3 ms·
> This is exactly what I was talking about, you consider that your atom has energy levels and then you plug in classical EM fields, sometimes that's good enough
by naasking 8y ago
> This is exactly what I was talking about, you consider that your atom has energy levels and then you plug in classical EM fields, sometimes that's good enough to get somewhere. But it can never be classical because there's no way to have energy levels in a classical atom.
And this is what I'm talking about: this conversation is becoming an ever-shrinking pocket of you claiming, "well that's not classical", or "that can't be done in a classical theory", and me demonstrating that it has been done, toy theory or not.
I have no problem with discrete theories, I have a problem with people claiming something can't be done when it most assuredly can.
As for your derivation of old QM, I don't see how this is relevant. You seem stuck in the mindset that "classical theory" means building off of some known classical theory. As I've been saying, this isn't necessarily true. My discussion of classical theories are about the class of theories with various properties that differentiate it from something like QM.
People working on Bohmian mechanics are perfectly familiar with the history of quantum mechanics, see [1]. This doesn't somehow negate the fact that Bohmian mechanics can be viewed as a classical theory that nevertheless reproduces the predictions of QM. And it solves the radiating electron orbit problem just fine. Again, you're stuck thinking about this like classical mechanics rather than as a different classical theory that reduces to classical mechanics in the limit.
[1] https://arxiv.org/pdf/1206.1084.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/1206.1084.pdf