3 ms·
What if their lawyer explained to them that removing the canary for a reason was likely to be criminal and they removed it preemptively? Unless you want to cit
by maxerickson 8y ago
What if their lawyer explained to them that removing the canary for a reason was likely to be criminal and they removed it preemptively?
Unless you want to cite a bunch of jurisprudence that warrant canaries actually work, I'm gonna stick on "who knows", even though I'm not a government shill (I'm more "pragmatic about who really has the power in that particular relationship").
- NullPrefix 8y ago>even though I'm not a government shill Let's just stick with "who knows" on that one too.
- viraptor 8y ago> What if their lawyer explained to them that removing the canary for a reason was likely to be criminal and they removed it preemptively? Then a nice solution would be to say "our lawyer explained to us that removing the canary for a reason is likely to be criminal, so we're letting you know we're going to remove it in 2 months to make you more sure we're not doing it in response to a current issue".
- cyphar 8y agoAnd people would have precisely the same primary reaction (as they should) but then would also get angry at SpiderOak for "poisoning the well" with doubts about the legality of warrant canaries. To be clear, as far as I know there is no legal precedent that says warrant canaries are a legal way of subverting gag orders (then again, the fact there is no such legal case even though Reddit activated their warrant canary could point in the favour that the US government doesn't want to try their luck in court).
- philipov 8y agoIt doesn't matter what kind of excuses they give. Once a canary is dead, everyone should behave as if the target has been compromised. That is what the canary is for, and once you sign it, you can't just go back. If you don't continue updating a deadman's switch, it doesn't matter if you died or not: it activates.
- rocqua 8y agoTechnically, this is why the canary had an expiration. This means they did not need to remove the canary, just let it expire and refuse to publish a new canary.