7 ms·
Yuval Noah Harari extract: ‘Humans are a post-truth species’
- everdev 8y ago> The higher cause that allegedly justified the invasion of Ukraine was the preservation of the sacred Russian nation. I'm sure there were many reasons, but the one I heard was that Russia said it was committed to defending Russian speaking populations wherever they are and said that the Russian speaking population in Ukraine was being discriminated against it repressed in some fashion. Regardless of the primary reason, it seems these issues are more complex than a single primary motivating factor. For example, why Crimea and not all of Ukraine? Why Ukraine and not another ex-Soviet satellite? Why now? Why not earlier? I'm sure there were lies and disinformation, but I also think the issue is more complex than the author might be suggesting.
- pharrington 8y agoThe Crimean peninsula specifically provides direct access to the Black Sea, and in turn humongous economic and military access to southeastern Europe and Turkey.
- dogma1138 8y agoRussia has direct access to the Black Sea regardless, Crimea provides them an existing port they don’t want to give up.
- nyolfen 8y agoit's also ~90% ethnically russian iirc, and russia fought a very costly war with a lot of nationalist sentiment attached to it to gain control of crimea in the 19th century. these aren't realist school-type rationalizations but they are important context.
- dogma1138 8y agoCrimea has a strategic value to Russia its their largest warm water naval base, the rest of Ukraine is nothing but a liability. They can hold Crimea because it has a large Russian ethnic population and like it or not regardless of the reasons behind it a sufficiently significant portion of it seems to not to mind being under Russian control the same cannot be said for the rest of the country. The reason why Russia isn’t going to go much beyond Crimea is the same reason why Turkey never really tried to annex the Greek part of Cyprus it knew it cannot control it and it doesn’t want another Kurdish situation which this time would be also supported by another NATO member. There are a lot of reasons to why but none of them are really that complex. Russia’s movements in theater are the same since the early days of the Russian empire and are governed by geography the rest can be easily factored in by measuring environmental factors and Russia’s own capacity and capability. Syria as well isn’t that complicated, Russia didn’t want to lose an ally and their only port in the med and they as sure as hell didn’t want another NATO controlled zone in the region. Beyond that they also needed a “real” conflict to test the modernization of their military its the first time Russia has been employing combined arms with precision ground, naval and air based strikes in its operational history. Syria was a great excercise for them they got to test all their new toys on targets that the general public doesn’t really care about whilst Ukraine and previously Georgia had many more limitations due to geopolitical pressure.
- myth_drannon 8y agoAfter the coup in Ukraine and removal of pro-Russian puppet government and subsequent installment of pro-NATO puppet government there was indication that the new government will end the lease of Russian naval bases in Creamea(and possibly allow NATO bases)...
- DubiousPusher 8y agoThis is a point I frequently try to make among my peers when the topic arises. Right now, in the U.S. we're seeing people's information sources splintering. With people attaching themselves to sources that conform to their worldview. But if you go back to before the middle of the 20th century, hundreds maybe even thousands of newspapers ruled the day. With some of the most respected papers of our day churning out tabloid crap chaff in that time (looking at you NYT). Many were little more than party organs. So it's not now that's strange. It's 1950-2000, that's the weird time, where there were a few news sources that people more or less believed in. I'm not saying we're not losing something but we are probably returning to the more common state of the "news".
- swsieber 8y agoIt was a strange time because of government regulation requiring some sort of public service reporting, but I can't remember anymore detail that that...
- h4b4n3r0 8y ago>> Many were little more than party organs. Why “were”? They still largely are.
- kurthr 8y agoBut then isn't it OK to blame and shame those who have engineered and monetized the public loss? It's not just the loss of some Great Truth, but the loss of even honest debate and collective acceptance of facts, or universal disgust at obvious hypocrisy and lying. Spreading disinformation for profit (and allowing trolls for clicks) is a pollution of a public good. It's as classic an example of a Tragedy of the Commons as any other. Edit: I am also saddened by the loss of sarcasm and irony. Complexity must be replaced by simplicity again.
- tim333 8y agoI think its generally ok to blame and shame. Zuckerberg seems fairly ashamed of some of Facebook's failings and is hiring thousands of staff to try and fix things. You wonder a bit about people who are not ashamed, if there's some way to change the incentives.
