4 ms·
This is just so bloody predictable. Recycling isn't a new thing. It's been common "forever" to recycle paper and metals. But you had to keep stuff separate: ste
by mirimir 8y ago
This is just so bloody predictable. Recycling isn't a new thing. It's been common "forever" to recycle paper and metals. But you had to keep stuff separate: steel, copper, brass, newspaper, bond paper, etc.
But to increase participation in modern consumer society, commingled "recycling" became the norm. And it just doesn't work. Broken glass makes paper useless, because it damages machines. And once commingled recyclables go through the collection process, with crushing and shearing, separation becomes virtually impossible.
Anyway, the only hope is source separation. And that's problematic. Because most people don't want to bother. And because there are just too many categories. Too many kinds of plastics. Packaging with multiple layers, including paper, metal and plastic.
- samstave 8y agoThe real point I always see when looking at the problem is Packaging. Packaging should be required to be as literally minimal as actually possible, consuming the least amount of resources in every phase of the lifecycle as possible. Excessive packaging should be as illegal as it is immoral and anti-environmental. Inks, Paper, Plastic, Wraps, Ties, ALL of it should be as eliminated as possible. Think of the time, energy, resources (power, fuel, transport, machinery, engineering etc) all that has been put into the creation of waste.
- mirimir 8y agoI agree. Also, options for material usage ought to be limited. And one could require that every manufacturer accept return of all packaging. I'm old enough to remember when milk, beer and soda bottles were typically returned, washed and reused. The last time I lived in Mexico, that was still common, at least in some markets. But the other side of it is that modern packaging arguably reduces waste. Or at least, I've read that. Maybe it's BS.
- samstave 8y ago>But the other side of it is that modern packaging arguably reduces waste. Or at least, I've read that. Maybe it's BS. I find a good illustration on how this is not true is Christmas. Look at how much packaging waste is left over in your house alone from christmas. Now, thats consolidated to one day/event, but spread that out across billions of purchases and you can see that waste in packaging is still monumentally huge. On a % of waste for a widget, as compared to, perhaps the way packaging was previously made for a widget 20 years ago - perhaps its easy to make that argument that its less waste - but I doubt that as; The widgets today didnt exist then Everyone is trying to sell more and more widgets the widgets are made of more exotic and complex and numerous components etc..
- mirimir 8y agoTrue. I was thinking about food products. I've read that a major aspect of product packaging is to make shoplifting harder ;)
- HillaryBriss 8y ago> But the other side of it is that modern packaging arguably reduces waste. I've heard that too. I thought the gist of it was that it reduced the labor involved with handling, loading, unloading, protecting and stocking the products at retailers because US labor is expensive.
- philipodonnell 8y ago> Packaging should be required to be as literally minimal as actually possible It would be interesting to approach this as requiring all elements of a product not intended to be used as a part of the product to be composed of materials which all fall within the came category of recyclables so that they do not have to be separated.
- samstave 8y agoThis and requiring all disposable 'plastic' materials to be made of plant-based product. No more plastic clam-shells for example.
- ryanmercer 8y agoOr at least requiring them to be made of the plastics that wax worms and meal worms can digest.
- jimrandomh 8y agoThat would be extremely wasteful. That packaging is there for a reason; it prevents items from getting damaged. If you remove the packaging from 1000 items and one of them breaks, you've wasted a lot of resources on net, because most packaging is very cheap compared to the items inside.
- schiffern 8y ago>most packaging is very cheap ...in part because the manufacturer doesn't pay the cost of plastic pollution, or leached persistent organotoxins, or microplastics. Is the solution as simple as a tax on all plastics (funding ocean/land cleanup of existing pollution), plus a universal per-item deposit to ensure that future plastics get separated correctly and returned?
- zerb 8y agoI'm wondering how possible it would be to have garbage trucks identify valuable materials in trash as they enter the truck, so the city can fine someone who doesn't separate.
- milesvp 8y agoGood luck enforcing these kinds of things. States like Washington have constitutional privacy protections that extend to curb side garbage collection. The state, or an actor working on behalf of the state, can't look through your garbage. I know a number of lawyers here who are waiting with baited breath for the wrong person to get fined based on what's in/not in their garbage in Seattle.
- zerb 8y agoPrivacy, other people putting things in your can, previous tenants and perhaps other flaws exist. That's why I think it best it be automated and take more than one offense.
- nitwit005 8y ago> Because most people don't want to bother. That ends up being the only thing that matters. We have separate bins here. Just look inside and you'll see most people ignore it and treat it as 3 trash cans.
- krsdcbl 8y agoThese comments are the first thing that made me realize the US has one "recycleables" bin and everything recyclable is dumped in there. And it doesn't sound like a smart idea, i mean how the ... I'm a little lost for words.