4 ms·
"I don’t think that’s what killed Usenet. What killed it was UI." Nah. It wasn't the UI. It was developers and corporations chasing the new shiny, which was
by pmoriarty 8y ago
"I don’t think that’s what killed Usenet. What killed it was UI."
Nah. It wasn't the UI. It was developers and corporations chasing the new shiny, which was the web.
Any UI could have been built on top of Usenet, but instead everyone jumped ship and on to the web bandwagon.
Usenet also had a big spam problem, but one which was not insurmountable, as Gmail and other web mail providers have proven. Modern anti-spam solutions could just as easily be applied to Usenet to keep it as spam-free as most web mail is today.
Of course, now there is the lack of historical knowledge, as another poster alluded to elsewhere in the thread, but there's also a contempt for the average user, and a widespread belief that UI's have to be dumbed down for the average user. Web UIs could be just as powerful as Usenet was, but corporations such as Google, Reddit, and Facebook choose to cater to the lowest common denominator rather than to power users.
Also, unlike Usenet, with these corporate walled gardens, alternate UI's for them are rare. At least Reddit has an API, so at least there there's a potential for some powerful alternative UIs built around it, but the ones that I know of are still a pale shadow of Usenet clients from 30 years ago.
- ams6110 8y agoNetscape Communicator included a newsgroup interface that was just as usable as email. I don't know if that has survived into modern Thunderbird.
- interfixus 8y agoIt has indeed. I can read all the Usenet I want in my Thunderbird. Provided, of course, that I have a provider, and can find something still worth subscribing to.
- u801e 8y agoThere are a number of free providers out there. eternal-september.org is one that provides access to the text only newsgroups.
- kalleboo 8y agoUsenet was already dead by the time "corporations" like Facebook and Twitter came on the scene. What killed it was UBB/vBulletin/phpBB web forums. People who ran blogs with some traffic installed them for their community, it was easy for people to just click in and get started, and then you ended up with huge communities like gamefaqs and Something Awful (and car forums, collector's forums, etc etc). These then generated lots of content, which showed up in web search results. Then web forums in turn got killed by social media (twitter/tumblr/facebook) and reddit and withdrew to a niche.
- disconcision 8y agosomething i've never been quite clear on: were web forums killed, or merely eclipsed? social media brought many more people online; the demographics changed, by orders of magnitude. certainly the old stalwarts you mentioned have dwindled (though are still active), but while doing searches i will still run into active webforums on speciality topics; perhaps ironically i feel these are more likely for non-tech topics
- kalleboo 8y agoI agree that forums aren't "dead" - there's tones of very active forums in all kinds of niches. I meant more in the way that they're no longer where the largest growth is.
- flashman 8y agoI ran the kind of mid-sized forum that catered to an active community of posters and a casual community that showed up for topic-related content (i.e. from search engines). But because most of what we were sharing was either links to news elsewhere, or shitposts, there was no reason to keep using the forum once Twitter went mainstream. I think this was probably the case for many similar communities. If you are utterly massive, your forum is probably still alive.