And I have written a simulation which proves her wrong, doesn't matter. I mean, when we deal with ambiguous questions like this a simulation doesn't really help

And I have written a simulation which proves her wrong, doesn't matter. I mean, when we deal with ambiguous questions like this a simulation doesn't really help since you had to add information not originally stated in order to write it. It just happens that most people make assumptions which aligns with this answer, but you could just as well make other assumptions and get another answer.