- hodgesrm 8y agoAnother way of stating the article thesis that adherence to scientific method is more fragile than many people think. Scientific inquiry in most fields is driven by a relatively small number of people. It's easy to see from current debates on vaccines, climate change, and evolution how quickly their results can be ignored.
- AndrewKemendo 8y agoThis was effectively the argument of Paul Feyerabend in his book Against Method, which posits that there is an Epistemological Anarchism in the sciences broadly. [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paul_Feyerabend https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paul_Feyerabend [2]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Epistemological_anarchism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Epistemological_anarchism
- aldoushuxley001 8y agoLove Feyerabend. You don't by chance know any other people following up on his work?
- AndrewKemendo 8y agoI'm unaware of any, though I wouldn't be surprised if someone is. I haven't investigated it much however. He was pretty widely hated and derided, so it's not a comfortable path to take - thus, I expect few are taking it.
- aldoushuxley001 8y agoPointing out hard truths is never popular. Thankfully Feyerabend blazed a trail and made it easier for others to follow. Is Feyerabend still widely hated? Or just back in his day? Because many people I've met regard him as one of the foremost philosophers of science.
- AndrewKemendo 8y ago
- _cs2017_ 8y agoAccording to the author, humans need fiction to unite, and therefore persuasive fiction is far more powerful and successful than truth. So far so good. But then the author makes one mistake after another. First, he conflates the use of currency with fiction. Currency doesn't need fiction to function, it can be survive even if every human was completely rational and couldn't be tricked with fiction. That's because the mechanism that gives currency its value is game theoretic equilibrium / focal point. Then he starts complaining that bad guys use fiction. Come on man, you just explained that humans are inherently wired to follow fiction, so why are you blaming people for using it? The author also goes into political and moral arguments and starts taking sides. Given that both sides of any conflict use fiction, this seems out of place. Finally the author encourages people to read scientific literature, without explaining how to identify the rare thoughtful writing among the tons of fiction that academics write. Academics, after all, aren't stupid, and also follow the approach of writing fiction into their papers to make their work more impressive to the outside world and more appealing to journal editors. Overall, I'm very disappointed since the topic is important and deserves a better treatment.
- rpm33 8y ago> First, he conflates the use of currency with fiction. Currency doesn't need fiction to function, it can be survive even if every human was completely rational and couldn't be tricked with fiction. That's because the mechanism that gives currency its value is game theoretic equilibrium / focal point. Disagree. Currency exists because humans cooperate on a common medium of transaction. If cooperation didn't exist (via fiction), then the equilibrium wouldn't exist.
- _cs2017_ 8y agoThe author uses the word fiction in the strict meaning of untruth. There is no untruth required for humans to engage in cooperation. Even a very rational person, who doesn't believe in any untruth, may engage in cooperation if it is more likely to benefit him than hurt him. The author seems to not understand that there are reasons beyond untruth that can make this situation possible. crazygringo reply to my comment gives a specific example of this gap in the author's knowledge.
- silveira 8y agoVery hyped author. I read Sapiens and despite very interesting points at the beginning and at the end of the book regarding things nobody can prove or disprove now, the bulk of the book is very week. A long logical juggling to praise a lot aggressions and mistakes because "hey, it could have been worst".
- based2 8y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mythology https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mythology
- alexandercrohde 8y agotl; dr: 1. States that there is a common modern fear that this is a moment of unprecedented ignorance of reality (i.e. people worry about "post-truth") 2. Counters this premise by reviewing the history of very wide-reaching and fundamental political lies providing examples including Russian, Japanese, Chinese, and Israeli. 3. Cites the historical adherence to religion as another counterexample. States that people find value in guiding "myths" even if not fact. Likens Harry Potter to the Bible. 4. Quotes Hitler and Goebbles on how effective propaganda/lies are to get people to believe in a common cause. 5. Extends the point, by likening modern advertising to such lies/myths. 6. Examines whether the inherent value of currency can be seen as such a myth. Though of practical value at first, some grow to see it as an ends in and of itself. 7. Suggests sports is another form of myth. 8. Proposes an inherent conflict between honesty and holding power. 9. Clarifies that despite the history of myth and inevitably of dishonesty, that there is still value in differentiating truth from lie. 10. Proposes that for free news sources, one should be skeptical of the motives of those providing that information.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]