3 ms·
"Today nobody learning biology or medicine begins with Darwin, Galen, or Hippocrates. But economics and philosophy still expect their neophytes to read with car
by pmoriarty 8y ago
"Today nobody learning biology or medicine begins with Darwin, Galen, or Hippocrates. But economics and philosophy still expect their neophytes to read with care the scrolls of ancient dead white men as if their words had been written on clay tablets by the gods."
Philosophy is more of a dialogue with great minds of the past and present, rather than some kind of "advance" or "progress" of the kind idealized in some views of science.
If you want to engage in a dialogue, it would be a good idea to try to figure out what the other people in the dialogue thought and said.
If you're trying to make better predictions, create more accurate models of the world, or build better bridges, you might not care what anyone else thought or said except in so far as they help you with your project. But that's usually not what philosophers are after.
Also, if you are ignorant of philosophers of the past, you are likely to reinvent the wheel or get bogged down in issues already covered at length by minds far greater than your own.
Finally, reading, analyzing, and discussing the philosophers of the past is great training in philosophy. It is in some respects analogous to doing exercises in mathematics, or maybe participating in a programming contest.
- gowld 8y agoTo call Hippocrates "white" is to be deeply ignorant of the history of racial divisions in societies -- which is forgivable for the average person, but not in someone making a specific argument about racial divisions.