3 ms·
"I’ll go on a limb and say that design is more important than engineering" No it isn't. Let me explain. Design is incredibly important. No doubt about it. But
by auxbuss 16y ago
"I’ll go on a limb and say that design is more important than
engineering"
No it isn't. Let me explain.
Design is incredibly important. No doubt about it. But I hire designers
by the week, perhaps by the month. I hire them by the design. I have
longterm relationships with them. They are a core part of the project
but they are interchangeable, if push comes to shove. And I don't need
them engaged every day. I really don't.
Most companies are not Apple. Apple has design at its core because it
creates tangible products. I loath Jobs and all he stands for -- I
detest bullies -- but I saw an Air for the first time (years ago) and
had to touch it. Shiny. Hardware design is not software design.
Personally, I don't like the metaphor of "experience" that is currently
en vogue. I have never had an "experience" with a site or application,
but I have used them. They are functional things, designed for purpose,
to fulfil an objective. They are not an orgasm. I wish. They are do not
evoke a tangible emotional response. I have never been moved to tears,
even close, by viewing a webapp. I do not weep at Google's minimalism
YMMV. Graphical designs, as applied to computer application, are not an
experience. They really aren't.
I can buy that interface design. And I love to. I love the process, the
passion of the artist, and the attention to detail. But that's all it
is. And I can get it in many places.
But the skill required to build the infrastructure and networks of
complexity that satiates all the requirements of my business plan, and
things I have not thought of yet, and things I don't even know I need
yet, now that takes skill and experience that cannot be defined, let
alone hired by the week. That takes immersion and involvement. That
takes a large degree of dedication, foresight, and yet more dedication.
It almost take faith in the belief that unforeseen obstacle can be
overcome. All of them.
Rewinding, design is incredibly important, a central part of any
initiative that's outward facing. But top of the pile it ain't. And it
never will be. I can buy it by the hour. I can buy it off the shelf. I
hope I never have to.