have the skills to hold the job and/or can't be trusted.
- clarkmoody 8y agoWe start with "paying your debt to society" as justification, then society remembers the debt forever.
- cubano 8y agoSmart, well-meaning people on boards such as this refuse to see the Prison Industrial Complex for what it really is...a jobs program for police, courts, judges, jails, prisons, and of course, lawyers and politicians. One group "increased incarceration" definitely has a non-marginal positive impact on are all-of-the-above. Can you show me any examples, anywhere in history, where a group that directly benefits from and controls the entry level and duration of access have ever decided to lower their wages and put at jeopardy their livelihoods? Because at the heart of it, that's the real effect that decreasing incarceration will have...closing jails, firing police officers, lowering ridiculous attorney fees, and shutting down county court complexes. And we are surprised when the very people whom benefit from the status quo don't see things the way we do?
- ransom1538 8y agoThis. One of the best comments I have ever read. In the south you also need to account for the lack of voting power of African Americans. %30 of African Americans can’t vote in Florida because of their dealings with the “justice” system. http://www.orlandosentinel.com/news/politics/political-pulse/os-former-felon-voting-rights-20170223-story.html http://www.orlandosentinel.com/news/politics/political-pulse...
- bilbo0s 8y ago"...%30 of African Americans can’t vote in Florida because of their dealings with the “justice” system..." I'm not a southerner. I'm certainly no Floridian. But I strongly suspect that's not a "coincidence". I think the current system was likely set up as a political "gimme" meant to appease Southerners.
- dragonwriter 8y agoIt's a state-by-state system. Whatever is set up in the South wasn’t set up to appease Southerners, it was set up by Southerners to give effect to their desires.
- 8y ago
- jothezero 8y agoThis is making a good case for death penalty.
- prolikewh0a 8y ago4%+ of people who receieve the death penalty are innocent. This is unacceptable. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/apr/28/death-penalty-study-4-percent-defendants-innocent https://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/apr/28/death-penalty-...
- casiotone 8y ago100% of people who receive the death penalty are murdered. This is unacceptable.
- ugotsta 8y agomurder: the unlawful premeditated killing of one human being by another. If a legal system grants the death penalty, it isn't murder under that legal system.
- ugotsta 8y agoThat same 4%+ would exist with or without the death penalty so the death penalty isn't the problem. It should be unacceptable that any innocent people suffer under false judgement.
- arcticbull 8y agoAh yes, the old "beatings aren't working, BEAT HARDER." Easier than a systemic rethink anyways.
- mberning 8y agoThis makes no sense. As far as I can tell they pulled property crime out of their definition of public safety, but left in the cost. This also flies in the face of the fact that the current era is one of the safest in history. I think many people are sympathetic to reform in the criminal justice system. It would be a good thing to do. Particularly laws around drugs and illegal substances. It also gets to the root of many of these problems. I think that’s a much better way to move the needle, rather than just looking at the money spent and deciding “well, this isn’t working based on my definition, so we might as well not do it”.
- gameswithgo 8y ago>This also flies in the face of the fact that the current era is one of the safest in history. Is it also one of the safest in history in other nations that have not increased their incarceration rates?
- edmccard 8y ago>Is it also one of the safest in history in other nations that have not increased their incarceration rates? Yes[1] [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crime_drop https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crime_drop
- gnu8 8y agoInteresting that there is no link between that page and the lead hypothesis, which seems to be gaining more credibility these days. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lead-crime_hypothesis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lead-crime_hypothesis https://www.motherjones.com/kevin-drum/2018/02/an-updated-lead-crime-roundup-for-2018/ https://www.motherjones.com/kevin-drum/2018/02/an-updated-le...
- SketchySeaBeast 8y ago> This also flies in the face of the fact that the current era is one of the safest in history. If this were solely limited to incarceration rates the United States would have the lowest crime rate in the world.
- SaintGhurka 8y agoWhile I'm sympathetic to this point of view, it's really hard to take seriously a conclusion like "no impact". California's murder rate peaked around 1994. Three-strikes sentencing was enacted that same year in CA and about a dozen other states. Are we to believe that the 50% decline in murders since then is not, at least in part, a result of the incarceration of repeat criminals? I guess we'll find out soon enough now that 3-strikes is being considerably softened.
- grandmczeb 8y agoProperty and violent crime rates started dropping in California in the early 90s[1], along with the rest of the country, before three-strikes was enacted. Crime in California has also declined at rates similar to states without three-strikes policies (e.g. Illinois). [1] http://www.ppic.org/wp-content/uploads/crime-trends-1.png http://www.ppic.org/wp-content/uploads/crime-trends-1.png
- SaintGhurka 8y agoUsing the same site you referenced, violent crime peaked around 1993, the year before three strikes. http://www.ppic.org/publication/crime-trends-in-california/ http://www.ppic.org/publication/crime-trends-in-california/ Also, the number of homicides specifically peaked in 1993 at 4,096 and dropped almost every year for the next 25 years. It looks like it bottomed out in 2014 and started climbing again. http://www.disastercenter.com/crime/cacrime.htm http://www.disastercenter.com/crime/cacrime.htm It's true that rates in other states dropped also. You mentioned Illinois who did not enact a three strikes law (but its neighbors did, as did the federal government). Note that it didn't see improvement on the same scale as California - and now Chicago's murder rate is so bad that it makes the national news almost every week. I really don't know that the halving of the murder rate should be credited to tougher sentencing, but it coincides pretty well - so well that when I see claims that they have zero effect I can't help but assume that the findings are agenda-driven. But tough sentencing laws are falling out of favor and being reversed - or partially reversed. Maybe the homicide rate will stay low and 3-strikes laws will be completely discredited.
