4 ms·
Failing to vaccinate your child is actually child abuse, and should be investigated and prosecuted as such.
by walrus01 8y ago
Failing to vaccinate your child is actually child abuse, and should be investigated and prosecuted as such.
- mcny 8y agoWhat do we do with these children? I admit my sample size is tiny but my anecdotal evidence from the few people I’ve talked to who went through the foster care system makes me believe in the meta that the majority of children are best left with their parents. I would rather require vaccinations for all children and remove a parent to have any say in the matter. I would also rather have everyone be opted in to become an organ donor upon death with no opt out possible. Sadly, I don’t rule the world.
- nickwalton00 8y agoWe dont need to make there no opt out for organ donation, all we need to do is make organ donation the default and it would drastically increase the number of organ doners.
- everdev 8y agoWhile I understand the numbers benefits of vaccines and their ability to eradicate diseases, here are a few points from a devil's advocate: 1. No medicine is 100% safe in all circumstances. Vaccines do have published risk of complications and while tiny are not zero and sometimes are greater than the risk of contracting the disease itself. 2. As a general rule, I don't want any government telling me what to put in my body or my kid's bodies. Why not ban sugar that leads to far more health conditions than some of these diseases? Why not force people to eat the government recommended ratio of fiber, fat, calories, etc.? Sure, people might be physically healthier but at the expense of freedom of choice. 3. The flu and common cold kills lots of people per year yet those vaccines are optional for adults while some are required for kids, why? 4. Vaccines are required for kids to come to public school in CA, but not required to go to placed where they're in even closer contact (sports, pools, etc.), why? While I think free vaccines, good education and honest dialogue are important, punishing dissent doesn't seem right. I think understanding that non-vaxers have legitimate concerns helps create a better solution than enforcement and blame.
- walrus01 8y ago> greater than the risk of contracting the disease itself. This is a circular argument. In G7 countries with highly developed economies and medical systems, the reason why the risk of contracting a disease like mumps, rubella or polio is extremely rare is because almost everyone is vaccinated against them.
- jacoblambda 8y agoI'll offer a counterpoint. Some people have extremely adverse reactions with vaccines. Those who have predispositions that can lead to extreme reactions should be able to opt out of vaccination because they may in rare cases be more harm than good. Now, most people should be vaccinated and those few that aren't should hopefully be protected by herd immunity. To say that the quality medical systems and herd immunity decreasing the risk of those diseases nullifies the dangers of adverse reactions is a bit unfair. To close, I agree that most everyone should be vaccinated and that philosophical beliefs are not valid reasons to avoid vaccination. I do disagree in that I believe that there are a number of rare situations where vaccination is legitimately more harmful than just relying on herd immunity.
- colemickens 8y agoHow does society reconcile this "all opinions are valid" viewpoint with the fact that anti-vaxxers are actively putting others at risk due to reduced herd immunity? It's not theoretical -- we have data that shows outbreaks of "cured" diseases in places with reduced vaccination rates.
- everdev 8y agoThe same way we do with other topics: guns, alcohol, driving. We'd be in less danger if no one did anything dangerous ever, but that doesn't leave much room for freedom. It's extremely frustrating to see people doing something dangerous you disagree with, but it's likely that we all do it at some point.
- 8y ago
- dang 8y agoPlease don't take threads into even deeper circles of hell. The community is already incapable of discussing this issue civilly, and upping the ideological ante makes the flamewar worse.