2 ms·
The scheme creates the perverse incentive of traffic jams as a source of government revenue -- incentives similar to speed traps. Even better it's able to scale
by brudgers 8y ago
The scheme creates the perverse incentive of traffic jams as a source of government revenue -- incentives similar to speed traps. Even better it's able to scale to hundreds or thousands of imposed charges per hour, doesn't require staff, and individual drivers can't challenge it in court as would be the case with a traffic ticket. As a public policy proposal, it's a regressive tax designed to keep those without financial means out of the way of those for whom congestion pricing is but a trifle. Starting the sentence with "scientists" doesn't make it science. It is there to create an undeserved aura of inevitability to ordinary horseshit.
- CryptoPunk 8y agoExactly the same thing applies to the gas tax. This has the benefit of increasing the efficiency of vehicle commuting, which means less pollution, and less time and gas wasted sitting in traffic. Carpoolers will be taxed significantly less than single occupancy vehicles. Electric vehicles will be taxed just as much gasoline-powered ones. It is tax that charges people for the scarce public resource they use, rather than charging them for use of a private resource that acts as a proxy for use of that public resource. The biggest concern I have with it is privacy, but that could be addressed by consciously designing it to not disclose personally identifiable information (this could be done with zero-knowledge proofs).