3 ms·
I think there are 2 ethical arguments in your message: a) Someone's going to the bad thing anyway, so the world won't be worse off if it's us b) I'll join the
by fulafel 8y ago
I think there are 2 ethical arguments in your message:
a) Someone's going to the bad thing anyway, so the world won't be worse off if it's us
b) I'll join the wrongdoing organisation in doing the bad things and affect change from within the cooperation framework
I think a) is quite hard to defend philosophically. We don't generally excuse a member of an actor just because the bad thing was done as a member of a group, either in everyday life (think raising kids) or in national law, or in international law.
b) would need a clearer and bigger counter-badness component with "the lesser evil" to even be arguably defensible, even then being a pretty dark shade of realpolitik.
- Leary 8y agoJust because it's realpolitik does not mean it's not ethical.
- beaner 8y agoI actually do not think A is the proper argument here. Google providing a restricted search service is not doing a "bad thing." It will be a product that helps people find what they are looking for, which is a good thing. At the same time, they are restricted from sharing certain information, a restriction that is applied blanketly to all of China's citizenry. Imagine that there exists a prison wherein any prisoner can escape by simply knowing the escape passphrase. One of the jobs in this prison is to walk around providing water to the prisoners, keeping them alive. Everyone in the prison is prevented from speaking the escape phrase, punishable by death. You are a water provider in this prison. You know the escape phrase. You know that by doing your job, more prisoners are fed more quickly and are healthier and have better lives. But you know they would have even better ones if they could escape. Would the moral thing to do to be to quit in protest and remove yourself from the equation, because you cannot speak the passphrase, which is a decision that ultimately helps no one? Or would the moral thing be to continue providing a helpful service that prisoners need, meanwhile having access to the prisoners and the wardens, and being able to push for the ability to speak? It seems to me that the providing of water and the ability to speak the passphrase are two separate things that you as a water-provider have the ability to do. And when you remove yourself from the prison on the absolutist moral basis, you leave the prisoners worse off in practical terms, for essentially no purpose. I think in Google's case, it is helpful to identify what is the water and what is the unspeakable passphrase. Water is returning benign results, and the unspeakable passphrase is (separate & distinctly) returning censored results. Providing water is not a bad thing. It is a good thing. It is not aiding the prison in hurting its prisoners, it is keeping the prisoners alive and healthy. The citizens are permitted health, and it is a good thing to help them have it. Providing benign search results is not a bad thing. It is a good thing. It is not aiding China in censorship, it is keeping the citizenry within quick reach of benign information. It is a good thing to help them have that. A bad thing for you as a water-provider to do would be to not provide water, or whack the prisoners with sticks. A bad thing for Google to do as a search provider would be to not provide benign results, or to develop tools for forcing the Chinese to have access to less information than they currently do. The providing of water is a good thing and is distinct and separate from bad things. Not speaking the escape phrase is not a bad thing, because it is not your choice. It is forced on you by the context. At worst, not speaking the escape phrase lets you continue to provide water. At best, while you're there, you can try to convince the warden to loosen up, possibly leading to more freedom. I think the point here is that given the threat of force, morality is not absolute, it is contextual. When your options are morality vs. survival (or knowledge/life-promoting things), then your morality must be re-evaluated, because survival (and life-promoting things) are the goal of any framework that is actually moral. Returning benign search results is a good/life-promoting thing. There is a large swath of search results which are very good for the Chinese to have access to, which enriches their lives, which Google can provide better than anyone else. This is the knowledge/life promotion on one side of the equation. On the other, many are holding an absolutist position that only complete uncensorship can be offered morally. They are holding adherence to the morality in a specific context (the US/free speech), above the actual goal of the morality, which is life-promotion. I argue that when a morality leads to the removal of good/life-promoting things in this way, it must be re-evaluated for the context, because it is no longer achieving its goal. We must see what parts of the morality we cannot apply because _it is not our choice whether or not to apply it_. We discover that within the context of the threat of force, it is acceptable to abide by that force, and provide a subset of results that is still helpful for people to have access to. Morality only applies to decisions you can make within a context. If you don't enter that context, you can't claim to be doing anything moral. And if you do, the things that are not your decision cannot be part of your morality. Given what remains, you do the best you can. This is why I think Google should enter China with a restricted search engine.
- xzel 8y agoI think this analogy/thought experiment breaks down because currently Google is not the water provider and instead has actively been sitting out of the prison and not playing the game, thus some amount of disapproval is shown from google. That is why entering is seen as negative, because it says to the world the game is okay. I agree that morality is contextual but the ever-present lack of Google search in China to me provided a strong message and is the most ethical.
- fulafel 8y agoI think arguing against a "complete uncensorship" morality is barking at the wrong tree here. There are various restrictions on free speech in all countries that Google operates in. At issue is collaborating with an authoritarian regime and overbearing application of censorship to prop up the regime.
- solidsnack9000 8y agoMaybe their argument is more in line with "harm reduction"? Just because we can't do the best thing doesn't mean we have to do nothing.
- confounded 8y agoHarm-endorsement, or harm-monetization may be more accurate terms.
- jpalomaki 8y ago>How do the Chinese benefit from that? If products and services from companies like Apple and Google are not available in the market, it raises the question why. More people may become aware that there are certain limitations which prevent these services from being used. Offering the censored versions means it is easier to think that things are the same as in other parts of the world - we even have access to the same products and services they are using. I'm not saying that people would not otherwise know of the censorship - they certainly do. I see this more as an awareness thing. When something is constantly on people's minds, they might be more active in trying to push a change. Of course, it is a bit hard to relate to this thing. Uber is pretty much the only example that I can come up with. In my local market, the taxi business used to be heavily regulated and Uber could not operate here. People having used to using Uber abroad were annoyed and I think that helped at least a bit in pushing more relaxed regulation.
- amaccuish 8y ago> If products and services from companies like Apple and Google are not available in the market, it raises the question why Having chinese friends, lot's of them didn't really know who these companies are. The absence doesn't make anyone ask questions.
- telcodud 8y ago> If products and services from companies like Apple and Google are not available ... Products from Apple aren't available in China?! Hasn't Apple made billions of dollars in China every year for the last few year?