3 ms·
>Facebook is useless because the village idiot gets more say than the scholar, and that makes the content stupid. This misunderstands the intended use case for
by krapp 8y ago
>Facebook is useless because the village idiot gets more say than the scholar, and that makes the content stupid.
This misunderstands the intended use case for Facebook as well as demeans most of the people who use it as intended.
Not every social media platform is, or needs to be, about curating "intelligent" content, any more than the web itself needs to be about sharing whitepapers between university peers, or phone calls need to be primarily about business. The problem with Facebook, specifically, is that it's curated too much rather than not enough -- people just want to be able to form networks with their friends and share content within that network.
> but just imagine what would happen if HN had its own eternal September and all of reddit decided to visit
It used to be so common to accuse HN of "becoming Reddit" that it was mentioned specifically as something to avoid in the comments. And... there is a large overlap between the HN community and Reddit. A lot of the content that gets posted here is posted from Reddit.
I hate to break it to you but a lot of the intellectual elites here are also on Twitter and Reddit and Facebook and sometimes they share pictures of their food and cats. And there's nothing wrong with that.
Also, complaining about Eternal September on the World Wide Web is a bit like cancer complaining about lymphoma.