5 ms·
>Again this dynamic is sort of terrible! In a perfect world you’d want clients and banks to develop relationships, to know and trust each other, to build mutual
by nabla9 8y ago
>Again this dynamic is sort of terrible! In a perfect world you’d want clients and banks to develop relationships, to know and trust each other, to build mutually beneficial sequences of repeated interactions rather than just trying to gouge each other in atomistic arm’s-length trades.
Why this should be the case? Ideally, you want maximally impersonal bulk markets for buying and selling assets. Finance industry should have smaller and smaller profit margins. Only those relatively rare cases where someone can provide value over others the trend is reversed.
- skybrian 8y agoI think you'd want access to such a market, but still want your accounts and user interface to be with a brokerage that would tell you whether you're getting a good deal on trades. Of course this could be entirely automated. Having a UI that clearly tells you what's going on and doesn't lie to you or use dark patterns seems pretty basic?
- nabla9 8y agoYou can't get good and honest advice from someone whose advice is tied for them making trade with you with a extra markup.
- jonknee 8y agoThat wasn't related to zero expense ratio index funds, but instead on the foreign exchange derivatives market. Matt's point is that the worst clients get the best pricing and the people you'd normally want to have as clients get the short end of the stick.
- nabla9 8y agoYes. But the worst client is only worst because he is price aware. The natural development in financial industry with increased automation is to make everyone the worst possible customer for the financial service provider and that's a good thing.
- jonknee 8y agoSure, all he's saying that in a perfect world you could give the best price to people you like.
- mLuby 8y agoA recipe for cronyism.
- toomuchtodo 8y agoSustainable financial service/investment banking businesses are based on relationships, not razor thin margins and excessive leverage between parties.
- PeterisP 8y agoIt seems a bit on the opposite - that it's natural to like/prefer customers who are suckers and will gladly overpay you significantly for no good reason.
- hammock 8y ago>the worst clients get the best pricing That's how it always is, in every market. Fact of business. Your worst customers are the most price-sensitive and the least loyal - but you can't turn them into better customers by making them pay more in a tiered loyalty structure, that's not how it works. They'll go to a competitor. Your best (meaning worth investing in) customers on the other hand, WILL pay more. That's not a bad thing. They're happy to do so.
- ambicapter 8y agoThere's got to be a way for trust to be financially advantageous.
- Spooky23 8y agoIt can be, but it needs to be for a service that offers some other value. The problem is that doesn’t scale — most customers don’t care.
- AlexandrB 8y ago>>Again this dynamic is sort of terrible! In a perfect world you’d want clients and banks to develop relationships, to know and trust each other, to build mutually beneficial sequences of repeated interactions rather than just trying to gouge each other in atomistic arm’s-length trades. This loss of trust has been happening across the capitalist landscape. Consider job security in the 60s compared to now for another example. As a consumer/employee I personally feel the frustration that's at the root of this - many companies treat their employees and their customers like interchangeable cogs that should be optimized, not like people at all. But it's clear that the same thing happens in the other direction as well. For all the complaints about the decreasing quality of air-travel, almost everyone I know chooses flights based on cost and time, not service. Walmart was able to drive mom & pop shops out of business because they could sell things cheaper, not because they offered a superior shopping experience. Perhaps the post-WWII era was a unique aberration. Happening after automation was advanced enough to make things pretty cheap, but before management science had discovered that hyper-optimizing every input and process was a great way to compete on price. Or perhaps this is the result of stagnant wages forcing people to buy from companies they hate because money is tight. Either way, it seems like relationships are becoming increasingly currency-driven and transactional - the human factor matters less and less in spending, investing, and career decisions.
- mmt 8y ago> For all the complaints about the decreasing quality of air-travel, almost everyone I know chooses flights based on cost and time, not service. Almost everyone I know does the opposite, but only to a limited degree. I think it's also more nuanced than equating "quality of air travel" with "service". I think it's true that the vast majority of people don't actually care how well they're served. Many do, however, care about physical comfort (as evidenced by willingness to pay for coach-plus type seats) and convenience. Convenience is, arguably, closely linked with time, which you mentioned being something people are paying for. However, time is at odds with cost in at least the sense that airlines are flying jets slower to reduce fuel consumption.
- lmm 8y ago> Ideally, you want maximally impersonal bulk markets for buying and selling assets. Finance industry should have smaller and smaller profit margins. Some people would consider a personal, friendly market more valuable than a maximally efficient one. Finance is a tool to help humans fulfill their values, not the other way around.
- cwkoss 8y agoWhat is a 'friendly' market in contrast to an efficient one? Do you a prefer a market where you get a worse price, but your broker smiles at you?
- komali2 8y agoYea, I do. Just like I prefer selling my car on craigslist "priced to sell" to avoid haggling. Or helping people move for free with no implication that I'm owed a favor later for it. Although I'm not sure we're still in "market world" at that point.
- orasis 8y agoHire a fee only advisor. This is a separate role from the funds.
- woolvalley 8y agoFinance feels like something akin to my electric bill, not an emotional good like entertainment or food.
- bscphil 8y agoAre you thinking of funds that don't have money in corps causing social harm (carbon, tobacco, etc)? It's not clear to me what you have in mind here.
- vostok 8y agoMatt Levine's articles should be read in a light, slightly irreverent tone.
- slavik81 8y agoThere may be costs to making things impersonal. Repeated interactions provide more opportunities to reward cooperation and punish defection, so the equilibrium point of a repeated game is often better than the equilibrium of a one-off game. Basically, it's sometimes more efficient to work with people you can trust. It's expensive to build protections that ensure people cannot betray you.