5 ms·
This article was really disappointing. It doesn't answer the only question I really want to read about: what happens when people break these rules?
by Waterluvian 8y ago
This article was really disappointing. It doesn't answer the only question I really want to read about: what happens when people break these rules?
- mpclark 8y agoFor it to work there has to be a relationship at stake. If there is, it works every time.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> for it to work there has to be a relationship at stake And for this to have teeth, you need to (a) have relationships with multiple reporters and (b) provide recurring value. The first makes it possible to close off a reporter who misbehaves. The latter gives everyone an incentive to keep that from happening. Journalist-source relationships are political. They aren't governed by laws, but tradeoffs and customs.
- CPLX 8y agoOr you can just hire a publicist that has a long term relationship. The effect can be similar.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> Or you can just hire a publicist Unless you’re in the press every day, this hasn’t been—in my experience—worth it. Better to pick the relationships and delegate managing the messaging yourself.
- ad_hominem 8y agoThey get hired by the New York Times? https://twitter.com/RealSexyCyborg/status/1025425088445702145 https://twitter.com/RealSexyCyborg/status/102542508844570214...
- hitekker 8y agoWow. I knew about Sarah Jeong's racism but I didn't know she deliberately screwed over a Chinese tech activist while working for Vice. When the NYTimes defends this kind of creature, it exposes them to justified outrage, certainly not limited to the right. Like, for example: http://nymag.com/daily/intelligencer/2018/08/sarah-jeong-new-york-times-anti-white-racism.html http://nymag.com/daily/intelligencer/2018/08/sarah-jeong-new...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- jwilk 8y agoCan someone explain what happened here? These Twitter threads, like most of them, don't make any sense to me.
- simcop2387 8y agoThis person did one of the best summaries of the whole situation that I've seen, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y0dkwwV_iaw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y0dkwwV_iaw I can't vouch too much for the veracity of everything in the video but there's nothing I know of that she got wrong. EDIT: Just saw that Wu has actually responded to the video in the comments too, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y0dkwwV_iaw&lc=UgxKQJHTXHv9bE88NmF4AaABAg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y0dkwwV_iaw&lc=UgxKQJHTXHv9b...
- cyphar 8y agoThe short version is that Naomi Wu was asked to give an interview to Vice. Before doing the interview, she asked that a few ground rules be followed -- as far as I'm aware the main one was that her relationship with her partner not be discussed (as far as I understand the concern was related to a conspiracy theory that Naomi doesn't do her projects herself -- and that her foreign partner does them for her -- which could cause massive political problems for her in China). Vice decided to ask her questions about it anyway, and included those questions in the article (and apparently Naomi didn't know they were going to include them). Naomi then went on to talk about how this was (in her view) a massive breach of ethics, and how it endangered her safety within China (something that she apparently explained to Vice before accepting the interview). Once the article came out, Naomi tried to get them to remove that section of the article and they didn't respond to any of her emails. She then went on to "dox" one of the reporters (though I have heard that the information she posted was available just by searching his name online). Sarah Jeong basically attempted to counter this criticism of Vice by saying that she has asked around, and Naomi's concerns are ill-founded (Sarah used to work for Vice, so you could argue that she isn't exactly impartial on this topic). And obviously most media outlets focused on Naomi's doxxing (which to be clear -- is something that shouldn't have been ignored) rather than the original situation with Vice. This evolved into a pretty big argument, and Naomi appears to have come to the conclusion that almost all western media is unethical. Later Vice apparently asked Patreon to close Naomi's account (as a response to her doxxing one of their employees), and Patreon followed their instructions -- cutting Naomi off from one of her sources of income for her videos. It's apparently very hard to get donations into China (crypto-currencies don't help because you cannot convert them into real money inside China easily). Hopefully I've explained the situation without letting my position poison the summary.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- goodJobWalrus 8y agoThe source will presumably deny, so there’s no point in breaking it? or The source will confirm it, but they’ll also let everyone know that you broke the rule, so as a journalist, again not in your interest to publish. If you are Trump, then sure, go ahead, why not.
- xoa 8y agoIf you (like one of reader comments on the NYT piece itself) are asking about what law is involved with this, the answer is "none". Nor, if you think about it a bit, could there be in the USA given the First Amendment. Once you voluntarily share facts and opinions with a 3rd party that information is theirs and they may legally disclose it as they wish. Even if there was a valid, written contract around it that would still be a matter of civil, not criminal, penalties and further itself subject to abrogation by public interest arguments. Whistleblower laws deal with power and retaliation against a discloser by organizational superiors and (in some instances and locations) the state. They are not about "journalists" (which isn't a special category) but about protecting the release of information in the public interest, and apply for everyone. They're not for recourse against reporting or revelation by independent parties though (in fact that'd be directly against the point of them). So basically what it comes down to is honor, reputation and future dynamics. It's about soft power human relations, with everything that comes with that. Obviously a reporter that develops a reputation for betraying sources will be unlikely to ever again get any sources, and the same for a larger news organization. Given the competitive nature of reporting, a news organization whose well of tips and sources dried up would suffer heavily for it, if not collapse entirely. Additionally, it's rare that critical off the record/background/deep background information is an end by itself. Rather, it's a jumping off point for investigation and corroboration by public sources and those willing to go on the record, and that is then what serves as the real core of the story. It is often the case that something critical is hidden more in the vast sea of noise and other information rather then through any particularly deep level of protection, so being pointed in the right direction and having investigators start asking questions and digging is more then enough. It's a complex dance of motivations on each side, but over time the equilibrium has generally ended up somewhat around what this article discusses in terms of ethics. Not just pure self-interest but even idealistic goals considered long term and simple morality/empathy tend to drive a respect towards keeping promises. However even then it's never 100% certain, and it's not just the occasional genuine ethical breach or scumbag either. It's conceivable even the most scrupulous reporter could come across something so important and time sensitive that they'd decide burning their career and other lives would be a price worth paying and then just report it regardless. Conversely sources by definition are also always taking some risk by not keeping something to themselves, and will have their own sets of motivations and calculations about whether it's worth it or not.