4 ms·
>dynamic, fair toll for road use could reduce congestion. In addition to the explicit imprecision, in a significant range, demand will be inelastic and simply
by mc32 8y ago
>dynamic, fair toll for road use could reduce congestion.
In addition to the explicit imprecision, in a significant range, demand will be inelastic and simply result in higher tolls without commensurate reduction in traffic and will end up hurting those of lesser means.
- maym86 8y agoYep. Toll roads hit poorer people harder. Maybe there could be a credit limit that everyone (or just people of lesser means) gets by default and you only pay when you start going over it. Or maybe just build better public transportation.
- gowld 8y agoIt's not possible to build good public transportation after people have already chosen where to live, work, and build buildings based on the non-public-transit infrastructure.
- asteli 8y agoIt took a while for the suburban model to take hold of the United States, clearly it would take a while to re-densify metropolitan areas. I think you go too far by saying it is impossible. To use an Americentric, and worse, SV-centric example, consider when SF's BART was built. They trenched Market Street through almost all of downtown! Building transit even in dense urban areas is clearly doable with enough political will. Maybe I'm doing the typical HN thing and assuming that lots of people are like me, but I've been moving around the SF bay area, and being close to transit is a massive consideration.
- maym86 8y agoWhat makes you say that it isn't possible?
- wonder_er 8y agoAt the moment, everyone pays the same for roads, regardless of whether or not they use them. Charging only those people who possess the means to drive, AND those people who choose to drive, sounds like it could reduce the harms to those of lesser means. Right now, if I cannot afford to own a car and use my bicycle to get around town, I pay for someone else to use roads, because my taxes subsidize those roads. So, if we paid for roads not out of general taxes, but out of tolls, it seems like it could be cheaper for those who don't drive. Also, for what reasons do you suppose that demand is inelastic? I'm not sure what mechanism you're assuming is not sensitive to price.
- vageli 8y ago> At the moment, everyone pays the same for roads, regardless of whether or not they use them. > Charging only those people who possess the means to drive, AND those people who choose to drive, sounds like it could reduce the harms to those of lesser means. > Right now, if I cannot afford to own a car and use my bicycle to get around town, I pay for someone else to use roads, because my taxes subsidize those roads. > So, if we paid for roads not out of general taxes, but out of tolls, it seems like it could be cheaper for those who don't drive. > Also, for what reasons do you suppose that demand is inelastic? I'm not sure what mechanism you're assuming is not sensitive to price. Most people would be hard pressed to up and leave their jobs if tomorrow the cost of their commute doubled.
- maym86 8y agoThis is wrong. Tax is already tiered by income so people in lower brackets pay less for roads right now and richer people pay more. By narrowing the focus to people who have to drive on the roads and doing it in a flat way using tolls will hurt poor people the most if they have to drive to work. Having to drive to and from a job at a certain time is relatively inelastic especially for lower paying service jobs. With tolls the same money will be spread over fewer people in a flatter way.
- gowld 8y ago> Tax is already tiered by income Not in all jurisdictions. Sales taxes and gas taxes and license fees are not tiered by income. Property taxes are vaguely tiered by income.
- empath75 8y agoDemand is inelastic but more people could car pool to save money.