5 ms·
It is hard to agree with his conclusion that the market is unstable. The flash crash was a huge exogenous shock of unknown (at the time) origin and the market s
by yummyfajitas 16y ago
It is hard to agree with his conclusion that the market is unstable. The flash crash was a huge exogenous shock of unknown (at the time) origin and the market self corrected in a few minutes. The market did such a good job that the author did not even notice the crash until a specialist pointed it out.
If only all multithreaded programs behaved that well.
[edit: added parenthetical "(at the time)", thanks chr15.]
- chr15 16y agoIf people are actually interested in what caused the flash crash, it was a sale of $4.1 billion of E-Mini contracts by a single fund. Report of SEC finding [PDF]: http://www.sec.gov/news/studies/2010/marketevents-report.pdf http://www.sec.gov/news/studies/2010/marketevents-report.pdf
- yummyfajitas 16y agoTo clarify, I meant "unknown at the time."
- dpapathanasiou 16y agoWell, you would have noticed it if your order book had open limit orders on PG: a sudden drop and recovery like that would have cleared them all.
- gaius 16y agoOne thing that I think isn't getting enough attention is it wasn't even a Wall Street "master of the universe" like GS, just a relatively staid firm out on Main Street in the Midwest.
- salemh 16y agoFrom the report..and where much of the ludicrousness surround HFT exists: "Between 2:45:13 and 2:45:27, HFTs traded over 27,000 contracts, which accounted for about 49 percent of the total trading volume, while buying only about 200 additional contracts net... " While buying only 200 additional contracts...HFT algo's pinging the market with orders never placed :D
- yummyfajitas 16y agoYou don't know what you are talking about. A) You can't ping the market with "orders never placed." You can place orders which may or may not be filled. In this case, they were filled. B) They are talking about trade volume, not order volume. Further, "200 additional contracts net". Thus means the HFTs immediately purchased 27,000 contracts and later resold 26,800 of them to someone else. Lastly, your laptop can probably process 27,000 trades in less than one second.
- nomurrcy 16y agoThis really isn't what caused the flash crash. The SEC either doesn't have a complete understanding of what happened, or is omitting swaths of data from their report. Nanex did a much better job writing this all up, and weeks before the SEC published their report. http://www.nanex.net/FlashCrashFinal/FlashCrashSummary.html http://www.nanex.net/FlashCrashFinal/FlashCrashSummary.html
- nomurrcy 16y agoTo further clarify: 75,000 e-mini contracts is not an astronomical amount. Orders of this size are not uncommon. To really understand what happened one must answer the question: what are the market conditions we have created such that a normal sized order can cause such a dislocation? A lot of this has to do with the practices of the HFT 'liquidity providers.' This is a complex topic, but the flash crash demonstrated what a lot of people have been saying for years: volume != liquidity, the HFT shops generate volume, not liquidity and engage in some practices (quote-stuffing, sub-pennying etc) which serve to systemically destabilize the markets. (and overload the market infrastructure)
- vecter 16y agoJust a minor point, but I've never seen a 75,000 lot rip through ES in one order.
- nomurrcy 16y agoNo body just dumps all 75,000 in one transaction. The order is filled over a period of time. W/R didn't dump either, actually further analysis shows that they sold the majority of their contracts after the crash http://www.zerohedge.com/article/refuting-secs-lies-core-flash-crash-analysis http://www.zerohedge.com/article/refuting-secs-lies-core-fla... The blog here is zerohedge, but the data is from nanex.
- SHOwnsYou 16y agoI agree that his conclusion of instability is difficult and will offer the idea that of all the critiques of the stock market, instability is probably the least credible. A stock market with round the clock, instantaneous transactions is one of the most efficient markets that exist. Instability would suggest that it frequently allows for inefficient outcomes. A stock market's prices are determined exactly by buyer demand and seller supply. It corrects itself in the event of freak transactions (like the flash crash) and if it doesn't correct itself, that means the supply and demand have changed and the price of stocks nearly instantly reflect those changes.
- jbarham 16y agoIt's all very well to say that the market "self corrected" unless you lost a bundle w/ stop-loss orders that were triggered on the down-spike.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoVery true. If you made the problem worse by placing "sell at any price" orders, you lost money. On the other hand, if you (as many HFT's did) tried to buy at the bottom and push the price back up to normal, you made money. This is why the market tends to correct errors quickly. Fixing things == making money, breaking things == losing money.
- borism 16y agoNobody said people placed simple STOP orders. I think it's pretty obvious to even n00biest of the traders and investors that in such volatile markets as we had in last couple of years you should use STOP LIMIT. So all those people that wanted to protect their hard earned investments (incl. 401k's) at a reasonable level "broke" things and HFT "corrected" them!? In my world that's actually called stealing.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoFrom the comment I responded to: "...unless you lost a bundle w/ stop-loss orders..." If you placed stop limit orders, you didn't lose a bundle and you also didn't harm the market very much. If you placed a stop limit on Accenture at 40, you lost $1/share. That's a hit, but not a ridiculous one. That's the penalty for telling the market that Accenture should be priced at $40 when it should really be priced at $41. A lot of retail investors actually did place stop loss orders. That's why Accenture traded at $0.01 (note: those trades were broken). Bargain seeking HFT's and daytraders bought at $0.01, sold at $0.05, and quickly pushed the price of Accenture back up to $40.0 or so. The market will hurt you if you give it bad information. The worse the information, the more you lose. If you don't understand this you should not trade.
- 16y ago