- 8y ago
- glitcher 8y agoToo many politicians and voters are in the habit of ignoring facts and instead going with their gut feelings, even when the facts directly contradict their "feelings". And unfortunately fear mongering for votes can be very effective. Here's Newt Gingrich's classic "debate" between FBI crime statistics and his own "feelings". Notice particularly the language he uses to frame actual facts that don't agree with his ideology: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xnhJWusyj4I https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xnhJWusyj4I
- whack 8y agoI wonder how many people actually understood what the article is referring to when it says "increased incarceration". It's not referring to increased jail sentences for those who commit violent times. It's referring to the imprisoning of non-violent "criminals" such as marijuana dealers. > "Higher incarceration rates are not associated with lower violent crime rates, because expanding incarceration primarily means that more people convicted of nonviolent, "marginal" offenses (like drug offenses and low-level property offenses) and "infrequent" offenses are imprisoned." I'm all for legalizing marijuana and other soft drugs, but not for going easy on rapists and murderers. Do increased jail sentences have a deterrent effect? A quick Google search shows that the answer is yes, up to a certain point, and this makes perfect logical sense. If the punishment for committing armed robbery consisted solely of one day in prison, so many more people would give it a go. As you increase the sentence from one day to multiple years, you would weed out the less hardcore would-be criminals. We can debate the inflection point where the effects start to taper off. But there is no doubt that having some threat of jail time, has a extremely significant impact on crime. https://www.economist.com/free-exchange/2016/03/29/longer-jail-sentences-do-deter-crime-but-only-up-to-a-point https://www.economist.com/free-exchange/2016/03/29/longer-ja...
- downandout 8y agoWhenever this topic comes up, I like to link to this [1] study done by the ACLU. It is a study on people that have received life without parole for nonviolent offenses. It is truly shocking that US lawmakers have allowed even one of these sentences to happen. The "land of the free" is anything but. Here's one of the more salient quotes: "...thousands of people are serving life sentences without the possibility of parole for nonviolent crimes as petty as siphoning gasoline from an 18-wheeler, shoplifting three belts, breaking into a parked car and stealing a woman’s bagged lunch, or possessing a bottle cap smeared with heroin residue." [1] https://www.aclu.org/files/assets/111813-lwop-complete-report.pdf https://www.aclu.org/files/assets/111813-lwop-complete-repor...
- smallgovt 8y agoThe data show that areas with high incarceration rates generally have higher crime rates; and areas with lower incarceration rates generally have lower crime rates. The article then deduces that high incarceration rates CAUSE high crime rates when it seems blatantly obvious to me that the causation runs in the OPPOSITE direction. Areas with high crime rate cause high incarceration rates because as crime rate goes up, more people must be put in prison. I don't necessarily disagree with the article's agenda (to support prison reform) but the reasoning seems shockingly lacking. Also, the article mentions that the incarceration budget went up by 340% with no meaningful change to public safety, but fails to mention that inflation during the same time period was 240%....so the budget didn't really increase all that much.
- theShowdown55 8y agoWhy can't the focus ever be on the prevention of crime in the first place? These discussions always dissolve into the same cesspool of blaming prisoners and politicians. The government can never be relied on to fix things. The single biggest predictor of living in poverty or doing time in prison is growing up with no father around. 80% of prisoners today had no father in their life. Seems like we should be looking at things like that. I never shook those conversations here though. W have to empower single motherhood (heroism) and not discourage it here... Well look at where that has led us.
- wodenokoto 8y agoI thought it had positive impact on crime - that is, prison teaches petty thieves to become hardened criminals.
- warbaker 8y agoThis is just a correlation study, showing that states where incarceration went up did not simultaneously have decreasing crime rates. The study can't tell you what would have happened if that state had reduced incarceration rates. People who get cancer treatment are far more likely to have cancer than the general population. This does not mean that reducing cancer treatment rates will reduce cancer rates!
- warbaker 8y agoThis is just a correlation study, showing that states where incarceration went up did not simultaneously have decreasing crime rates. The study can't tell you what would have happened if that state had reduced incarceration rates. People who get cancer treatment are far more likely to have cancer than the general population. This does not mean that reducing cancer treatment reducing cancer treatment will reduce cancer incidence!
- notyourtypical 8y agoNot surprised at all. Born and raised in a country with criminal punishments a lot harsher than here in Canada yet the crime rate is 5-10 times higher.