5 ms·
Absolutely. Musicians can feel latency as low as 1ms when playing a digital instrument. You bet your ass it matters to people used to immediate response.
by bitwize 8y ago
Absolutely. Musicians can feel latency as low as 1ms when playing a digital instrument. You bet your ass it matters to people used to immediate response.
- Gibbon1 8y agoI remember a friend editing tracks for a video. He was annoyed that the tool he was using couldn't align the drum track close enough, difference was plus minus 10ms or some such. I think the thing is you can't discern 10ms absolute but you can easily hear a 10ms differential.
- agumonkey 8y agomusic is surprisingly sensitive to the slightest differences
- jve 8y agoHmm, this got me interested. Found a tool which I can use to test myself what kind of difference do I hear: https://www.audiocheck.net/blindtests_timing_2w.php?time=5 https://www.audiocheck.net/blindtests_timing_2w.php?time=5 With some training I could achieve >95% confidence in discernig 5ms with my headphones.
- phaus 8y agoIn just a few minutes I was able to start identifying the difference between synced audio and a 5 ms delay. That's about my limit. I wasn't able to get the 2ms delay correct more than you would expect from guessing.
- Zelizz 8y agoI managed to get "76/100 (76%) — Confidence : 99.99%" for the 1ms test. I wonder if headphone quality makes a difference?
- phaus 8y agoI have a pretty good setup with a DAC/AMP + nice headphones. You might have a better setup but I think my hearing just isn't good enough. Age impacts the frequency range that most people can hear. That might be a factor here too. I'm in my mid 30s, are you younger?
- chronial 8y agoCan you give a source for that? My understanding is that we just identify latency and account for it. The human reaction time is orders of magnitude higher that 1ms.
- panuma 8y agohttps://www.researchgate.net/profile/Robert_Jack4/publication/326464649_Action-sound_Latency_and_the_Perceived_Quality_of_Digital_Musical_Instruments_Comparing_Professional_Percussionists_and_Amateur_Musicians/links/5b4f5fcdaca27217ffa1e7fb/Action-sound-Latency-and-the-Perceived-Quality-of-Digital-Musical-Instruments-Comparing-Professional-Percussionists-and-Amateur-Musicians.pdf https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Robert_Jack4/publicatio... This claims that for percussionists 20ms is too much but 10ms is not. As a bassist I disagree, and think under 5ms is acceptable.
- chronial 8y agothx, that's interesting to see
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Gibbon1 8y agoI had a meeting with a group that was looking into wireless game controllers. They said they really wanted <2ms latency over the wireless link because they didn't want the total latency to be more than 8-10ms. Because tween gamers could totally tell when the lag gets above 10ms. Which is all well and good but 12 year old boys start throwing the game controller when that happens, which causes higher failure rates. Which means more warranty returns.
- short_sells_poo 8y agoI think we have to distinguish reaction and perception. A musician or gamer might perceive <5msec latency and it might be jarring/disturbing for them. This is different to actually reacting to events in <5msec time.
- gmueckl 8y ago1ms latency, you say? With a speed of sound of 340m/s, this corresponds to distance between loudspeaker and ear of 0.34m. So, anything except headphones will add more than 1ms of latency. I get that the rhythmic nature of music enables precision at the scale of a few ms because musicians can anticipate these moments in time (reaction time does not apply). But I'm baffled by claims of sensitivity to delays less than about 10ms because these are near or even over the limits of acoustics. For example, when you do the math, you'll see that it is basically impossible for a large enough orchestra to play perfectly in sync. But a good orchestra can give the impression of a precise performance despite that. This can only mean that the human hearing is less precise than what people claim.
- purerandomness 8y agoThe speed of sound is a constant, so I'm sure the brain filters it out. What you can hear are changes in latency which get added to the constant time the signal travels to the brain.
- panuma 8y agoSpeed of sound in e.g. wood is 10 times faster than in air. So an electric guitar player with 3.4m cord to the amp can feel a latency of 1ms for low frequencies through the stage and his feet. Humans have more rhythmical precision with said low frequencies. Symphonic orchestras are not known for their tight rhythm.
- panuma 8y agoSuperior time perception for lower musical pitch explains why bass-ranged instruments lay down musical rhythms http://www.pnas.org/content/111/28/10383 http://www.pnas.org/content/111/28/10383
- machiavelli1024 8y ago>For example, when you do the math, you'll see that it is basically impossible for a large enough orchestra to play perfectly in sync. Why? The conductor keeps them in sync visually, so the only limit is the speed of light.
- frou_dh 8y agoMuch the same phenomenon as line-drawing with a stylus on a tablet screen. It has to be really low latency to not feel cheesy compared to pen-and-paper.
- rawTruthHurts 8y agoYour bet your ass that less than 5ms go unnoticed by serious pros in the business.
- aljarry 8y agoSome real-life tests disagree, saying 10-15ms is roughly the minimal latency noticeable by musicians, while 20 for "normal humans". Tests: http://whirlwindusa.com/support/tech-articles/opening-pandoras-box/ http://whirlwindusa.com/support/tech-articles/opening-pandor...
- nickjj 8y agoWith my old audio set up I had about a 12ms delay from talking into a microphone and being able to hear myself in headphones. It screwed me up so much from the delay that I had to take my headphones off when recording otherwise I couldn't put together a sentence.
- izzydata 8y agoThere is no chance of that. As someone who has played music games for 20 years with timing windows as small as around 15ms I can safely say anything less than 10ms would be imperceptible. It isn't about training and practice. There is just a physical limitation of being a human.
- phaus 8y agoAs far as listening to music and determining there is something wrong with it because you noticed a 5ms difference, I find that hard to believe. However, when given samples of audio with no delay and a 5ms delay. I, with no special talent and no musical training, was able to start accurately identifying the delayed audio almost every time after a few minutes of practice. The difference isn't imperceptible when it comes to a single noise when we are specifically told to look for it, but I would bet that its imperceptible when it comes to just randomly listening to music.