3 ms·
I wonder if adding a "layman abstract" after a typical abstract in the papers would help. It could state things that should be obvious to scientists reading the
by viraptor 8y ago
I wonder if adding a "layman abstract" after a typical abstract in the papers would help. It could state things that should be obvious to scientists reading the paper, but could prevent some mistakes when a random person reads it. Like "This is early research about a small number of people that X. We're not sure if Y. It doesn't contradict common knowledge Z or mean that Q is no longer true."
I feel like typical reporting of research could be improved this way.
- craig1f 8y agoThe layman abstract is basically what cable news has turned into their business. "Forget trying to understand this issue, let us explain how you should feel about it!" It will immediately be abused. Still, probably better than the current situation.
- bumholio 8y ago> "Forget trying to understand this issue, let us explain how you should feel about it!" Well... yeah. Because you stand no chance of understanding the issue, and there is a very high risk that you will develop irrational feelings that will lead you to do dangerous things. Take for example the flu effectiveness in elders study. The biased journalists summarized it as "flu vaccine is killing elders". It would have been harder to misrepresent it to such a degree if the abstract contained something like this: "Public health notice: the authors believe existing vaccines are safe and effective and strongly recommend people of all ages to undergo vaccination. This study is a scientific inquiry with the purpose of increasing that effectiveness for elder patients, and our current findings have no imediate clinical application. More specifically, we report no evidence that flu vaccination is a net health risk for the elderly."
- sethrin 8y agoThat doesn't sound like it gets quite as many clicks, and people tend to fund more exciting research. I'm thinking that this problem wouldn't exist, except for the perverse incentives. This is probably particularly true of the substance-hysteria research. If you do research to show that tea tree oil is completely safe, that leaves less room for follow up studies.
- analog31 8y agoI like this idea. A friend of mine wrote a paper and his university's PR department called him up to propose writing a press release, because it looked like it might be of popular interest. And my friend's first thought was to downplay the actual impact of the research, as it was a preliminary study. It got me thinking that maybe every paper should include a similar thing.